All Forum Comments
Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 03/12/2014 - 14:29
You want, you want, you want ... Yet you don't have it .... Is that just because all this new technology you hunger after is still really quite unaffordable ... Or are you only telling us the positives? Is there a downside to the system you desire? For example, apart from the body, what would the likely cost of a new lens collection be, or would you expect to manage on old glass and adaptors? Also, are there limitations to the modern EVF focussing aids depending on the type of lens fitted?
(I ask these questions of course as they apply to any similar system that Pentax might release in future ... And we might hope that Pentax could overcome any limitations ....
All good questions mate, which I'll try to answer below.
*** Note: This is a Pentax forum, but the question was asked by other Pentax users. ***
Why I don't have
I had two items on the shopping list this year:
A higher quality action camera.
For this I have selected a GoPro Hero 4 Silver, which now has excellent night time capabilities for the first time ever in an action cam. It also offers 'Protune' settings in video (and now stills pictures also) which gives a flat picture profile and ups the bit rate to Mbit/s. It also features 4k recording at a tiny 15fps, which is only really good for static landscapes, but of more use is 2.7k @ 24, 25 & 30fps which will give room to crop a 1080p image with no detail loss. Oh and it not only has a screen, but it's a touchscreen.
This is coming on Sunday, which is my birthday
Pentax/Ricoh equivalent: WG-M1
Assessment: Comprehensively beaten in most areas I'm interested in.
A better platform for video
For this I was looking at the Sony NEX 6 / A6000 type range.
I've decided to hold off on this because the A5100 came out and this had the newer XAVC-S video codec, which is not present on the A6000. Then there are rumours of an A7000 which will almost certainly add this video capability to the A6000 platform. It seems silly to rush this, and it also gives me time to see what Pentax offer. So no, price is not a factor presently. This stuff is available now if you're not interested in the newest video codec, and the price is very competitive, coming in at roughly the same as a new K-S1, just without LED's in the handle.
Pentax/Ricoh equivalent: K-01?
Assessment: Comprehensively beaten in most areas I'm interested in. Hopefully a new Pentax offering would address this. I think Pentax should release a new line of mirrorless lenses, like they have with the Q, and an official adapter to adapt existing K mount lenses to the new mount. That's just my opinion. Actually this is all just my opinion.
To answer the question on functionality:
If I went with the Sony I'd probably look to secure one native lens, to use the autofocus features, but then manually focus for video work anyway, using my existing Pentax lenses.
The focus assist aids are present for all lenses, with regards to focus peaking (adjustable for colour and intensity) and digital zoom. These match, but often surpass, what we can do on our Pentax's already in live view mode, and they are available via the viewfinder.
The focus features, such as autofocus, require Sony Lenses. They can work on Canon lenses via an adapter but the reports say that they area much slower. I wouldn't bother.
Some specific focus features, such as eye tracking and autofocus require specialist Sony lenses.
Major downside for me? It's not Pentax. I want to stay with Pentax. I'm not sold on the form factor of the small mirrorless cameras, but feel that they do mimic the earlier '60s and '70s film equivalents.
Anyhow, apologies if my posts have become too large on this topic.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 02/12/2014 - 23:36
What are the lottery odds out there in NZ Richard?
I'll tell you what I want, what I really really want...
I want to stay with Pentax. I want to stay with the bodies, but I want them to move with the times, producing devices that compete with the mirrorless styles that are winning the buzz wars, the sales and excitement. Some of that stuff can only be delivered on a mirrorless, but SO much of it is actually open to all manufacturers.
Another way to look at it is, if you have a live view capable DSLR, then you've already got mirrorless functionality.
I see a Hybrid View finder as giving the opportunity to keep both sides engaged. As has been pointed out, as soon as you put a lens on, it's not really any smaller, so I don't see weight as actually being a huge factor in mirroless. Plus sinking GPS into all DSLR's (to give free astrotracing to all) is a huge opportunity for a point of difference.
Right now though, you get the same APS-C sensor as a DSLR, 11 fps, active subject tracking, wifi and free phone app control, NFC and direct upload to facebook, an EVF, a flippy screen, and the chance to add a focal reducer to simulate FF fov/depth of field with all your existing Pentax manual focus glass, in a sony that costs £499.00 with FREE Delivery in the UK.
I'm not joking, Pentax/Ricoh have to do something more to remain competitive, as do Canon and Nikon.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 02/12/2014 - 20:34
Mirrorless benefits / differences are actually quite small, it's just that mirrorless developers tend to let go and go nuts with their implementations. This could of course be implemented on future DSLR designs, but the main two and then Pentax are just slow to offer this sort of tech.
By which I'm referring to EVFs for use during video mode, Near Field Communications, wifi, phone control apps that don't require a flu card to work, faster burst rate (Samsung NX-1 is 15fps, Sony A6000 is 11fps), Tracking autofocus across the whole frame, ability to remote trigger HSS flashes without needing one located on the camera itself, higher bit rates during video, options of electronic shutters etc etc.
By it's nature, mirrorless designs can adapt to nearly any brands lenses via cheap adapters. Pentax looked to utilise the K mount directly on the K-01 and missed this opportunity. Whilst the K mount allows the use of legacy lenses, a mirrorless design allows the use of nearly all legacy lenses, not just from the same brand.
Anyhow, the point is that there is a few points that are mirrorless specific, but there is an aweful lot that just happens to have been developed and released on a mirrorless body that could also be applied to a DSLR body, but haven't been. Personally I'd like a flippy screen weather sealed Pentax, with mechanical stabilisation returned during video mode, with an option for higher quality video, and with a hybrid viewfinder, so I can use optical if I want, or digital for when I want the focus aids that an EVF offers over optical. And so I can use the viewfinder during video. I'd like FF and I'd like an APS-C crop feature so I can use my existing APS-C only lenses if I want to, just at a lower resolution than FF.
And I want the focus options that mirrorless cameras presently offer, so I'm talking on sensor focus points, even if they're not used when in optical mode. No one else is doing that yet, combining the best of both worlds. New features pulling the best from the mirrorless devices, but merging with the body design, grip and optical capabilities of the DSLR.
This all sounds silly and funny and whingy I'm sure to some, but Sony have now released the A7ii which has a better bigger grip, is weather sealed, has sensor stabilisation and via mirrorless is compatible with a huge variety of legacy lenses. Traditionally you would have called that very much Pentax territory, but it's out there now and is FF. All jokes aside, Pentax have to do something different.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 02/12/2014 - 20:09
I wouldn't call that HDR. it's a method of making sure you've got a good exposure for both the interior and the lighting through window
People have been manipulating photo development and content for ages. Any time you move a stray stick out of the frame you're 'changing reality'.
Comment by richandfleur posted on I'm just waiting for the flak !! -or not!!! at 01/12/2014 - 20:06
Comment by richandfleur posted on End of Year Sunset at 01/12/2014 - 20:01
Video wise people want real stabilisation back, and higher bit rates. Oh and the ability to visualise audio levels, if you actually use use on board audio.
The rest is actually there in my opinion.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Great K3 review at 01/12/2014 - 05:54
Further to post above and to richandfleur's link, I'm not trying to claim the K-3 is anywhere near as good at high ISO as Sony A7, just observing that it's no worse than my K-5iis in my opinion.
Regards
David
You have experience with both, so you carry a lot of weight in these discussions.
I think the vibe was that the K-3 was no better that the K-5iis with regards to low noise/high ISO abilities, and that simply urked some who thought it would/should have been. The fact remains that the K3 has a newer processor and much bigger burst memory buffer etc. It's a different camera, with advances in some fields, but not in others.
Given the plateau of APS-C sensor advancement, I see either lower res offerings or a larger FF sensor type as the way forward in ISO ability terms. A certain A7s for example is in a league of it's own for the price. One can only hope that Pentax opts to emulate it's strengths in this ISO area in a subsequent product development/release. There are options to stay in the traditional DSLR formfactor, or to drop the mirror box, but regardless it has been shown that low light performance CAN be delivered.
To address your comments directly though, I think they're essentially the same. The noise appears to be different in nature, but fundamentally they're in the same ball park. A new approach will be required to deliver something with a significant advancement in this ISO specific area.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Great K3 review at 30/11/2014 - 23:27
This was an interesting comment elsewhere on the site:
Comment link
Comment by richandfleur posted on Great K3 review at 30/11/2014 - 21:58
I know there's a push towards less moving parts, especially with the new type of pump that's now appearing more and more, but personally I still prefer one with the traditional handling, sounds and mechanical vibrations that come with our current technology.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Full frame rumour at 30/11/2014 - 21:38



The A7ii has just been announced and has addressed the larger deeper grip and metal mount, among other things, as well as adding inbuilt FF sensor stabilisation.
ILC is a better term, meaning interchangeable lens camera. CSC seems to have defined the class but I don't much care for it.
Your thoughts on the EVF match my own Nigel, but i can only see that improving over time.
I'm still keen on a hybrid option if possible, where an EVF is displayed via mirror lock up ( as live via does now) for situations where the optical viewfinder is less than ideal. Best of both worlds scenario.