mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
mayday wrote:
Andrew - are you pleased with your photos? If so, job done!
Quite so. But once displayed to others they may not have the same reactions as the photographer.

If your sole aim is to take photographs you like why show them to anyone else?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on A Misty Morning in Beaumaris at 07/06/2010 - 09:48

mikew
Of course everyone's comments are welcomed and I like to read them all as without doubt you learn a lot from seeing things through the eyes of others.

I think what concerns me and possibly some others is the unstinting and sometimes seemingly non-analytical praise given to what are on occasions pretty poor shots (not applicable in this case - gee I'm still walking on egg shells). It does no-one any good to say a shot is really good when there are clear technical problems - which is something more experienced members can comment on and probably offer some help as to how to tackle the issues. I know I have learnt a lot from members here and elsewhere who have been generous with their criticism and advice.

But here I'm just asking why the shots appeal - then I can learn and deliver better shots that appeal to more people (if that's what I want to do). Anyone is qualified to explain the appeal and we all have valuable opinions on that area.

Please don't let me discourage you from commenting and supporting others but equally let me wonder aloud why a shot works.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on A Misty Morning in Beaumaris at 07/06/2010 - 09:46

mikew
Well we are in the realms of taste but the effect jumps at me as being unreal.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Dreamy Steam over Glenfinnan at 07/06/2010 - 09:36

mikew
I have never heard any suggestion that Norton will allow an infection through when nearing renewal - hardly a recipe for getting someone to pay again surely?

Pre 2009 versions I would not have touched Norton as it was slow, inefficient, very obtrusive but they seem to have taken comments on board as 2009 and 2010 versions are fast and just get on with things only telling you when they detect an 'issue'.

But of course this is a very personal choice - however unlike Ray I don't trust my ISP to trap virus attachments etc. although they do have a very competent system, well they tell me they do.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Virus at 07/06/2010 - 08:46

mikew
George don't you feel that while subtle and sharp there is still that slight feel of being out of register? I look at it and my eyes go 'whoa there's something odd here'. HDR and moving objects must be a really tough task.

I do agree it has a nice feeling of getting on with things.

The best HDR I have seen was of an interior where there were exposures set for the windows so you could see outside, the main seating area and the darker corners. Very cleverly done and totally suitable - but static.

Comment by mikew posted on Royal Daffodill (HDR) at 07/06/2010 - 07:53

mikew
George Lazarette wrote:
I think this is a nice picture spoiled (for me) by over-enthusiastic photoshoppery.
I agree with George at this stage but disagree about PS in general, terrific tool which can be used and abused just as darkroom techniques like solarisation could be used well and in my case badly.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Dreamy Steam over Glenfinnan at 07/06/2010 - 07:49

mikew
Why would a machine gun approach make a good shot? If that were true then I would certainly do it. Does the machine gun mode carefully compose the shot for you?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Machine gunning captured animals at 07/06/2010 - 07:45

mikew
I used AVG Free right up the time it let through a nasty attack as described above. I would not recommend AVG any more and all I can say is that Norton 2010 has so far delivered the goods at reasonable cost. I suspect there are better products but the cost in footprint and money seems more.

I'm sure Glyn is right but the SPYBOT boys will give you very detailed instructions on how to get rid of an infection that will take a few hours, umpteen restarts and lots of downloads but will work and that's all I have ever used them for.

Comment by mikew posted on Virus at 07/06/2010 - 07:40

mikew
Anvh wrote:
K10D wrote:
[Maybe I should have posted the un-softened versions.
I like the softened ones it's refreshing then those sharpened ones you see all day, not that those are bad but you see my point i hope.

People need to be more daring instead of walking the safe pad where everyone walks on. Luckily this forum does provide more variety then others so don't feel like I'm talking to you.
With respect to your opinion Stefan my own flatly contradicts you in this case. There may be an argument for softening some images and some parts of some images just as a vignette can sometimes help. In this case I think the intention was to blur the background when that should have been done in camera. I think the OP has already he says he just 'will fire away' and then it seems apply PP to get an effect that you can achieve in camera.

This is where I start to agree with people who say they never use PP. PP is a tool but it's hard to rescue a dud photograph using PP. If it's not sharp then sharpening may disguise it a bit but it will not remedy it. If there is no selective DOF then blurring may disguise it but it's no remedy. Incidentally I am not saying these photographs are duds so I hope no offence taken.

Taking a photograph is a series of decisions and you have to live with those decisions right or wrong. I understand not every photograph has to be sharp and technically correct but it's got be good to carry 'issues'.

FWIW I think the elderly lady with no blurring is better than than the manipulated one. She is quite strong enough to carry a sharpish background.

Incidentally I will also take shots as I see them but rarely will I not take a moment to check the speed/aperture combination is suitable for the purpose or that I'll accept the risk inherent in the compromise. I have lost so many shots to camera shake or subject blur it depresses me - but they are simply duds.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on images from an istD at 07/06/2010 - 07:33

mikew
I guess what you say has some strength but I can't see that the first and last really do anything more than record - blimey I'm walking on eggshells here not wanting to give offence and it's not my strength! Blunt is my usual style!

They need something a bit more I feel to use the people in them or to use the main subject matter.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on A Misty Morning in Beaumaris at 06/06/2010 - 22:20

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo