richandfleur

Joined: 3rd December 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

richandfleur
McGregNi wrote:
walkeja wrote:
richandfleur wrote:


conceptualising
read "conceiving", we are British not American. Another bugbear of mine.
Glad to have you joining in What do you think of my classification of the camera controls ....? will it help with the issue of 'photoshopping' when we debate it?
Agreed Nigel,

In this instance I used the term conceptualising, with reference to visualising a concept. Conceiving would fit also, but I felt conceptualising conveyed my intentions more suitably, and potentially more directly than conceiving.

I do hope my choice has not caused you too much distress, and hasn't prevented you from contributing further to the actual thread topic.

Use of the term link 1

Use of the term link 2

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 20:14

richandfleur
McGregNi wrote:
WB is one setting that is often claimed to be variable after capture in RAW, without quality loss.
That's my take on it, in that a WB suggestion is inserted into the RAW info and this is applied on opening the RAW file, but you are free to adjust it as required, without quality loss.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 20:10

richandfleur
MrB wrote:
McGregNi wrote:

...I don't agree with your characterisation of camera jpegs as 1 hour photos ... We do have quite respectable on camera controls for adjusting the shots...
+1

Also, 1 hour photos from a shop are not usually developed by the photographer, whereas JPEGs, particularly the large 4-star files from our DSLRs, can be extensively adjusted (although 'extensively' is rarely necessary) in photo software, including ACR.

Cheers.
Philip
I agree this is not strictly correct and want to make sure this doesn't derail the discussion.

Clearly you have far more control over the settings you want to apply in camera than you ever did with a 1 hour photo processing shop. What I was referring to though was that you have to make those decisions in place in the field, some of which are baked onto the final output. You're making those decisions before you've seen what is captured, and they are often harder to correct, especially if you're applying any in camera filters etc.

Nigel has alluded to this though, in that physical settings are harder to correct to appear natural than image forming software settings. Like I say, I'm not looking to derail this conversation with the 1 hour lab comment, just to put forward my take that image manipulation should be done later when you 'develop' your image, rather than in camera. This of course is central to my own use of the image capture tool and subsequent development workflow. Your results may vary as they say.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 10/12/2014 - 02:30

richandfleur
K10D wrote:


This may sound odd but I consider my K5 IIs to be in the same category as my *istD and K10D in that they are keepers as far as I'm concerned.

Classics in their own right.

Best regards
Agreed, was the K100d the first to have in body sensor stabilisation? That's a pretty significant step forward.

Comment by richandfleur posted on The K5 is no more... at 10/12/2014 - 02:22

richandfleur
johnriley wrote:
I'm glad to see you thinking about things Nigel. You might need different names for your terms, as we already have input and output used in a slightly different way.
If this is to genuinely cause confusion, then I'd suggest conceptualising this as pre shot and Post/after shot control options.

Pre being everything you are referring to as Input Nigel, and Post being everything you are considering as Output.

Pre is what you (the photographer) can influence before the shot is captured, and Post being what the camera handles from there on.

Much of this will then flow onto work flow choices. For me for instance I set my camera to jpeg + raw and use the jpegs for quick skimming and image selection. Anything important will be edited in a subsequent image manipulation software application. To what degree depends on what I feel is required. Anything not important is likely taken on an iPhone and is generally shared, uploaded to Facebook or sent via email or Whatsapp directly, with no subsequent image manipulation done.

I only edit the RAW file as I'm not interested in any image manipulation choice the camera made on the day, at the time of the shot. I use my DSLR as an image capture device only, and then develop the photo as I desire afterwards. In that respect my workflow matches the manual development of the film days very closely. I see in camera JPEG as being the equivalent to the 1 hour photo development of which I have no control over, so this is recreated on the iPhone now. I want my DSLR to capture the widest range of detail possible, which gives me the most image detail to work with in development. That's akin to shooting with a flat picture profile in video terms, so the final work can be colour graded to suit the overall tone requirements of the whole piece, without any camera decisions burnt in.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax Camera Image Controls vs Computer Editing at 09/12/2014 - 22:01

richandfleur
50mpCMOS wrote:

One also has to wonder... Are there people out there that are still capable of using full manual. I could even turn a meter completely off; not using one at all - even turn focusing off - and still get a publishable result a majority of the time
Agreed, with autofocus out of the picture, there are only ever aperture, shutter speed and ISO sensitivity to play with. Depth of field requirements are set via aperture, motion decisions via shutter speed and ISO based on what sensitivity you require to satisfy the selections of the other two above.

