mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
We got curves of varied types which is good – pity there weren’t more entries as you can always have fun with curves. As always the judging is all mine alone and I hope I don’t give any unintended offence nor let my prejudices get in the way of sound judgement!

Matwhittington – bench.

Benches seem an ever popular subject – been there done that! This one is a lovely shape but the image seems to need a little help to make the colours sing. I like the way that the bench snakes off into the bushes but of course that’s also part of the problem as the surroundings are too intrusive to let the bench assert itself. That gate is areal pain in the wotnot! It is a nice use of curves though.

JudithAnn – Bottled up curves

I really like this one. The repeated bottles and their curves are great, the colours are great the background isn’t so great. It needed to be white or black I think but a textured grey doesn’t allow the bottles to be the sole centre of attention. Flash was used and cast a shadow on the darned background. Personally I would have placed the bottles on a table or something well away from the wall and then tried my best not to illuminate the wall with the flash but even if I had I expect I could have avoided shadows. I like this shot.

Davidtrout – Bridge

Great sweeping curve right through an attractive sky with the strong radial lines. The exposure seems to be well managed as there’s plenty in the sky while the bridge hasn’t blacked out. Focus good, sharpness good but I am sure David has a better similar shot. I’m not sure what is not quite right about the composition but something’s not there.

Thoughton – Curves

There are curves in the image but it’s more about circles. Nicely shot and presented with a good clean black background. No blown out whites which shows careful technique. No shadows on the background! I wonder if it would look better with more DOF but how much more can you get given this is f13 already. The plane of focus is well chosen.

Cardiff_gareth – Watch

A very well taken photograph – very sharp and well exposed. Very well lit, I can’t decide if there are significant blown highlights or not so that probably doesn’t matter. Curves – well there are curves but I’m not sure they are the main subject it’s really a shot of a watch that happens to have curves I fear.

GlynM – CD Slinky

Clever shot. I assume it’s not just Photoshop work but I don’t care if it is. Well exposed, probably sharp enough although I’m not totally sure. The background is a good black, the varied colours are good and there are curves there that create the composition. Nicely framed in the square crop.

Belina B. – Curvaceous frost

Sorry that’s just not curvaceous enough for me! There is the one main curve but then it is subservient to the detail of the frost. Very well exposed and sharp allowing for the limited DOF. I find the large white thing bottom centre distracting and the split background seems to draw my eye as well.

Hyram – Abstract cured glass

The noise is a total killer for me. Given it’s already a tripod shot lower the ISO and get the quality would be my policy. I realise this creates issues with the smoke but I am convinced a shot like this needs flowing fluid tones and colours. The curves are great with one curve mirroring the next with that very bold main edge to the glass. The colours had every potential to be so lush and liquid. Great choice of subject but ISO 800?

Prieni – Sweeping through

Well we sweep through all right. I am hesitant to question this but those chevrons – do they add or detract to the composition? It looks better to me when I cover them up. I like the way the tilt accentuates the way the clouds are sweeping off into corner which could have been more pronounced with the 12-24 (which I think you have). The colours all round are OK but I am a little disturbed by the way the red acts as a halo in the further distance. I think this shows how a careful choice of time of day can make such a difference. I expect I would have chosen total darkness and then there would be less to hold the eye and draw it round that curve.

Aiki – Curves

No shortage of curves here – everywhere you look there is a curve except that top right corner which looms a bit. The lighting is the problem here and must have been tricky as I think this is daylight. All photographs are made through choices so it must have been a deliberate decision not to reflect some light into the darker areas on the left using card or aluminium foil. Yellow scissors – good or bad? I like the introduction of both the shape and the colour as they add contrasts. An imaginative shot.

Darkmunk – Winkle

Very well exposed except perhaps the small area at the bottom of the shell. We have a lovely luminescent colour at the top. The focus is good although limited DOF doesn’t help much. I find the composition to be very central and ‘upright’ – perhaps engineering it so that there more uneven boundaries might add to the interest. I’m not sure what the context is but I think it’s man made and this shell cries out for nature – a nice smooth rock say.

Dr Mhuni - Induruwa Curves

It’s just possible that the good Dr knows me a bit too well and knows which buttons to press! I said I wanted quality, sharp, good exposure and good technical quality and this just oozes all that. I am struggling to criticise any part of the technical side – the sky is a tad bright I suppose. Curves – yes there are curves. That broad sweep of the pool repeated at the front three times and then the further side of the pool curves again. The reflected palm branches curve. But the rails of the steps - what great curves and colours – the shot would be hugely diminished if they weren’t there. Looking at it again everything curves apart from the sun beds.

Darlene – Beautiful butterfly curves

Curves galore in all directions. The colours are good too with the lovely warm basic copper and then the brighter beads. The exposure lets us see and enjoy all these colours. I think it’s a pity to cut off any part of the butterfly – I find that there needs to be a compelling reason to crop of bits of a subject. The background colour is a bit pea soup – I think once again you could lift the butterfly away from its background and isolate it.

Hefty1 - The curves on the lens go round and round...

They do but they are really circles and while they are curves I don’t think this shot is about curves it’s about the lens and the lovely contrasts within its component parts. The exposure is terrific with just that one highlight that lifts the whole picture. The focus is weird as I can’t quite work out where it is. Hand held – probably camera shake rather than lack of focus then. I’m sure Hefty has a collection of tripods

Oppenheimer45 – Kitchen curves

To be sure there are curves but they live dangerously close to the bottom edge. I think with such a strong element as that handle it could be given more space at the bottom and perhaps less on the left. The background needs to make its mind up – is it black or not? I think it needs to be dead black which you can usually manage in post processing one way or another. I’m surprised it’s a flash shot as it lacks the tell tale harshness but there are burnt out areas. The subject is good the composition isn’t so good to my eyes.

Now the tough part who gets what! Once again I find it very difficult to separate the top few and there is no obvious winner as there sometimes is.

I am going to follow my instincts and …

Winner Dr Mhuni for both sheer technical excellence but more importantly the beautiful balance of the composition and the elevation of a simple snap to a higher plane using the curves that abound in this image.

Second place Aiki and her curves and scissors
Third place Prieni for a very dynamic shot of what must have a gloomy road

If I started doing highly commended then I don’t think I’d ever stop so I’ll leave it there.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #30 - Curves at 09/12/2009 - 19:42

mikew
And closed.

It's been a long day so it's best I leave the judging until I have mellowed I think. Try again about 8pm.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #30 - Curves at 09/12/2009 - 18:02

mikew
I think he must have been a bit difficult but that doesn't excuse the behaviour of the security guards or police.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Photographer's rights gets a higher profile at 08/12/2009 - 16:55

mikew
Paul - It is the Vivitar VP-1 Varipower unit that replaces the thyristor.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Too cheap? at 08/12/2009 - 07:14

mikew
Yves I think you may be correct although I was told the Vivitar was a pretty powerful unit. I will look at the manual and report back.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Too cheap? at 08/12/2009 - 07:12

mikew
That's not my wife has told me

Comment by mikew posted on LET ME BE THE FIRST at 07/12/2009 - 21:33

mikew
This sounds like a wide open topic to me and right up my street as I have good old Kidderminster on my doorstep (sort of) with its ancient past, the scars of 60s developments as it has the third ugliest building in the country in it, and the ghosts of its industrial prime being recycled as discount stores.

Or I could I guess drift off into the Marches and visit Ludlow or Bridgenorth.

Interesting topic I'd say!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Comments: Weekly competition #127 - History at 07/12/2009 - 17:22

mikew
Just the job.

Comment by mikew posted on Perhaps an eBay bargain? at 07/12/2009 - 17:18

mikew
Count me in

Comment by mikew posted on Perhaps an eBay bargain? at 07/12/2009 - 16:54

mikew
I'm sorry to see you hang up your camera. I did something very similar when we started the family. I was busy with a new job and a new child so that everything else took the back seat. Then 30 years later I came back and I am having a great time relearning it all so there's hope for you too!

Enjoy your new life.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on My Pentax gear for sale in classified at 06/12/2009 - 21:48

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo