Lens calibration - Focus Tune software

dpm
Posted 29/04/2013 - 07:48 Link
"I don't think teh increments can represent anything other than teh amount of micrometers the AF sensor moves by. Each lesne, focal distance, etc, will be different to how much this applies to a certain distance out of focus anyway"

hang on a mo, let's think about this...

AF sensor can't move, can it? Image sensor can't move fore/aft either. AF mirror- and therefore path length0 *could* move if the main mirror is stopped by a servo rather than a hard stop. Dunno if this is the case.

So what is fine adjustment *actually* doing then? The sensor is looking for phase match between different paths so one presumes the adjustment is selecting a different pair of sensing pixels at each site for our selected "best" focus.

Still doesn't really explain why a per-lens adjustment is needed IMHO. Anyone?
McBrian
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:07 Link
dpm wrote:
"
AF sensor can't move, can it? Image sensor can't move fore/aft either. AF mirror- and therefore path length0 *could* move if the main mirror is stopped by a servo rather than a hard stop. Dunno if this is the case.
My understanding is the the micro adjustment does indeed move the sensor back and forth relative to the lens mount flange on a per lens basis (or global) depending on your choice from the lens adjustment menu.

If you think about it, both the camera body and a lens have a tolerance stack, so the only constant between any lens and a camera body is the tolerance stack of the body, say all your lenses and camera both have a tolerance stack of ±0.05mm (and that's a very tight tolerance for a component stack), when you calculate that out using the lens flange as the datum there is an error of 0.2mm at max tolerance between the focal point of the lens and the sensor plane, that's a lot in a mass produced precision instrument.

There are other tolerances involved i.e. mirror box tolerances, focus screen position and tolerance, viewfinder etc. which will all have an input to what you see through the focus screen/lens so I can understand why we know have micro adjustment cabability in camera bodies and if a software solution helps to give me confidence that I've input the correct adjustment I'll go for it over my eyes any day.


Jak and Smeggy must have 20/20 vision, something I would dearly love to have
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
Edited by McBrian: 29/04/2013 - 10:16
JAK
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:14 Link
McBrian wrote:
Jak and Smeggy must have 20/20 vision, something I would dearly love to have
Not sure what you are getting at here.

John K
John K
McBrian
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:15 Link
JAK wrote:
McBrian wrote:
Jak and Smeggy must have 20/20 vision, something I would dearly love to have
Not sure what you are getting at here.

John K
Missed a sentance, might make more sense now
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
JAK
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:17 Link
Nope :
John K
McBrian
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:40 Link
I don't trust my eyes
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
tyronet2000
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:41 Link
I didn't know there was a word search puzzle on the back of Cornflakes boxes I'll have to change from Bran flakes, anything to help get better photos
Regards
Stan

PPG
McBrian
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:50 Link
Mannesty wrote:
JAK wrote:
Is the software camera specific?
No, but some Canon and Nikon cameras output their adjustment settings, Pentax doesn't, which means you can only use the shot by shot comparison analysis method.
Hi Peter

When you say "Pentax doesn't" do you mean that the adjustment setting 0, +2, -2 etc. didn't shown in the software?

I did a test with the software on my K5IIs and DA17-70 and the adjustment setting was listed in the second column of the imported images.
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
kh1234567890
Posted 29/04/2013 - 10:51 Link
McBrian wrote:
My understanding is the the micro adjustment does indeed move the sensor back and forth relative to the lens mount flange on a per lens basis (or global) depending on your choice from the lens adjustment menu.
Your understanding is wrong.
gartmore
Posted 29/04/2013 - 11:02 Link
Care to explain? Its such a blunt comment.
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
JAK
Posted 29/04/2013 - 11:38 Link
McBrian wrote:
When you say "Pentax doesn't" do you mean that the adjustment setting 0, +2, -2 etc. didn't shown in the software?
I'm pretty sure different cameras makes use different scales. I doubt there is any standard unit applied to these values so would be very surprised if, say, a Canon +2 setting equals a Nikon +2 setting equals a Pentax + 2 setting. So the values given by the software would not apply to a camera not incorporated into the program's database.

If you have to determine the focus points and input it into the program, you have already done the work and all the program is doing is to use statistical analysis to ascertain the best value which you'd probably already be aware of just by looking at the results you already have. Or in other words, blind you with science!

Just wondering, if the people who think this is a good idea, do you use some scientific method to determine what other values to use for other menu settings, say deciding a filter strength, or do you just look at the images and say that one looks best?

When I started photography, cameras lacked meters to determine exposure and I had to decide if it was dull, sunny, cloudy bright etc. and use my judgement to set the exposure. The film makers kindly incorporated a leaflet in the box to help with this. Then I had to guess how far the subject was away and set that value too. We seemed to manage most of the time. Now apparently, according to this thread, I have to go into a high tech lab with specific software just to setup the camera before I even press the shutter. I thought the manufacturers were supposed to do that! Phew!

John K
John K
Edited by JAK: 29/04/2013 - 11:53
dpm
Posted 29/04/2013 - 11:46 Link
The AF sensor is bolted to the base of the camera body. Nothing short of baseplate removal and mechanical adjustment is going to move it...
McBrian
Posted 29/04/2013 - 12:59 Link
dpm wrote:
The AF sensor is bolted to the base of the camera body. Nothing short of baseplate removal and mechanical adjustment is going to move it...
Nope, the sensor plate (oscillator plate) is not bolted to anything, it is held in position between the the front plate (permanent magnets) and the back plate by magnetic force (that's the simple explanation).

I'm guessing the adjustment is done by adjusting the resistance strength to the magnetic fields.
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
Edited by McBrian: 29/04/2013 - 13:08
McBrian
Posted 29/04/2013 - 13:06 Link
JAK wrote:
McBrian wrote:
When you say "Pentax doesn't" do you mean that the adjustment setting 0, +2, -2 etc. didn't shown in the software?
I'm pretty sure different cameras makes use different scales. I doubt there is any standard unit applied to these values so would be very surprised if, say, a Canon +2 setting equals a Nikon +2 setting equals a Pentax + 2 setting. So the values given by the software would not apply to a camera not incorporated into the program's database.

If you have to determine the focus points and input it into the program, you have already done the work and all the program is doing is to use statistical analysis to ascertain the best value which you'd probably already be aware of just by looking at the results you already have. Or in other words, blind you with science!

Just wondering, if the people who think this is a good idea, do you use some scientific method to determine what other values to use for other menu settings, say deciding a filter strength, or do you just look at the images and say that one looks best?

When I started photography, cameras lacked meters to determine exposure and I had to decide if it was dull, sunny, cloudy bright etc. and use my judgement to set the exposure. The film makers kindly incorporated a leaflet in the box to help with this. Then I had to guess how far the subject was away and set that value too. We seemed to manage most of the time. Now apparently, according to this thread, I have to go into a high tech lab with specific software just to setup the camera before I even press the shutter. I thought the manufacturers were supposed to do that! Phew!

John K
A scale is a scale whether it is +20 to -20 or +10 to -10 and yes the software does recognize the pentax scale of +10 to -10. The software actual measures the sharpness of each image in the set and reports what it believes to be 1: the sharpest image 2: the best average setting based on the image set statistics.
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
JAK
Posted 29/04/2013 - 13:36 Link
McBrian wrote:
A scale is a scale whether it is +20 to -20 or +10 to -10 and yes the software does recognize the pentax scale of +10 to -10. The software actual measures the sharpness of each image in the set and reports what it believes to be 1: the sharpest image 2: the best average setting based on the image set statistics.
Well you've clearly made up your mind that the way you want to go is with the software package so who is anyone else to say you should not do that?
I'd say to be absolutely certain with the result you'd need to repeat the checks for each lens you have under a range of lighting conditions and apertures and remember to change it each time you take a photograph depending on the lighting conditions and aperture used required by each lens at the time. Personally I'd only change the value if I had a problem and apply a quick fix as required. We're all different, thank goodness!

John K
John K

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo