All Forum Comments
Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #27- Comments - 'THE WHITE SHIRT' at 14/10/2009 - 22:34
If I'm working I sometimes have a CD on but when the going gets tough the cd stops going.
I rarely have music when PP or taking photographs.
In extremis (like when other bu88er has music on when I'm on site) I can zone it out. Like many people when I concentrate I simply don't hear anything around me.
A test match or parliament live I can sometimes cope with.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Background Music at 14/10/2009 - 22:33
Comment by mikew posted on Ebay Bargain at 14/10/2009 - 22:26
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #26 - Half and half at 14/10/2009 - 22:25
We've just had a cracking set of entries for the last fortnightly all taken within the last 14 days to a set theme - in this case 'half and half'. JR's weekly would give you lots of scope to capture a technically excellent shot and get his valuable feedback on it.
Just a thought.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on wedding photography. at 14/10/2009 - 22:13
Comment by mikew posted on Sharpest lens under £300. at 14/10/2009 - 22:08
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #26 - Half and half at 14/10/2009 - 22:06
Comment by mikew posted on Ebay Bargain at 14/10/2009 - 20:51
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #26 - Half and half at 14/10/2009 - 20:50
Now I have to mark it! As always just my thoughts and no offence meant if I am clumsy with my words.
Tony-O – Mussel Shell
Nice take on the theme. Nice colours and exposure, focus I think is good – did you use the unsharp mask after resizing? Maybe I’m too fond of it but I think this would look a little better with some applied. Nice composition, good light and dark – a good start for the entries!
Hyram – Peace elephants
Peaceful with this vibrant colour? I think not! It’s a very interesting use of colour and not one I’d think of. I like the use of the books and the topic of the books. Certainly half and half but very hard to judge or indeed comment on as it clearly a one off approach.
Matwhittington – Pomodoro
Lovely colours, exposure and focus. Nicely sharp where it needs to be. I’m guessing soft natural light all very good. Is it half and half – well I guess so. Maybe it would have been better to crop in on the fruit more to exclude more of the gaps between them – but then again maybe not.
Malo1961 - One half down, another half to go...
Nice take on the idea and it’s halves all the way. Book half way read, half way open and halfway up the composition. Lovely lighting, exposure and focus. Good and sharp. The question is how much do I like it as it certainly fits the topic!
Prieni – Gripping the flounder
Beautiful colours, exposure and focus. Clever use of split frames and surprising myself I don’t object too much to the drop shadow. It’s the gap between the two halves that makes this work without it then I think it would be quite ho hum. The background is I think real as it reflects onto the hand. Very good.
Glynm – Squash in two
Good use of two halves, spot on the topic. Nice colours and exposure, sharp where it needs to be and using a fruit that has a lovely shape – all swelling curves. There is texture and tone in the main part of the flesh which shows good control of the exposure. Possibly the way they tend to one side isn’t perfect, not sure. You must have cut with care.
DrMhuni – Half advertising/Half retail
Terrific street scene. Lots to look at, lots of human interest. Great mix of colours – perhaps you could risk desaturating them slightly. Beautifully sharp and clear. I like the idea a lot of this interpretation of the theme. The shadow in the foreground is a nuisance but is balanced off at the top. More people might have been better but that’s a different picture.
Thoughton – half young half old
Again a clever application of the theme and a nice clear photograph. Well exposed, good focus nice subtle colours. The composition has clearly been thought about with all those diagonals. Do I mind that the child’s face is slightly obscured? I don’t think so as the photograph isn’t about him (or her). Very clever and must have been hard to take in subdued light.
Father ted – Pomegranate
Good choice of halves well arranged, well exposed and focussed. Could be a little sharper to my eye but again that might be my failing. The main problem I see is that you can see the shadows on the white surface. This might be unavoidable or some reflective card held in front might have prevented it. Carefully and artfully arranged. Possibly the white needs to be whiter which I think you can do with levels or by masking round the fruit and just painting it all white.
Nathanever82 – Eyes
It is stretching it a bit in that it’s more of a pair than half and half. However, the guy I took the inspiration from would probably have worked with this. Well exposed, focus bang on, colours are powerful but not gaudy. I wonder how many people would have tidied the eyes up? Personally I know eyes have lines and stuff so I don’t care but so many eyes are photoshopped to perfection. Very strong and broody expression – just a matter of how well it fits the topic.
Belinda B. – Paired flight
Pretty much half and half – rather as with the eyes two making a pair rather than half and half. Lots of tones and good and sharp. I don’t like the shadows especially as there seem to be multiple shadows but I think it was probably deliberate. In that case just not to my taste.
Galoot – half moving half not
Hmm really pushing it in my view but it is half of one and half of the other so I guess it’s OK. Nicely done long exposure giving the water that lovely fluid appearance. The starbursts provide a good counterpoint to the glassy smoothness. I find the light blue in the background a little jarring but it does need something.
Darlene – Granny Smith
I like the way this has been cut and presented. It’s killer sharp and well exposed giving lovely colours. I like the dead black background no matter how it was done – very small areas that are possibly burnt out but nothing to bother about. The slightly off centre and rotated composition works for me. Nice.
Mecrox – Garden shot
I can see how this works half and half. I like the well controlled colours. Not easy to avoid getting burnt out areas on flowers in sunshine. I think I might have cloned out the reddish flower that’s out of focus as it does attract your attention a little. Good focus and good sharpness. Again very nice.
Lilly – My other half, a la half n half!
Very clever use of the theme and her other half (not better I note). An excellent study of an interesting face treated in a way that emphasises the character within the face. The almost gritty texture of the photograph is very good, the way the colours have been managed is excellent. The lens baby well I guess it did contribute something but not all that much I think although the effect on the necklace is very good.
Gartmore – Two halves of a wood
Once more a clever use of the topic not one that would ever have occurred to me. The colours are so subtle but I don’t really like the effect applied to the non brown trees. I do like the way the colours have been treated but not that filter. Exposure is great – is it as sharp as you’d want it to be? I wonder if the PP hasn’t robbed it of a little sharpness.
Results
Well it was hard work to choose although I think you will have guessed who the winner is the other places were really hard to separate and I mean really hard. I think that everyone deserves to feel proud of their entry as the standard is high.
First: Lilly and her other half – for me clearly a winner for imagination and execution
Second: Dr Mhuni and his street scene – for the vibrance and excitement of this vivid street scene which fits the topic in an imaginative way
Third: matwhittigton and the tomatoes which may seem an odd choice but those fruits are just so well captured, the skins are so smooth and well done and there is the very strong half and half theme
I’m not doing and highly commended as the list would be way too long, I hope no-one is disappointed just count yourself in!
This really was the toughest choices I’ve had to make for a competition and I am sure no-one will agree with all my choices! If anyone wants to open a debate I’m happy for that as I think I can support my choices and I’d be interested to hear what others think.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #26 - Half and half at 14/10/2009 - 20:34


Mike