All Forum Comments
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on Sandwich - visiting the place at 21/01/2013 - 23:20
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on Wanted: Samyang 8mm Fisheye at 13/01/2013 - 20:22
Firstly, congratulations... you'll have the most amazing trip...
Secondly, can't really comment on zooms, I'm afraid, but I'd definitely suggest taking at least one lens that's weatherproof... the weather in Patagonia is genuinely remarkable... it really can change on a sixpence... expect your DA*16-50 to come in very handy indeed... it's at its best when it's at its wildest...
I was there in November, just after they'd reopened some of the trails after winter... very cold, very wet, very windy and quite magnificent...
Enjoy
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on preparing for patagonia at 11/01/2013 - 11:56
Thanks very much
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on Wanted: Samyang 8mm Fisheye at 09/01/2013 - 11:50
Best
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on Lens Receommendations svp - wide angle zooms at 29/12/2012 - 21:48
From the landscape p.o.v., particularly useful for me to see that there is actually a very wide spread of opinion on this... seems to me depending pretty much on
a) personal preference
and
b) ultimate end use of the photograph in question...
Happy to say I'll be staying firmly towards the practical (as opposed to artistic) cloning end of the spectrum, and use it for dust spots/sea spray spots and the odd edge of frame/stray litter tidy up...
Best
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on To Clone, or not to Clone... at 26/12/2012 - 23:40
Both times, the suggestions were bang on (thank you bwlchmawr and Hullman), and cloning out the suggested object would definitely have improved the composition of the shot.
But I didn't do it because (rightly or wrongly) I was interested in preserving the integrity of the original. Tbh, I felt a bit guilty trying to improve on what mother nature had very kindly given me.
But it's got me thinking. And I'm interested as to what the consensus is amongst you all re cloning - particularly wrt to landscapes (esp given this year's LPOTY shenanigans) - and specifically as to what you think is typically acceptable re cloning both
a) practically
and dare I say it
b) philosophically.
So, in your opinion,
* What is it ok to change in a landscape photograph? Is it ok to clone out telegraph poles, people, animals, buildings, powerstations etc from images?
* Is there a difference between cloning out man made objects and what's naturally there eg a pylon vs a rock?
* What is it not ok to change?
* Are you happy to remove stuff, but might draw the line at adding stuff from another photo eg Would you swap in a sky from another photo?
* Anyone know what the old school film guys (eg Ansel Adams or equivalent) do/did re this? I know he did a shed load of dodging and burning, but cloning? And if he didn't (maybe because he couldn't), would he have done if he could?
I only bring this up as I've generally always removed dust spots etc, but never removed anything structural (posts, buildings, rocks etc). And I'm interested to know if this is a bit of fundamentalist loony position to take, or an accepted, if somewhat extreme, position. Or frankly if I should just get over myself and clone out whatever I like.
Genuinely interested in responses on this, so please don't hold back.
Thanks very much
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on To Clone, or not to Clone... at 22/12/2012 - 00:29
Best
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on Wide angle at 19/12/2012 - 14:23
Best
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on 2 Pentax manual lenses: M 50 f1/7 and M 28 f2.8 at 13/12/2012 - 20:48
Comment by thingsthatihaveseen posted on 2 Pentax manual lenses: M 50 f1/7 and M 28 f2.8 at 07/12/2012 - 21:42


1. Sandwich Bay itself... Massive beach at low tide... Costs £4ish to get there via private road...
2. Deal: nice beach huts etc
3. St Margaret's: just a car park by the beach, but quite an interesting spot and walks nearby
4. Reculver: gt old Roman fort
5. Dungeness: weird as you like old huts, fishing boats etc
6. Whitstable: old fishing town rebranding itself as trendy spot
Have photos from many of these on website below should you fancy a peek...
All the best