Throw a decision on noise in the mix, and where you want to centre the fixed dynamic range capability of the camera (metering) for your subject matter and you're there.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Great K3 review at 08/12/2014 - 21:32

richandfleur
cabstar wrote:
I still can't believe in this age of the smartphone that there still hasn't been a dslr with a built in smartphone similar to what samsung did.

This would do more for dslr sales than anything else.

Getting the images from dslr to Internet is far to long, complicated and requires more kit than necessary.

Imagine a dslr with a touch screen and android OS. The possibilities would be endless. Pentax are already half way there with the KS-1 add a nano sim slot and android and away you go...
I hear you and know what you mean. There are plenty of industrial devices that are equipped with mobile data connectivity. Those referring to cell phones and calls are somewhat missing the point. Android is an OS onto which any multitude of applications can be developed and run, though it's easy to see people only associating this with cell phone calling devices.

An example of such app development is available on some Sony cameras, where you can extend the functionality of your device by downloading additional apps that provide extra features. One I particularly like for example allows you to see long exposure shots developing in front of you on your cameras screen. You can then stop the shot when you feel you have enough light trails etc. It's nifty, and it's this type of thing that appeals to the 'cell phone generation' but also might have some genuine benefits to 'real' photographers also.

Providing an open platform to develop on definitely gives a good base that is likely to be seized upon by the developer community. Examples of why this is useful would include the Magic Lantern development on Canon bodies. This took what is a very mediocre offering from Canon themselves and unleashed the full potential of the hardware via full blown hacking community development. Offering the option outright upfront could see the awesome Pentax hardware adopted for use by a wider customer base who presently don't go near it.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Is this a new golden age for Pentax?? at 08/12/2014 - 21:25

richandfleur
50mpCMOS wrote:
Great photographs there Crossed-up!!



On a side note: I'm surprised that Pentax isn't taking a more obvious cross hair comparison at companies such as Nikon. Why not do a compare and contrast between Nikon and Pentax; showing items like cost and lack of WR in Nikons lens line??
Agreed on both points.

When I looked at replacing the K100d I did a pretty comprehensive assessment across the options and easily arrived back at Pentax (K-30) for the budget I had. 100% bright prism viewfinders, S/R included and weather sealing, plus 6fps and full HD video at 24fps etc etc. Easy win at the time.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Nice to know it works, Pentax does what it says on the tin... at 08/12/2014 - 02:30

richandfleur
I fully agree about chasing the largest possible market, and honestly that's not FF, unless you're looking to convert professionals. Sony's A7 series seems to be doing just that, which is no small achievement. Pentax's aren't there for this yet.

So, the next biggest market is the enthusiasts and new entrants. I keep seeing comments of the K-S1 being targeted at the smart phone market. I think that concept of the market is a good idea, people looking to step up from their cell phones. To be intuitive to them though, you'd be looking at things that resemble a smart phone, such as a touch screen and the ability to upload to the internet quickly, which means wifi.

And this is where traditional Pentax supporters clash with this proposal. You can't have your cake and and eat it too as they say. We the enthusiasts want Pentax to be focussed on IQ, ruggedness, and good ergonomics of the grip and optical viewfinder. Talk of wanting wifi or a touchscreen etc drives supporters mad with the I don't need that, will never use it, focus on what's important, don't change it comments. I personally doubt putting bright lights on a Pentax will be enough to draw cellphone users to a Pentax, given the physical size upgrade from a cellphone. So if they're going to target that customer group, then go all in and achieve it.

It's exciting times in camera developments. The K-3 came out late 2013, so it's a year old now, and the K-5 iis was released the year prior, so is now two years old and is discontinued on some sales sites now. Pentax must be releasing something in that range this coming year? Looking forward to what's coming

Comment by richandfleur posted on Is this a new golden age for Pentax?? at 07/12/2014 - 22:49

richandfleur
Chrism8 wrote:
Like number 3 and 5

Chris
As do I

Comment by richandfleur posted on A Shot in the Park at 07/12/2014 - 20:16

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo