richandfleur

Joined: 3rd December 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

richandfleur
McBrian wrote:


How many enthusiast photographers do you know personally?
How many amateur photographers do you know personally?
How many Soccer mom photographers do you know personally?

That own a Pentax?

Comment by richandfleur posted on Is this a new golden age for Pentax?? at 06/12/2014 - 21:28

richandfleur
I think Pentax makes a by deal about their flagship APS-C camera, and rightly so, but professionals don't necessarily shop by sensor size. So professionally the K-3 has to be compared to the professional FF equivalents of other brands.

The 645 range gets compared to both FF and MF options from other brands, as many brands don't do MF, so it compares much better than the K-3 does I feel.

Sensor IQ and ISO capabilities haven't really lept ahead in recent years, so developments are now mostly in areas such as burst rate buffer size, software functionally and body shape. It's interesting to see resistance to non IQ related add ons such as wifi. It's coming, so best get used to it.

Pentax does have a wide range of products when you rad a post like this though. Thanks.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Is this a new golden age for Pentax?? at 06/12/2014 - 18:24

richandfleur
andrewjlennon5 wrote:
A hybrid viewfinder would be possible on a DSLR, but there would be no way to have a traditional SLR optical viewfinder without the mirror box. You could go down the X100 route as you say but then you wouldn't be looking through the actual lens. Your average rangefinder user would of course say that this isn't too much of an issue.

will be interesting to see how this develops and in particular how Pentax address this if at all.
I'd propose a dslr with an evf as well. Yes, two viewfinders on the one body. Use Optical when you want to and flip up the mirror and use the EVF when you want to, such as in dim lighting where you can't actually see much through the optical viewfinder, or in video mode.

Just an idea along my best of both worlds line of thinking. And not mirrorless, just you chose when to use the mirror and when not to.

Hybrid is the elegant solution, but two would be the next best. Optical in the middle, EVF to one side.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 05/12/2014 - 09:07

richandfleur
thingsthatihaveseen wrote:


If Pentax can make a mirrorless machine (no idea how) with a proper ovf I'd be interested,
My take would be that if your DSLR has live view then they already have. Hence I'd be keen on a hybrid viewfinder, that allow's the user to swap between optical and EVF as required.

I believe the Fuji FinePix X100 has had a go at this.
Typically when I link to something non Pentax the post gets deleted, so you may want to google that to see an idea of what form this could take, should Pentax look to implement it.

Alternatively, brainwave time, why not have two viewfinders? One for optical and one for EVF, when the device was in use with the mirror locked up. Seems ridiculously simple really, especially when you consider that EVF's don't have to be placed in the centre like an optical viewfinder does.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 04/12/2014 - 22:37

richandfleur
K10D wrote:
Smeggypants wrote:
This video was posted before and is basically an advertisement for Fuji APS-C cameras
Never dawned on me when watching it but your right.

The XT1 is the modern digital equivalent of the MX with ME automation.

Best regards
Those cameras must all be rubbish as they don't have a chunky grip
Sorry, couldn't help myself, as that's normally the comment about the A7 series, and mirrorless in general, despite classic film cameras being essentially that same body design shape for years.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Why we don't need FF at 04/12/2014 - 21:48

richandfleur
McGregNi wrote:
So it may have limitations for large scale output then ... Would that not rule it out for a good number of professional purposes? The K3 presumably would be a better choice for some of those ...
Definitely. That's kinda central to my take on this stuff though. You pick the right tool for the job.

If you want to display on a web page, or album cover for example, or a magazine, then 12MP will be fine, as is 16MP or 24MP. If you want to print large posters, (not billboards), then you may need to step up to something with a higher resolution. Video is presently a 2MP image at Full HD, and 8MP at 4k, so 12MP is ample for that. On the flip side, any image you can take is better than a larger MP version you couldn't take because your camera wasn't useable at higher ISO levels.

With regards to this discussion, if FF is the right tool then use it. Seems really weird to make a thread about why we don't EVER need it.

You don't get a sledge hammer to drive in lots of little nails, but when you need to drive lots of posts in, then using a builders hammer is going to take for ever!

Comment by richandfleur posted on Why we don't need FF at 04/12/2014 - 21:46

richandfleur
McGregNi wrote:
It's not really true though, is it, that sensor size directly relates to size of possible output. I thought actually that was in fact resolution? Resolution and sensor size are different things. I believe sensor size influences other IQ factors also, dynamic range being a key one. Potential maximum output size is related to number of pixels, not directly to sensor size, I believe ...
agreed. Resolution determines the print size, other aspects influence the quality and dynamic range.
You don't need FF to print large, you need a high res sensor. The A7s is a 12 MP camera, and it's got my attention for reasons other than resolution.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Why we don't need FF at 04/12/2014 - 19:49

richandfleur
Algernon wrote:

You can't have a waterproof camera that uses adapters which don't even stop the lenses from wobbling. Lenses designed for one system won't work properly on another.
I guess you haven't seen the Pentax 1.4 rear converter.

I'll include a link for you here

This is an adapter that mounts between a lens and a camera, and it maintains the weather proofing nature of both. As far as I know it doesn't wobble. Change the mount on the end of it and bingo, you've now mounted a different lens to a Pentax camera. Think outside the square.

I see this discussion has now split into two threads, one here and one to rubbish comments here elsewhere. Nice.


McGregNi wrote:

But this should not really be about minor features like WiFi, focus peaking etc ... It's not really even about Pentax or Sony, because many of these things are equally possible on aDSLR or a mirrorless body. Those like Richard and Jon who are keen on the current Sony options are attracted to the various combination of features they offer.
Spot on mate. I welcome a mirrorless discussion, but that really limits the conversation to lens mount type, and the lack of a mirror box, which is only there to provide the optical view finder, and some focussing comments as I believe DSLR's use a different focus method to mirrorless.

Mirrorless uses on sensor focus points, and feature both contrast and now phase detection options, just like a DSLR. And they spread these right across the entire sensor, not lumped in the middle. This allows for tracking right across the image for instance.

A DSLR in live view mode is a mirrorless camera in essence. Porting this info to the EVF is required because there is no optical option anymore. You loose what Optical is good at unfortunately, but you gain where optical is poor, so there are tradeoff's to be made either way. Hence my hope for a hybrid solution to provide the best of both worlds.

Anything else that comes up, wifi, faster shooting speeds, electronic shutters, better video codecs, FF etc really isn't limited or related to mirrorless per se, it's just that we're seeing this tech deployed in those form factor bodies much earlier and quicker than DSLR's.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax mirrorless SLR at 03/12/2014 - 21:25

richandfleur
michaelblue wrote:


PS. How many people have taken how many photos over ISO 25,000?

Just interested
Not on my Pentax, and that's the point I think you're missing here.

Having low noise / High ISO capabilities allows you to shoot with faster shutter speeds and wider depth of fields than you otherwise would be able to. This is useful in situations where you can't directly control the lighting of a scene, such as street photography at night or band/concert work etc.

As I said elsewhere, geotagging is not the only use for GPS, and if included would allow for native astrotracing. This presents Pentax with a serious point of difference, and I expect most would see the benefits in Pentax having a stronger position in the market. (Heck a $50NZ phone has gps and wifi capabilities, it's not expensive and doesn't hurt your cameras photo taking ability).

App control. Mate, Pentax already offers this via flu card. This is nothing new, but I'm proposing they do it in a more standard way that doesn't require shelling out more money to another company to achieve this.

Seriously, nothing above relates to mirrorless form factors, and that was the main point I was trying to make. Lets avoid the hype and look to improve the DSLR as it stands.

I personally would love to be able to use a viewfinder during video work, and then I'd love some of the focussing aids that are available when in live view. You mention the "good old "nice bright clear" optical viewfinder of the past" and I agree with this, but it does make me think of two things:

1) There genuinely are times when an optical viewfinder is pretty useless. You use the viewfinder to frame and focus, but when the light drops that's hard, and when you're trying to focus with a narrow depth of field it displays differently than when the shot is taken - Hence the DOF preview button. Honestly, digital displays can be very useful for this type of work, and Live View is already on your camera. Focussing on the moon is massively more accurate with digital zoom and focus peaking than via optical.

2) Have you picked up 35mm cameras of late and looked through their viewfinders? That's the optical viewfinder of past that I want. Seriously they are massive and bright. Personally I don't get that buzz from a Digital optical viewfinder in the same way. Maybe I need to change my focussing screen out for a different type than factory...

Video is the other thing that people rubbish, but seriously, that's nothing new either, Pentax have been offering video capabilities since what, 2009?

It's an interesting rant, and clearly shows two sides of a coin on this issue, but personally I don't think it's got a lot to do with the mirrorless form factor.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Re: Pentax mirrorless at 03/12/2014 - 21:19

richandfleur
Typically larger sensors capture more light and are better suited to low light situations, and they allow for narrower depth of field shots for a given lens. If these are important to you, then FF will be of interest.

FF no longer means higher MP images as heck, even a cell phone can have higher MP images than most DSLR's. I agree that there is a lot of hype and marketing mixed up in the FF debate. I know Pentax get's ruled out of most pro conversations simply because they don't have a FF offering. Whether that is fair is another story, but it does happen unfortunately, which is ironic given Pentax off MF that steps it up again to a higher level.

So for me, same old story. FF does offer advantages, but if they're not of interest to you then there's not a lot to be gained, and potentially even some aspects to lose. They are different, arguing that they're not, or that FF, or any sensor size, doesn't have a place is silly.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Why we don't need FF at 03/12/2014 - 20:37

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo