All Forum Comments
Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 09:15
If you want hard critique, you can always say so when you post an image. Be careful what you ask for!
Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 09:11
I really like PU and I like to post pictures and get feedback (and when I have time, looking at other pictures and provide feedback). However - I miss somehow that people also say, what they don't like on a picture. My experience is, good feedback is great for the ego, but critical (AND constructive) feedback is great to improve the photographic skills. It was mainly critical feedback in picture forums, that helped me to improve my photographic skills.
I know from myself, how difficult it is, to tell somebody, that something in his/her photo is not ideal. You don't want to disappoint someone, you don't want to do it in a forum and you want to be unpolite…. At least, I often prefer not to comment at all, instead of saying, what I dislike at a picture. The problem is – when no one speaks out the negative things, how should I improve my pictures.
I don't want to promote rude or inappropriate comments such as “Hey – your picture is absolutely rubbish” what I mean is to give a very personal opinion why something appears bad and ideally offer a proposal, how to do it better. At the end, photography is a matter of subjective opinions – so when receiving such a feedback, a photographer can still decide, if he agrees or if he prefers the way how he originally made the picture.
As it might still be difficult to give critical feedback in a public category, here a proposal. There should be a category that is called something like “Hard but fair” (I am not an EN native – I am sure some of you might have far better name proposals ). The character of this category is, that people submitting pictures in it, want to hear 360° feedback – they want to hear, what others like but also, what others do not like. Those that give feedback ideally suggest how they would have taken the same picture, what they would have done differently to achieve a better result. This category would be a nice place for newbies (when starting with photography, you typically do certain things wrong and hearing critical feedback might de-motivate you – but in such a category you are requesting critical feedback, hence it does not de-motivate). It would also be an opportunity for more experienced photographers, when they have a picture, that they themselves see critical (that has something, that seems to be wrong, but you can’t figure out what it is), or it is a great category for very polarizing, provoking, unorthodox, artworks, or when an experienced photographer tries out new areas of photography (like his first macros, his first HDRs or tilt-shift or portrait pictures). Uploading it in this category ensures , that it will be picked to pieces and you can take these pieces, re-arrange them, replace some and suddenly you have a better picture
Just a proposal – if you don’t like it or think, it is not needed as you already provide critical feedback, also fine with me
Axel
Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 08:50
Comment by AxelLuther posted on Lens with the best bokeh at 13/09/2011 - 11:59
Hi Axel. I have a WG-1, although have not had it for long. I bought it to have something pocket-able and rugged, especially for climbing, when my hands are usually covered in sweat and chalk and a DSLR would be less practical. I haven't yet tested it a great deal - not underwater as yet, but I have washed it off after a climb in the shower with no adverse effects.
I took it out the other day in central London and here's a handful of pics. Firstly trying out some macro, at Potter's Fields just at the Bermondsey end of Tower Bridge...

and a bit of a crop of that shot:

Here's another to show a bit of DOF/Bokeh:

Overall I think the macro setting is very usable and it focusses VERY close - minimum focus distance is about 1cm (above shots were probably about 5 or 6 cm range. The camera is fitted with LED lights around the lens to assist without using flash, and there is also a ring which you can fit around the lens which serves to illustrate the minimum focus distance (and turn the camera into what Pentax call 'digital microscope') as well as being threaded so you can fit filters etc. (46mm i think). I was keeping the ISO down to 100 and ended up with a number of sharp shots and a number of throw-aways. Higher ISO may have helped to have more sharp shots. The rear LCD screen is pretty good although it was only when I opened the files on my PC that I could properly see how sharp the pics were (maybe that's my eyes!). At high ISO grain seems more apparent as you would expect but in fairness I haven't really tested it that greatly.
Then one or two 'normal' shots from a wander round the nearby development which has some eerie sculptures dotted around (I think they might be Anthony Gormley...? Or if not very similar), although firstly some of the flowers which the bees were enjoying:



again they are down at 100 ISO. All shots have had a little PP although nothing too 'radical'. Overall I think the camera is very impressive. Very rugged and very small. There are a decent number of customisable settings and I have no complaints yet. Off on holiday in September so then I shall be testing it in the sea (I hope), and am also going to strap it somehow to my bike and test the movie capture on a cycle around Richmond Park... Battery apparently is good for about 250 shots. I have noticed that it has dipped down to two bars on the power display much quicker than my K-7 does.
There are one or two other threads on here on the WG1 as well I think. Am sure others will have their own views.
Hope this helps!
Regards
Comment by AxelLuther posted on Experience with the Pentax WG-1 GPS at 14/08/2011 - 22:31
Comment by AxelLuther posted on WTB Pentax 18-250mm at 13/08/2011 - 07:43
I am using Pnentax DSLR since several years but some of my outdoor activities are either a bit to tough for this camera (like the rafting tours) or my complete equipment is a bit to heavy for high altitude mountain trekking tours. Hence I am looking for a solid waterproof camera, that still makes good pictures. I recently bought my son a panasonic waterproof camera but this one is no longer available. The new panasonic is more expensive then the Pentax WG-1 GPS but I also found some not very promising feedbacks in the web, about the image quality of the WG-1.
Does anyone here owns this camera and can give me some feedback about picture quality of
normal shots
under water shots
low light shots
macro shots
I really like the tough construction of this camera but at the end - what I really like are good photos and the camera should therefore have a decent image quality.
Thanks for any feedback
Axel
Comment by AxelLuther posted on Experience with the Pentax WG-1 GPS at 07/08/2011 - 12:23
I used a tripod-head combination for up to 7 kg gear and with this bundle I never had problems to find a stable stand for my K20D with 18-250 mm zoom lense.
If you are not a trade-poser - Benro might be an option......
Comment by AxelLuther posted on Cheap Tripod? at 27/07/2011 - 13:22
Nevertheless, your samples are fantastic.
Comment by AxelLuther posted on St Cross Hospital - IR on reworked body at 05/07/2011 - 11:55
Hi,
Tamron 72B SP 90MM F2.8 MACRO LENS ADAPTALL FIT pentax is for sale on ebay, auction ending very soon so if anyone could answer my questions I'd appreciate it.
Item number: 280702966252
http://cgi.ebay.ie/280702966252?ru=http%3A%2F%2Fshop.ebay.ie%3A80%2F%3F_from%3DR...
1. Is this a 1:1 macro lens?
2. Will it fit onto a Pentax K-7 or do I need to buy a seperate adapter?
3. Would you recommend this lens? My budget for a macro lens is €150 max. It'd be used for trying macro out, a bit of everything (mainly objects, not inscets). Ideally I'd like it for portraits too but don't think I'd find one within my budget.
These are the details the seller put up:
This is the 72B version, it comes with a Pentax P/Ka adapter but you can obtain other adaptall mounts to fit it to your camera. The lens has been well used & the exterior of the lens shows plenty of signs of wear, but it still works fine. Aperture works fully, focus is smooth & the optics are in very good condition. comes with caps
Thanks in advance for the quick answer,
Patrick.
Comment by AxelLuther posted on Need quick help on a lens that's on Ebay at 05/07/2011 - 11:52


I would agree with you.
The ephotozine site has a Critic Gallery, I think this is what you are after :
http://www.ephotozine.com/critique-gallery
There comments like 'nice pic' and 'good shot' are banned, and actual critique of a photo is required.
The Gallery here is simply for sharing, though a lot of us use it as a testing ground.