terje-l

Joined: 25th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

terje-l
Some time ago, on the Norwegian forum foto.no , I came across an article on Photo Critique by the Norwegian photographer and author Magnar Fjørtoft. The article caught my interest, and by permission from the author I have translated the article to English.

After experiencing a few "incidents" in the Your Photos section, where discussions about posted images turned to a discussion about photo critique, I think the article could be of interest for members on this forum.

The article can be downloaded from my homepage in Word format. I am not fully satisfied with the language, and I'm working on a revised translation, so any suggestions are welcome by PM.

Please let me know if you have problems with the link, or if the format is unsuitable for you. Send your email address by PM and I will send the article directly.

I don't imply that we should start using Magnar's ideas to the full in our discussions. But I feel confident that most of us could pick up a few pointers, both as critics and receivers.

Hope you find it interesting.

Comment by terje-l posted on Photo Critique - a tutorial at 27/06/2010 - 21:49

terje-l
Agreed, Bob. I know Mike is good, I just wanted to know if he's that good

Comment by terje-l posted on Common Tern at 27/06/2010 - 21:15

terje-l
Now, TT and Emma, I think you are overreacting. Nobody has shot these images down in flames - yet. Quite the contrary.

If I post an image here, I don't want comments like "fantastic" or "excellent". If it is good, I want to know why it is good. And if it isn't, I want to know what I can do to make it better next time. That is what photo critique is all about, imho.

Just to make it clear, I am just speaking my own opinion. And I feel sometimes that you are right, Emma, the site is getting ridiculous, but the other way around. Too many superlatives without explaining why.

Rant over

Comment by terje-l posted on In defence of the series at 27/06/2010 - 21:13

terje-l
As one who have never been able to catch a sharp shot of a bird in flight, I admire your work, Mike. My Sigma 70-300 APO DG should be capable enough, I guess it just takes practice, practice, practice.

Apart from a sharp shot, you even managed to place the bird in the right position. (Or is that a clever crop

Comment by terje-l posted on Common Tern at 27/06/2010 - 20:58

terje-l
While I do like the series, especially What the Lid Says and The Light II, I have to agree with George that we should reserve our superlatives for the real top shots.

This post, however, justifies the entry of multiple images, as they belong together. I don't thing it was this type of multiple photos that was attacked in an earlier post.

Having said that, I feel that no.2, The Forge, is too dark, or has too much contrast, compared to the rest of the series. But that is just my personal feeling.

Comment by terje-l posted on In defence of the series at 27/06/2010 - 20:52

terje-l
I like flower pictures, therefore this one appeals to me. The blue colour is nice and delicate. Overall a good portrait of a blue poppy.

Exposure seems spot on. However, I feel it lacks a little in sharpness.
At the same time I would have thrown the background more out of focus by using a larger aperture.

Comment by terje-l posted on Blue poppies at 27/06/2010 - 20:40

terje-l
Today I have been visiting an exhibition by the 2009 Hasselblad Award Winner Robert Adams. A lot of inspiration for landscape and urban photography.

Comment by terje-l posted on Another pointless thread at 27/06/2010 - 14:18

terje-l
The thread works just fine here, John, using IE8.

Comment by terje-l posted on Updated Guidelines at 26/06/2010 - 09:38

terje-l
Please disregard my first entry in this thread. It was out of line and totally unnecessary.

Comment by terje-l posted on What lens for full body isolation ? at 25/06/2010 - 14:28

terje-l
Gwyn wrote:
The OP was a useful link and we are getting a long way from it.
But certainly there must be room for some fun on a sunny Friday afternoon

Besides, I find several of the above posts to be more offensive than my story about the Scottish Genie.

I do find the ExposurePlot very useful, thanks to Dr. Mhuni for the link. (Un)fortunately, I don't possess enough lenses to sort out one I don't need.

Comment by terje-l posted on LBA cure? at 25/06/2010 - 13:40

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo