AxelLuther

Joined: 16th February 2010

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

AxelLuther
Pentaxophile wrote:
Would be interesting to put that to the test
that would be a nice competition

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 28/09/2011 - 16:44

AxelLuther
prsjnb wrote:
AxelLuther wrote:
greynolds999 wrote:
I did suggest, a long time ago, that we have an 'anonymous' upload for such a critique area. That way, no egos are bruised and the poster can choose whether to reveal themself after an agreed period.
hmmm some people have a signiture - when I see their pictures I very often know that they are from them.... so such a category would not be too anonymous
I think that greyreynolds999 suggestion is a good one and I imagine it wouldn't be too difficult to arrange for the ID/signature of the user to be removed automatically during the upload; either, as suggested, until they chose to reveal their identity or automatically after an agreed period for the submission of feedback had elapsed (e.g. 72h). Either system would be likely, IMO, to improve the objectivity of the review process.

A further refinement might be to have the uploaded images grouped by category, thereby allowing prospective reviewers to concentrate on images likely to be of direct interest to them.

Jon
With signiture I did not mean any technical thing - it is the style of some members that is unique enough to easily identify their work already in the small view

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 28/09/2011 - 16:38

AxelLuther
greynolds999 wrote:
I did suggest, a long time ago, that we have an 'anonymous' upload for such a critique area. That way, no egos are bruised and the poster can choose whether to reveal themself after an agreed period.
hmmm some people have a signiture - when I see their pictures I very often know that they are from them.... so such a category would not be too anonymous

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 28/09/2011 - 15:39

AxelLuther
johnriley wrote:
Yes, and here I tell you that I am also a judge, appearing in camera clubs/photo societies in various places.

The basic principle is that when somebody puts up an image they have invested some of themselves in it. It's an expression and it's not to be trashed. Let's celebrate and highlight the positive aspects first and enjoy it along with its creator.

Then it is certainly OK to suggest improvements and point out any weaknesses, but with courtesy. Cheap shots are not on the agenda.

If we enjoy looking at pictures and genuinely want to help, this process can be honest without being negative.
Hi John - that's why I tried to avoid the phrase "negactive" and called it rather "critical feedback".... I aggree with you, that most members here don't take a snapshot and post it in the gallery - however - I e.g. invested hell lot of time in someof my pictures and when I upload them I normally think they are good and then you read a critical feedback about whatever, strange composition, missing elements, oversharpening andandand, you go back to your picture and think - yep - he/she is right.... these things I simply haven't seen when I produced it - getting pointed to them, makes you more aware and this has a nice "training effect" - after a while, you won't make this "error" again....
I also recognized that since I started this thread, I received more criticial feedback or change proposals to my pictures compared to before and I must say - I like them - they help so much to sharpen the own skills.

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 28/09/2011 - 15:37

AxelLuther
dougf8 wrote:
Perhaps if you did some analysis and appraisal of your own works and tried to understand things first you would benefit from others comments more.

Simple stuff like what you feel is good in the image, what is the focus of the image, how the background helps, what elements of composition you used to enhance the image, what you wanted the image to mean etc etc

It would be nice to see this kind of thing first which might give people an idea of the level you're thinking on.

If you just want to know if you have a Sharp photo with the right exposure, it would become clear.
What I meant was not so much feedback on the basics (although - wen I see photos of abslute beginner, even this is sometimes needed....I had things in mind like - a not ideal or too agressive crop and/or ccomposition, a too heavy usage of some filterings (such as sharpening), a non-ideal viep-point, halos in HDRs, or also the fact that a picture does (for what ever reason) not transfer the message it should transfer.

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 15:35

AxelLuther
Pentaxophile wrote:
The constructive crit section has been suggested before, by Cardiff Gareth I think. I'm not sure about it, as people may think that photos not in this section should then be immune from any negative comment.
Thats a good point

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 15:25

AxelLuther
johnriley wrote:
When I said be careful what you ask for, I simply meant that if you ask people to be brutally honest, then be prepared for some biting comments.

It was light hearted.
ah ok - yep this I can imagine.... when you call for such feedback you should be prepared for everything

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 15:23

AxelLuther
japers45 wrote:
[quote:3496ace15f="AxelLuther"][quote:3496ace15f="dannyh"]Hi Axel,
quote]
When I post some images feel free to be BRUTAL!
Jaspers - great statement - please use the same level of brutal feedback on my pics (but the more brutal it is, the more make a proposa, what to change) - I aggree we are all big boys and girls - but same at my work place - a real critical feedback or even saying "this was wrong" is rather seldom.... the fear to be political incorrect sometoimes hinders us, to speak these things out.

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 14:49

AxelLuther
dannyh wrote:
Hi Axel,

you are so right. I posted the same comment on my own pictures after just this sort of welcome but only ego boosting feedback. So far ive had no response. There is also a member who quite often only posts smilies as comments on my pictures!!

I am as guilty as everyone else of looking at a picture and posting nothing, whether or not i like it or not. I do try however to encourage those new to photography and offer advice where it's needed(not that i don't need it)
This is another reason why I think a hard but fair category makes sense - when I go there to look at pictures - I am more encouraged to say something - just skipping or doing one word comments is not so likely)

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 14:32

AxelLuther
fatspider wrote:
I always try and offer constructive feedback on images posted on PU, if there is any aspect I think can be improved I will say so, and I would expect it in return.

I dont think theres anything wrong with anyone saying "nice" etc, many people are unsure of what makes a good image themselves but still want to offer their appreciation of other peoples work, and if it gives them something to say and be a participating member of the forum then whats the problem.
Hmmm it seems I was missunderstood - yes I aggree - it is important to say nice things as well - it is just a gut feeling that negative feedback is not happeining that often. If you look at the galleries and go to a picture that has a low quality (for whatever reason - sharpness, composition, lights, contrasts,etc.), it often has no feedback at all. I made similar experience in the fotocommunity.de - this is the biggest community in Germany but I left it as after a while, you either received no feedback or nice feedback. Some members gave constructive feedback but only some. Was just wondering, if this would be different in a specific category and the fact that ephotozine has such a category might be the result of the same observation they made there?

Comment by AxelLuther posted on 360° feedback at 26/09/2011 - 09:31

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo