mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
gartmore wrote:
Probably not the last word... link
Thanks Ken.

Short but very interesting especially '... if you have enough craft ...' which resonates as to date I generally lack that craft even when I do manage to visualise.

Comment by mikew posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 18/06/2010 - 17:22

mikew
Dangermouse wrote:
I can't say I've seen any serious rows or flame wars here.
Oh dear I think I can. I can't recall what happened in PB's time but I think there was a pretty fierce bust up over something.

The fights are usually pretty entertaining while they last and they invariably end in tears.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Any Interest at 18/06/2010 - 11:07

mikew
I agree with Tim's thoughts almost to the word. I did wonder if you could lose the block middle left but if you then it looks less 'grounded'. The background hasn't been kind to you as it's quite cluttered.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Little bridge at 18/06/2010 - 11:05

mikew
The second shot comment that it only shows in export. I have had a similar experience, lots of PP which looks OK until save as JPEG or something then it goes 'funny'. I must get a good example and ask my mentors about this.

That lighting would be a huge challenge to anyone I'd have thought. I have wondered about asking my friend who does the lighting for a local amateur group if I could tag along and take some shots but I expect I'd be treading on someone's toes and they might expect me to do it well!

Comment by mikew posted on Waiting for No.4 at 18/06/2010 - 08:05

mikew
Emma - you can't let one inept posting from me shatter your self confidence or your enthusiasm. Don't look at that phrase taken out of context take the post by Bob and use that as a springboard.

There's nothing I can say to repair the hurt I have inadvertently given so I'm not going to try.

Mike

PS I rather like Doug's closing words in his last sentence. If tact was a prerequisite I would be long gone.

Comment by mikew posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 18/06/2010 - 07:47

mikew
Do you get the chance to have the actors pose for you or do you have to shoot in rehearsal or performance?

the over exposure was in the lighter coat I suppose?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Waiting for No.4 at 18/06/2010 - 07:38

mikew
ems82 wrote:
I was definatly not saying I have to be told I am the next AA or anyone else to feel encouraged. And why wasnt you analysing the shot that is in fact why we post our pics here isnt it??? I feel you was rude in the fact it was all negative saying I am no AA, AA would never have basicsally taken a poor shot such as I did. How was this helpful in any way? Surely you can see how this would upset anyone?
I have explained very clearly why I commented in the way I did - it was to draw attention to what I thought was an unhelpful critique. I couldn't really do that without the context in which it was made.

I didn't comment on your photograph because I didn't want to first and foremost and because I wouldn't have made such a good job of it as Bob did for example. I am not particularly interested in or good at landscapes so I tend not to comment.

Yes I get upset by negative comments - well what I think are unjustified negative comments. I have taken lots of photographs that I like and others are left cold by or dislike. I can cope with that and either disagree with their view or take on board their comments and grow.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 17/06/2010 - 22:05

mikew
ems82 wrote:
I am not denying the fact that good criticism is helpful but I feel Mikes comments do not help at all and actually come across and being rude. I no I am definatley no AA or anyone close but sometimes its nice to here that some of your work is actually not half bad.
Emma - in what way was I rude? Blunt yes, rude?

You were told you were comparable to AA and I refuted that with a rational analysis.

So, to offer you encouragement you need to be told that you are as good as AA? That makes no sense and I am sure that's not what you meant. Encouragement would be to say that yes the shot is good but there are areas that could take some improvement (and Bob has done this well) but I wasn't analysing your photograph.

As Ken identified my beef was not with your shot but with the suggestion that your shot was comparable to AA's work which in my view is unhelpful to our community and to you in particular.

Also I am not sure why you think I am any different to you. I take photographs for fun, recognise my huge failings and inadequacies and take great pleasure in striving to improve just like all enthusiasts. Like Bob I hope I have improved in the last couple of years - when I returned to photography I gave myself 2 or 3 years to get a solid technique so I could then move on to be more creative. I have progressed but when I see what other enthusiasts (and some professionals) produce I realise I still have a long, long way to go and I was probably very optimistic in thinking 3 years might do it.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 17/06/2010 - 21:41

mikew
I'm confused PP.

Are you suggesting that I should not have made the comment that I did or that Dr Mhuni should not have made his comment?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on The Lakes at the weekend at 17/06/2010 - 21:26

mikew
So you get more light onto the darker skin to balance it up?

@Tim - hmm well shiny isn't the first thing you think when you meet her. She is totally stunning, perhaps she's not shiny I am just dazzled by her beauty.

Comment by mikew posted on 50mm f1.7 M: More Wedding Pics at 17/06/2010 - 15:47

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo