All Forum Comments
Comment by richandfleur posted on Why video on a DSLR? at 23/12/2014 - 18:26
The camcorder is properly designed to do one thing very well.
For those asking why video on a DSLR? - The answer is all the same reasons you would pick a DSLR over a bridge or point and shoot camera. Interchangeable lenses, weather sealing, sensor stabilisation, investment in lenses etc. Sound familiar?! A DSLR (or frankly newer tech mirrorless bodies seem far more progressive and/or suited) offers the flexibility to produce results that match my creative vision. If your videos don't look good enough for you, that's not a valid reason to dump a feature others are capable of using.
Video is fundamentally lots of 2MP stills pictures, and it uses information from the light that the sensor receives. It's not some physical bolt on piece that enables it. It is software, much like the other software based features, such as sensor shift correction, intervalometer, in camera HDR etc? There is no such thing as a non video capable body as all you need is a sensor to write the pictures to a video file. There is no money to be saved here, and instead it would cost more to supply the 'purist' / OCD crowd a one off custom body design with no button or mode dial option to enable the inherent video mode available on all cameras.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Why video on a DSLR? at 23/12/2014 - 18:25
I've never used the video function on any of my DSLRs, I wish Pentax would release two versions of each camera one with video and one without for £100 cheaper
Look forward to the review. I'm personally keen to see what has progressed in video terms from the K-30.
Comment by richandfleur posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 18:07
I agree, the Movie SR is fairly useless. There is too much warping going on. When I stuck my K30 on a tripod and filmed an interview, the SR then began to think that head-bob was shake and I could visible see the frame shifting up and down when my subject was talking! Movie SR is only useful when one is filming a landscape on a tripod and there may be some wind interference. Otherwise leave it off. I have yet to try the SR in the K3 but I'm sure it will be a similar affair.
With Movie SR it only seems to be visual queues that are used to determine if shake reduction needs to be applied.
I have heard also that the live view display is stabilised mechanically, it's all rather confusing as to why they didn't keep the K-5 family approach to video SR, and some responses conflict. Most recently Pentax have openly blamed noise, so possibly the coding in the newer K-30/K-3 processors types responded differently etc?
Either way, keep it off for anything really important, and stabilise in post for more control. 2.7k resolutions would really help in this respect.
Comment by richandfleur posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 12:08
What software do you guys use for post production?
It's a very professional product, with a learning curve like photoshop I guess.
I can't comment on any others.
How does altering shutter speed affect things?
Eg how long the shutter is open for, which controls the amount of light the sensor receives, and the motion blur in the shot.
The difference though is that the blur of motion contributes to the feel of the video. Very crisp/sharp/no motion photos played back at 'movie' speeds look down right weird, so you are actually after some blur of motion.
Fundamentally though, full HD video is just 24 or 30 2MP stills played back one after another each second. All the normal stills concepts of composition and exposure etc relate to each of those photos. These photos are very much jpg equivalents with Pentax as they offer no RAW type offering in video mode.
Comment by richandfleur posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 09:15
The audio is ok but there is a lot of hissing in the audio at whatever recording level so I have resorted to recording loud and turning down in post reducing the overall volume which compensates for some of the hissing.
The camera's video low ight performance is pretty bad though and I tend to avoid shooting video above 800 iso which means I have to be wide open and at 1/30 for 1080p30. I would much rather be at 1/60 or even 1/100. It sufficed but in dark indoors the issues really showed.
Yep, Pentax don't offer much of a solution for low light video. The codec and bit rate is simply too low to allow for anything that can potentially be worked on in post production once light levels fall too long. I have found the video disappointingly narrow to work on in post, with little leeway up or down unfortunately. You simply have to get it right in camera as much as possible, which goes for anything really in general.
Disappointingly this (low light ability) was one of the main points picked up on the 645Z video mode, which had such potential with that massive sensor.
What is your final output frame rate and resolution? If you're after that filmic look, then you'd be targeting 24p, shot at a shutter speed of 1/50s You can play with this obviously, but it's a fairly well adhered to guideline. 24p also will give you slightly better low light ability than 30fps, that's mostly why I mention this.
You haven't mentioned stabilisation, specifically 'Movie SR' on these newer models you are reviewing. I think, in my humble opinion, that that's a good move (not to mention it), and it's also a good move to leave it permanently turned off. Quickly, it's warps the crap out of your footage, (in a non linear fashion, which means it's impossible to correct this in post). And this is highly disappointing, given this was potentially a massive point of difference over other brands, which you end up turning off...
Normally this would have been followed by a but I've since come to terms with the fact that there is no firmware fix coming for this (would have been oh so easy to have given an option in the menu) and zen like I've moved on
Comment by richandfleur posted on My thoughts on the K30 and K3 for video at 23/12/2014 - 07:24
Why do people go on about Sony it's only a dam Minolta rebadged and at one point you could only get them in dixons
With regards to lenses, yes they don't have many, but mirrorless opens up compatibility with nearly all lens types, including rangefinder lenses. More native lenses with come, but the fact is that they don't need many to still be able to offer an immediately useful range.
Comment by richandfleur posted on John Lewis at 23/12/2014 - 07:10
Comment by richandfleur posted on Boxing photos with DA* 16-50mm Published in local newspaper at 17/12/2014 - 20:02
Pentax have maintained that a flip screen compromised the weather sealed body.
Comment by richandfleur posted on K-S1 Wins The Camera Store TV worst camera of the year at 15/12/2014 - 21:34
go all-manual, to get the results you want
Dropping your camera is not a good place to start from though , but full manual means you're not asking it to do any thinking
Comment by richandfleur posted on k20 at 15/12/2014 - 21:21


From what I see, these people who use video seem to be complaining that "video is rubbish on Pentax cameras" and keep asking for better video - then go and buy a video camera! See RobL's comment above
Pentax has awesome hardware, but their software implementation of this feature needs only a few small tweaks to be very useful; at which point the complaining will stop. Stuffing up/going backwards with the sensor stabilisation from the K-5 family is one such example.