McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
no, not in advertising, but I do strive to find an outlet wherever I go

Here's another example of added weight as a secondary consequence of a primary benefit ...our flashguns! It's rare to hear photographers complain that they won't use a flashing because its all too heavy and big. But in fact a flash adds significant weight (more than a grip) and its not good for balance either ... But it can mean getting otherwise impossible shots or massively improving shots (such as bounced light for portraits) . We happily accept the price of the weight because the primary benefit is so valuable. It's the same for grips ... The weight is the secondary to the primary benefits (the tactile, contact stuff etc), but in the case of a grip it can be positive in stability terms (unlike a flashgun) ....yet we only hear complaints about grips, not flashes.....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Initial thought on new K3 at 26/03/2015 - 11:08

McGregNi
I'm very glad you gave me the opportunity to further refine my point about the weight/surface area relationship As in your quote there ' due to better grip and stability'. The weight increase will vary depending on whether we had the AA batteries in. I don't usually need these, so I find the extra weight insignificant. What matters is the extra contact surface for the hands ... This is the primary benefit, weight secondary.

I accept that with an already big heavy zoom then simply adding weight may not help ... But when the weight comes as part of the increased surface area, tactile boost and the added man-machine closeness I wrote about earlier, then it is no longer a negative.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Initial thought on new K3 at 26/03/2015 - 10:35

McGregNi
Our brain learns and builds up a kind of tactile memory of these things, and that affects what each individual perceives as ' 'normal''. Because I never use my camera without a grip, the combination is felt as one ... that IS the camera. Removing the grip makes it feel toy-like, fiddly, less secure ...I see that as being just as much pointless as others see the grip as such.

The extra battery capacity is just a secondary benefit to its main purpose of increasing the amount of contact surface. Also the vertical controls are an essential part for me now ... It just feels ridiculous to have to twist my right wrist downwards and stretch the index finger out to reach the shutter button in this orientation, like some sort of contortion.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Initial thought on new K3 at 26/03/2015 - 05:14

McGregNi
As far as stability goes then then the benefit stems from the increased points of contact that the larger surface area provides ... More skin to camera contact equals more movement feedback, and higher tactile response ... It enhances the man-machine interface by deepening the physical relationship.

Because of this enhanced ' closeness' the handling becomes more natural, the camera more an extension of the hands rather than something to be held.

So when it comes to physical relationships, bigger is better !

Comment by McGregNi posted on Initial thought on new K3 at 26/03/2015 - 00:27

McGregNi
I just wanted to give them ideas .. Good ways to showcase the DSLR system as a whole, opportunities that seem to have been missed.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Photography show, Nec, Birmingham at 25/03/2015 - 23:52

McGregNi
No, it's inflammatory nonsense .. Not based on what I wrote at all . The main added value in the grip comes from increased surface area, not it's extra weight, which without 6 aa batteries is easy to absorb, and actually has less relative impact the heavier the lens ... Quite the opposite of your assertion!

The extra weight from a grip will actually have more stability aiding effect the lighter the lens ... Here it's relative weight is higher in relation to the total lens/camera/grip package. The added surface area is fairly equally beneficial regardless of lens size or weight.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Initial thought on new K3 at 25/03/2015 - 23:38

McGregNi
davidstorm wrote:
Great set of images Drew, living in Sheffield I should know this place, but I've never been there. Cheers, David
You must live on the other side of town David .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Park Hill Flats, Sheffield - Image Heavy at 25/03/2015 - 22:33

McGregNi
All very well shot and framed ... I like the angles and depth you've created, and the sense of starkness comes through powerfully.

Processing style? It could be said to suit the subject (the grittiness you mentioned, in a literal manner) ... I can accept that, but I do find some of the 'lighting effects' (little unexpected 'pools' of light and some inverted shadows) a bit too much, unnatural. This type of HDR look will always divide opinions, but I prefer to look at each particular subject individually. Here I think the texture elements are a plus, but the lighting contrasts are not.

But not to distract from the excellent technical captures and compositions!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Park Hill Flats, Sheffield - Image Heavy at 25/03/2015 - 22:31

McGregNi
yes, good points thanks Richard . So poorer low - light performance and it would be harder to get very low depths of field on the smaller sensor ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Resolution question at 25/03/2015 - 22:18

McGregNi
The point about the grip is the extra surface area it adds for holding, plus the stability that comes from extra solidity. The left palm will support under the lens, but the extra size from the grip allows the right hand to have more effect, thereby creating the better balance ... a more even balance between the two hands.

An unbalanced or ergonomically poor setup (such as big heavy zoom on a small camera) will give the impression of extra weight. Extra weight that removes the imbalance and improves the ergonomics will not be felt as such (as in the seafaring example from George above).

Comment by McGregNi posted on Initial thought on new K3 at 25/03/2015 - 22:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo