McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
It depends on how you're looking at it ..... if you just see the 2nd flashgun as JUST an expensive trigger device (as you seem to be doing) then it will seem poor value. But surely we should look upon a 2nd flashgun as exactly that ... a versatile and helpful secondary on-camera lighting source that happens to add the bonus of HSS wireless capability!

There's not many situations surely when a little bit of on-camera (or off-camera with a cable) bounced, diffused, front fill or just plain catchlight providing illumination will be beneficial? A little bit of front fill, even with the built-in I find, can help to clean up side-shadows if there's a surface behind. Outdoors in sunshine some direct fill, regardless of what your off-camera lighting is, would mostly be a plus wouldn't it?

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 28/03/2015 - 21:21

McGregNi
But another nice thing about an HSS approach is about portability and convenience ... Only needs one stand for the flash and powersnoot ... No need for a tripod due to low light (or filter induced) long shutter times, and you can move around framing shots quickly with ease. (just be careful not to kick over your flash!)

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 28/03/2015 - 21:01

McGregNi
I don't use it myself, but I believe the hotshoe cables and shoe connectors provide full flashgun functionality (as far as the camera is concerned the flash IS still on the hotshoe), so that includes HSS.

The restriction with the built-in trigger is for wireless operations. I'm thinking this is simply because the built-in does not fire beyond 180th (ie because it has no HSS capability then it can't work as the trigger). Any flashgun mounted on the hotshoe to act as a trigger for HSS must therefore possess HSS ability itself, and be set for that in order to act as trigger. I believe this principle applies to third party flashguns as well, so we are not necessarily forced into buying a Pentax one specifically - but I'd recommend checking very carefully to be sure that any independent brand gun is rated for HSS and is known to trigger HSS wireless slaves and has the correct channel settings ... this can vary.

My point really above was that surely the 2nd on-camera flash is a bonus when set to 'Master', not 'Control' mode .... something to be utilised as an additional lighting asset, not just thought of as an expensive trigger device.....

And yes, the Pentax proprietary system uses light-based communications between the units.

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 28/03/2015 - 20:17

McGregNi
George Lazarette wrote:


Nigel,

Your Powersnoot is something I hadn't seen before, and it is not a snoot in the normal sense of the term. Normal snoots don't concentrate the light, they simply mask some of it. I can see that the Powersnoot will bring much more light to bear on the subject. G
Yes, I should have been more specific about the actual modifier I had in mind and not just said 'snoot'.

I was making a jump from the scenario that the OP outlined towards the type of demos that Gary Fong shows. With this approach the power of the ambient light is dramatically reduced, in fact in some cases actually shifting time! My earlier comments about it being less complex were just related to this aspect ... by killing off a lot of the ambient light with short time values you remove the concerns over harsh sunlight .... you end not needing to control it or re-direct it in any other way.

One aspect that I do think will remain a concern in bright outdoors conditions (with the light-based triggering system we have) is the ability of the trigger device to communicate well and reliably with the 'slave' unit. I have often quite successfully fired off-camera flash using the built-in as trigger outdoors, but the two flashes have been close together and in good line of sight.


richandfleur wrote:
..... unfortunately pentax doesn't offer any HSS triggers outside of buying a whole other flash as a master, that potentially doesn't contribute to the final shot. It's quite ridiculous really and makes for a very expensive trigger.
Ridiculous Richard? I don't think this is another on of those 'why can't they just issue a firmware update?' kind of problems is it? I would assume its technically part of the flash system .... to trigger an off-camera flash using an on-camera one you need the on-camera unit to be able to fire at speeds shorter than 180thsec .... the built-in can't ... that's the limitation.

But its what we've got .... Matt said earlier that he didn't think there was any third-party trigger that offers HSS wireless.

Personally I don't see it as a serious concern .... I understand the need to buy a second flash, but really that should be seen as a positive thing shouldn't it ? I mean, it will be much easier to balance and produce good flash images with an additional unit on the camera which could be bounced or diffused to support the main lighting source. I find even with the built-in I almost always set it to 'Master' mode and allow a small amount of front fill ... often set to -1 or -2 stops FC so that I only really end up with some catch lights, which are very good!

Now with a second flash, like a new AF-360 FGZ II I'd have even more options ... full manual power control, full bounce options, plus the new front - facing LCD reflector to provide fill and catchlights as well! Now that sounds really cool , not ridiculous at all ?? I know, I know, the money .......

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 28/03/2015 - 17:56

McGregNi
You don't know how hard it can get .... I'm in the early stages of FBA ... Flash buying addiction.

It's not so bad for you LBA people ... There's quite a community of you, and a lot of information and support out there. FBA looks like it will forever be a minority concern and widely misunderstood by the general photographic community. I mean there really ARE people out there who seriously think that one is enough!!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Heads up... Mega Pentax Lens deals next weekend at 28/03/2015 - 13:18

McGregNi
The op said he wanted HSS triggering up to 1/8000 , then he added that he wanted to underexpose the sunlight and light the model from a stand .... Any harsh ambient has been killed by the very short time value, including on the models face, so all that's left is to explore the sort of power and directional control needed for that. That was where my powersnoot idea came from.

A bit of patience and practice with it and manual mode should ensure reliability. Of course, explore all the other possibilities such as modifying the natural light with reflectors ...i guess there's loads of things to try.

My relatively short period of experience has taught me to always be open to new thinking and new ways of expressing and understanding things.

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 27/03/2015 - 23:51

McGregNi
That is a sight to behold! Should I ask the cost? Worth every cent of course! A beautiful piece of kit, I am dripping with envy .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Cost of ownership at 27/03/2015 - 18:37

McGregNi
You're most welcome, pity you couldn't get it going, it was a tricky one!

There's some great prices on used Pentax cameras around, I'm sure you'll find an excellent model and a bargain. Let us know what you end up with.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K10d Operational problem? at 27/03/2015 - 18:33

McGregNi
It's an idea Matt, it came to mind following what the OP was thinking about ... He mentioned 1/8000 so I imagined he was planning on knocking out a great deal of ambient light a la Gary Fong. My main point has been that to power through such short shutter speeds the flash light would need to be highly concentrated with some sort of channeling and amplifying assistance, and the powersnoot answers that need I felt .... Do you agree?

You misquoted me really, I said 'MAY remove the need for complex reflectors' .. Very unfair of you really, I am not in any way trying to contradict your suggestions which depending on the lighting and setup may be needed, with our without a snoot-type device ...I accept it all as things to consider as I hope the OP will as well. Certainly we can't provide a lighting course here, just ideas to consider.

No idea why you feel it necessary to be ' smart' and poke at me about ' understanding lighting principles' ... I don't presume about anyone's knowledge, if there's something to question or correct I do it in the interests of everyone's benefit. I have a great passion in Pentax flash, a willingness to share that and learn more ...I thought that was something we have in common and it would be great for us to build on that for everyone's benefit ....

I can't post links on my smartphone, but there is another interesting Gary Fong demonstration in Sydney Harbour in very bright sunlight where he creates an dusk effect with shutter time and the powersnoot lights the model, so I think it may be possible in such conditions. I guess it all needs plenty of experimenting though.

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 27/03/2015 - 16:38

McGregNi
The product I have in mind here is the Gary Fong Powersnoot ... A google will bring up good video demonstrations and the website for more info. Basically it has highly reflective insides which act like a projectile for the light, increasing the reflective insides which act like a projectile making an effective increase in power, much as a flash head zoom does.

This allows the flash to power through very big reductions in ambient lighting through short short shutter times, and may remove the need for complex reflectors to try and balance the sun ... You're really knocking down brightness with the shutter times, so really taking control of ambient AND flash light!

Comment by McGregNi posted on high speed flash triggers at 27/03/2015 - 15:14

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo