ok thanks for the replies. In Silkypix I get no option to choose whether I am applying NR BEFORE or AFTER downsizing. That is fine as I am happy to let Silkypix do what it thinks is best.

But say I have a full size TIFF that has had no NR applied to it. I open it in Photoshop Elements and want to apply NR and downsize it to 800x800pixels.

Would it be best to apply NR at full size,then downsize the image.

OR Downsize the image first, and then apply NR.

I will try and shoot some noisy images and do some tests myself, but would be interested to hear others views first.

Welcome to the forum.

Jackie

What lens is it ?

The first image shows it is certainly sharp. I think you focussed closer on the second image, but I am guessing the wind is moving the grasses. You can use a hyperfocal point to try and get everything in focus if that is your wish. There are online calculators to help you or the lens itself may have a marking.

The last image in my opinion would be improved by losing the left hand trees and having the single foggy tree on the right in sight.

ps. I like the b+w one from batch 2

When it comes to sharpening I use a 2 stage process: capture sharpening in Silkypix, then USM after downsizing to JPEG. Sometimes I do the downsizing and USM in PS Elements if I have done selective editing on the image.

My question is: when is the best time to apply Noise reduction ? :

1. while the image is still full size, ie in silkypix or PSE before downsizing OR

2. After downsizing ?

Father

Don't take my word for it on the raptor. I am no expert on whether it is a kestrel or hawk.

I think you did very well in the waterfall picture in that case. I have the same aversion to carrying too much kit unless I am on my own and going specifically to take photos.

I am not a huge fan of macro...but I like these a lot.

Nice capture. If I may suggest a crop to remove the blown highlight on the left.

I like the shot of the kestrel (?) A slighsoftness, maybe could do with a bit more sharpening.

I love the way the second waterfall image is framed. The fall itself cuts the picture in two, or rather cuts it into 2 thirds and one third which make it very pleasing on the eye. Did you use a tripod for this ?

Well I have no idea then. You have done the best thing getting it sent back. My experience was good, I had my camera back in my hands within 10 days.

Well done Dr. Mhuni and all the entrants, and well done to Ralf for expert and very prompt judging.