PygmyTwittle

Joined: 24th March 2006

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

PygmyTwittle
Undoubtedly, the features of the K10D look fantastic, and I am not trying to spoil anyone's enjoyment of their new toy before they even get it - I'd also be buying one if I had the money . I'm not saying that it won't be easy to use - I'm just interested in why, with digital, sensitivity hasn't just become a third and equal parameter.

I had a look at my old SF7 last night, which doesn't have a mode dial - you have the aperture ring on the lens (usually with an A setting) and an e-dial for shutter speed, which toggles in/out of Auto if you use the dial whilst holding a button - exactly as I described in my post above.
I haven't used it for ten years, but that must have been sitting at the back of my mind as an easier interface than 'modes' and a mode dial.

A camera can have sophisticated features like "sensitivity adjustable in 1/3 stops", without having to have a complicated interface, like Sv or TAv mode. The K10D already has the two e-dials - swapping the mode dial for a further e-dial for sensitivity wouldn't add any extra dials but would simplify the operation.

Really, MattMatic's reply illustrates exactly what I mean - "at least on the *istD". So I checked last night on my *istDS - the interface does let you adjust ISO to AUTO when in manual mode. I'd never actually taken a shot like that before - it fixes the ISO at 200 even thought the setting says AUTO. In fact, the manual does actually state that this will be the case for the K10D. But if you could have AUTO ISO in manual mode, how would it be different to TAv, that is what a meant in my original post.
The modes are unnecessary - why have a full manual mode in which you cannot adjust sensitivity easily (and then only in whole stops), but have a TAv mode in which you can manually adjust shutter and aperture but have auto iso which you can adjust with exposure compensation in 1/3 stops.
The K10D has the ability to adjust sensitivity in 1/3 stops, but you can't do it in full manual mode, just doesn't make any sense.

When you have just two parameters, you only need four modes - P, Av, Tv and M.
When you have three parameters, if you persist with the idea of modes, you really ought to have P, Av, Tv, Sv, TAv, TSv, ASv and M.
Much better to get rid of modes altogether - I have three parameters and for each, either I want to set it myself or I want the camera to control it - simple.

I know there are plenty of amazing photos out there which have been taken without the ability to control sensitivity so precisely, but if a camera is going to include such a feature (and I think that is a good thing), then it should be easy and it should be available in manual mode.
I'm going to give my completely unprofessional opinion and stake my non-existent reputation on this - there will be a dSLR which works the way I have suggested - I just hope it's a Pentax.

PygmyTwittle.

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Death on the dial at 20/10/2006 - 10:40

PygmyTwittle
I have been looking at the user manual for the K10D and, with the introduction of Sv and TAv modes plus ways of switching in/out of priority modes without actually turning the mode dial, I can't help but think that things are starting to get more complicated than they need to be. For example, what's the difference between Manual mode wih Auto ISO, and TAv mode? Well, alright, with the former you can under/overexpose by adjusting shutter/aperture (and I assume the sensitivity will only auto select one of the usual 100,200 etc) and with the latter, you get to use Exposure Compensation which I assume must adjust the sensitivity in 1/3 or 1/2 stops. But do you see what I mean? What if you have set your shot up in Manual mode and decide you want to underexpose by adjusting sensitivity?

Aperture, shutter speed and sensitivity are the three variables in exposure. Until digital came along, the only way to change sensitivity was to change film, and this seems to have restricted the design of digital SLRs for no reason. Even in the K10D, sensitiviy has not really reached equal status with aperture and shutter speed.

Since it has been suggested that Pentax might look to user forums for feedback/ideas, I thought I'd suggest the following:

Get rid of the mode dial. Have three e-dials - one on the front for shutter, and on the back, one for aperture and one (vertical maybe) for sensitivity). At the low end of the range, each dial would change to Auto. The sensitivity dial could be set up for 1/3 or 1/5 stop increments. For shutter, Bulb could be at the other end of the scale to Auto. The dials could be speed sensitive, so a quick flick would put you easily into Auto without having to spin all the way from the other end of the scale, or, if you think it important to be able to retain priority settings, have a single button which could be used with any dial, to toggle between Auto and the most recently set manual value.

And if you really must put all that scene mode stuff in, you can hide that away on a menu where ISO used to be!

What do you think? Anyone else been mulling over how to simplify dSLRs so we can spend more time looking through the lens?

PygmyTwittle

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Death on the dial at 19/10/2006 - 14:27

PygmyTwittle
Does anyone know whether these batteries are safe to use in a *ist DS?

http://www.panasonic-batteries.com/site/Europe/English/products/products_batteri...

I think this technology is fairly new, so probably was not available when Pentax wrote the DS manual (Lithium, Ni-MH or Alkaline only).

I see some of you have tried the Uniross Lithium-ion rechargeables. I normally get on fine with Ni-MH - just sometimes I don't plan properly and need to buy some power when out and about, and CR-V3's can be tricky to get hold of sometimes.

PygmyT

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Panasonic Oxyride at 07/07/2006 - 13:27

PygmyTwittle
It's not listed on the website and I don't know how many branches have them left, but my local Jessops are selling the *ist DS + 18-55 for £349.
Crikey.

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Bargain *ist DS at 05/07/2006 - 17:06

PygmyTwittle
I think the penny just dropped - the raw files are not affected by the camera setting for sRGB or AdobeRGB - this affects on-camera conversion to jpeg. So raw converters take the raw file, with its CCD-specific colour space with the wide gamut, allow you to do all the tweaking before losing any information, then convert to the destination space, preferably AdobeRGB if editing in PS or printing with Qimage, or sRGB if for display on the web.

Thanks for your help,
PygmyT

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Picture Window Pro and RAW files at 10/07/2006 - 15:19

PygmyTwittle
Matt,

I thought I'd try shooting in AdobeRGB this weekend.
When I came to use C1LE, I got a bit confused about the colour management. I can pick the Camera Model and a Camera Profile, and also a Destination (working) colour space. When you process the image, options include converting to the Destination (working) space. But how does C1LE know which colour space the image was recorded in? It's certainly not embedded in the .PEF file (bit of an omission that). That suggests that the camera profile is really a 'tweaked' colour space (most appications seem to use colour space and profiles interchangeably), say sRGB, and that if you record in AdobeRGB, you must pick that as the Camera Profile.

Have I got this right?

PygmyT

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Picture Window Pro and RAW files at 10/07/2006 - 10:24

PygmyTwittle
Matt, thanks for the info on WB.

Of course, I couldn't resist trying SilkyPix, since the trial version allows full product mode for two weeks - once I got used to the crazy menu duplication and rather clumsy translation to English, it does seem pretty good.

PygmyT

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Picture Window Pro and RAW files at 07/07/2006 - 14:01

PygmyTwittle
Yes please, I am interested in the other camera profiles which can be applied to *ist DS RAW files. I will send a PM.

I was planning on getting a Lee filter holder and ND grad set soon - there is a white 'lens' cap which goes on the holder adapter which apparantly can be used for WB. I've not tried the custom WB on the camera yet - think I'll take a look tonight.

I just downloaded SilkyPix to try also, although there seem to be quite a few things missing from the 'free mode' which I assume will be the one which ships with new Pentax cameras.

Assuming all goes smoothly for the trial period, C1LE looks like the best option. That's where you say "could've told you that and saved you all that time trying this and that'. Still, you gotta learn what's wrong to know what's right, right?

Thanks,

PygmyT

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Picture Window Pro and RAW files at 05/07/2006 - 16:49

PygmyTwittle
Matt, Liam, thanks for the info.

I tried C1LE and it seems to do a great job.

One thing I don't quite understand - With WB set to 'as shot', C1LE, BibblePro, PS raw plugin, RSE and Pentax PhotoLab all show a different colour temperature. Why is that? I know that the AutoWB camera setting will not do a perfect job and that some correction will be required, but it would be nice to know that the starting point is correct.

Also, with C1LE, the image will only display all pixels when at 100%/25% or at 400%/100%. When zoomed to 200%/50%, which would be a convenient size for previewing of the adjustments, it shows no more image pixels than 100/25. What's going on here?

PygmyTwittle.

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Picture Window Pro and RAW files at 05/07/2006 - 13:55

PygmyTwittle
I have been comparing various raw converters and photo editing applications including Photoshop CS2, Photoshop Elements 4, Picture Window Pro 4, Bibble Pro 4.8 and PictureMan 5.0 Pro, all of which are available as trial downloads. I am particularly interested in the quality of the raw conversion and arrival at the 'baseline' image.

If I open a raw file through Photoshop using the raw plugin, it looks pretty much the same as through Pentax PhotoBrowser or Lab (full monitor profiling aside). I see that the PS plugin applies some default values for contrast and brightness, and as per the Pentax software, you can apply different WB settings, including 'as shot'.

If I open a raw file in Picture Window Pro, it will read the Pentax raw format and perform some contrast expansion, but doesn't apply any camera specific adjustments. The loaded image at this point is similar to the one in the PS plugin Open dialog with the contrast and brightness at 0 and no WB adjustment. There is a colour temperature adjustment available from the Colour Balance tool, which I can set to the same value as indicated by PS 'as shot', and then adjust contrast and brightness using the Brightness Curves tool and end up with a good image, but there is still a colour cast compared to the PS image, which appears to be mainly a lack of red saturation. I really like the Colour Balance tool in Picture Window Pro and it is easy to remove colour cast from incorrect white balance, but is there a way to access the 'as shot' WB setting from the raw file?

Having compared the converted RAW images from Pentax PhotoBrowser with those from PS and Picture Window Pro, I'd rather not use the Pentax s/w, which seems to introduce some messy black edges with its contrast adjustment and leaves odd blocks where colour changes should be smooth.

Does anyone have any suggestions as to a RAW workflow for Picture Window Pro, which would apply the 'as shot' white balance without manual fine tuning on every image?

I would also be interested in any opinions of any of the editors mentioned above. I'm also about to try RawShooterEssentials from PixManTec; anyone used that?

PS Is it me, or is it incredibly hard to remember colour accurately?

Comment by PygmyTwittle posted on Picture Window Pro and RAW files at 04/07/2006 - 13:45

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo