McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Alan and David, it is important to eliminate different custom settings as a cause of this ... On the K5 /K7 series there is an option to ' link AE to active AF Point'. I assume the K3 has this or even something more sophisticated such as linking AE to a whole array of points ... This will affect the exposure bias given to in focus zones, and may explain things ... Could you guys check your settings for this?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Great K3 review at 06/12/2014 - 16:39

McGregNi
I understand that it is puzzling, I just wonder if there are other variables at play here, rather than just a camera fault. To be sure of course, a test would have to be set up, shooting the same subject in the same light with the same settings and techniques.

Metering results depend of course on where you point the camera, and depending on the shooting technique and how the camera is operated, it can be intrinsically linked to the focussing and capture stages, or rather divorced from those. David, what are you custom settings related to linking AE to AF point on your K3?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Great K3 review at 06/12/2014 - 12:49

McGregNi
I agree that Pentax need more marketing and market exposure, and lets hope that Ricoh put some of their muscle into it!

I'm not so sure about the wide appeal of medium format ... Of course for studio shooters it's a great solution, but I'm not sure about the wider wedding market? It's a big outlay, and many of the customers are not discerning on IQ matters anyway, and its a very different type of machine to manage then a DSLR ... I'd be interested to hear from our 645d or z users on this sort of flexibility matter ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Is this a new golden age for Pentax?? at 06/12/2014 - 11:28

McGregNi
I'd have thought the metering discrepancies could be due to differing techniques, settings and subjects. From what I've seen recently must of Alans landscapes are multiple exposures, probably shot on manual, where the variation from centre is hardly significant practically .. And his other shots are long telephotos of wildlife. These often involve a smaller number of centre metering zones on a subject that is often in different lighting from its background. Davids landscapes are more often single exposures (I think!) that would involve a metering algorithm much more of an averaging over the scene, because what is in the center zone is more spread out over a wider range of points.

Now, you might say ' but the meter is supposed to work all this out!' Well I'd say that may be asking too much. Considering the different types of scenes, I don't think its too much of a variation. Because Alan is looking to being out the subject then up to plus 1 is logical, considering that the camera will try and retain highlights and allow for keeping the background down.

Settings might be different also. There may be options for linking exposure to af points, and depending on whether these are active or not could be influencing the outcome.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Great K3 review at 06/12/2014 - 11:21

McGregNi
I think the current designation is something like 1DS, but anyway, I think it unlikely that the 645z is pulling sales away from those particular other brand top spec offerings ... Those models have a fairly specific and committed market, namely pro press and sports shooters, and a ' medium format' digital is not suited to those needs.

It may offer a logical more economic route into pro studio and landscape work though, for those who can't afford the competition, and it gives a 'leg-up' into that quality bracket which will help those pros who are early into their careers. For that reason I would also be positive about the potential growing market for it.

The rest, well it remains to be seen I think. The market in the enthusiast and starter levels is in great flux at present, with every company trying new ideas to see what sticks, and consumers having a great deal of choice, although the inevitable compromise comes with every choose as well! It's too early in this phase of transition and development of camera design, form factor and technologies to say what will stick I feel.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Is this a new golden age for Pentax?? at 06/12/2014 - 10:34

McGregNi
Easy, and my machine is hardly high end ... AMD A10 2.7ghz, 8gb ram, win7 home premium, cost £479 2 years ago ... Photo editing is a breeze, including RAW conversion and 16 bit tiffs in PS, although I use the old CS2. I can even edit and output HD video using Sony Movie Studio 13. Nothing to worry about really ... I'd say 6 gb RAM is a sensible minimum RAM to get now .. For photos RAM is really the most important component. Even budget processors will do the job, although with a few extra seconds taken here and there.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Anyone here able to edit and/or work using a laptop? at 05/12/2014 - 21:07

McGregNi
Nice fresh, wintery colours, great sense of space and a feeling of the isolation ... It all comes through very well. Favourite for me is 4, followed by 7 and 8. 4 makes good use of the wide angle with dramatic foreground and lots to look at further afield, 7 has a nice composition, I like the placing of the obelisk and the detailed foreground, also there is less wasted space than in some others.

The other wide views could all benefit from a narrower aspect ratio I think, with less sky at the top as there's not much interest further above the horizon, so a more pano shape would be better IMO. No 1 has a problem with the brightness balancing causing a glow along the left hillside edge where the sky starts, and this continues further to the right also ... Maybe the gradient needed to be higher (assuming you used a gradient tool).

Comment by McGregNi posted on Above Todmorden at 05/12/2014 - 19:18

McGregNi
Two good images, and the ' slide film' exposure technique has clearly worked well. I certainly think the discipline of not having so much latitude when shooting is worthwhile, but surely this type of competition is really a test of the camera JPEG processing capabilities as much as it is a test of the photographer? Out of interest, is anyone's EXIF checked to determine whether additional custom setting refinements have been made, as I'm sure these could make a good difference and push one shot ahead of the others.

Comment by McGregNi posted on ADAPS Straight Out of Camera Competition at 05/12/2014 - 12:16

McGregNi
So it may have limitations for large scale output then ... Would that not rule it out for a good number of professional purposes? The K3 presumably would be a better choice for some of those ...

Comment by McGregNi posted on Why we don't need FF at 04/12/2014 - 19:58

McGregNi
I do think the JPEG output from the K5 is customisable enough to satisfy most needs, and of course if any further adjustment is needed then small tweaks in Photoshop or similar will suffice. Unless there's a fault, it's difficult to justify, surely, going back to a camera many years older in design?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Help me justify - New lenses for K5 or 'cash in'? at 04/12/2014 - 17:01

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo