McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I don't see that it has been forgotten at all .... It's precisely the subject that is being discussed by everyone. ... ??

Comment by McGregNi posted on K5IIs versus K5 at 15/02/2016 - 18:33

McGregNi
I would say you're looking at it exactly the same as me Kris, which is to put it into a wider context. Taken in isolation, the presence or not of the AA filter on a modern DSLR is going to be of far less significance than many other factors.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K5IIs versus K5 at 15/02/2016 - 12:39

McGregNi
You're right to phrase it as a ' starting point', and noting David Storms post above where he said 'end of story' ... Well I'd say no, the sensor/AA filter configurations are just the START of the story....

That is why I have constantly approached this from a workflow and processing viewpoint, and there are so many variations to personal techniques and software default profiles that it becomes a very personal question.

Remember we started with this presented as a choice .... One that involved a 100 pound price difference .... And that is why I titled my workflow tests 'New Choice Considerations '.

I believe it is still the case that for most people, given their output needs and personal workflow techniques, that a sensor without AA filter will offer no particular tangible benefit .... Of course, times have moved on and the choice has either gone now or the prices are similar.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K5IIs versus K5 at 15/02/2016 - 08:28

McGregNi
Agreed, and the debate about whether an AA filter is now required is a different one again. It seems that the latest and highest resolution sensors reduce the occurrence of moire in many situations.

The old question and debate was about a very direct choice we were given with two camera versions ... And the 100 pound difference in price that involved.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K5IIs versus K5 at 14/02/2016 - 12:47

McGregNi
The Samyang 14mm f2.8 is a modern, high quality manual focus lens, and new at around 270 British Pounds is certainly 'budget' .... No compromises though in IQ nor build, plus its 'FF'.

It's not an architectural lens really, as the edge distortions are complex to try and correct. Plenty of examples in my PU portfolio if you click through ... Probably have to go to the 2nd or 3rd pages to see most, but there's a few taken around Canary Wharf at night with the Samyang and 20 to 30 sec exposures.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Landscapes lens - budget recommendation - Used acceptable. at 14/02/2016 - 12:13

McGregNi
Assessments via monitor screens, especially of 'web-sized' jpegs will always be fraught by inconsistency. The resizing algorithm applied for that final jpeg version may well be the overriding determining factor, and certainly RAW ' capture sharpening', which will be as varied as the number of programmes and profile set-ups used by everyone, can have it's influence.

I've never denied that taken to the ultimate extreme through a processing workflow then the non AA filtered image will prove to have a significant edge in clarity .... But very few of us have the need for such a highly optimised output, which is probably only needed for larger exhibition prints.

Going back to Steve's point earlier ... Surely the results of moving from a lesser lens to a premium * type lens will have far more visual impact on ones photography than a move to an AA filterless sensor .... ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on K5IIs versus K5 at 14/02/2016 - 12:01

McGregNi
Someone may have pointed that out, but unlikely they were able to prove it or demonstrate it.

Of course there's a technical difference between the two outputs., without the slight blurring from the AA filter, but really, it's what happens after the image is captured, during each individuals unique processing workflow, that makes the real life difference. For the majority of common uses many standard processing workflows would simply equalise the results and remove any noticeable difference.

By this I mean the K5 file simply requires more sharpening, or better selective targeted sharpening, up to certain limits of course.

Comment by McGregNi posted on K5IIs versus K5 at 14/02/2016 - 09:20

McGregNi
Sure, if you're already using a radio trigger then it makes sense to expand that system to two. For me, the next step up from that starting point would be a radio system that allowed remote control over manual power levels on the two flashes.

This is likely to be a system that offers 'group' control, in your case each flash would be one group. The added convenience and speed of being able to fine tune and experiment with the brightness of each flash, and all from the cameras position, is a huge benefit for manual working.

The two systems I know of that offer this and work with Pentax cameras are Cactus and Yongnuo. I can tell you about how the Cactus work, because that's what I use, but there are some experienced users of Yongnuo gear around on this site also who should be able to advise on that system.

With the Metz unit, to gain power control remotely, you need a radio system that supports the flash specifically or can be 'profiled' to learn it's power and control it in ratios. For your second flash then choosing a native unit from your radio system will ensure it has the power control capability built-in.

Let us know the model of radio equipment you already have and any particular flashes you've been looking at, and I'm sure between us all here we can come up with some workable solutions.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Newbie Seeks Advice at 09/02/2016 - 20:27

McGregNi
I think the main thing is to try and pin down if we think the yellow cast was 'baked in' by the camera settings at capture, or added later.

I wonder, is there any way to know whether this is a result of a colour temperature inaccuracy, or a yellow saturation issue? In my experience there is sometimes crossover between the results of these two things.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Picture not printed right at 08/02/2016 - 21:44

McGregNi
I will try the latest version for sure Steve. I remember getting completely bogged down in the dense user instructions with some extraordinary complex explanations of Lab colour modes and other stuff that was way beyond my understanding. I suppose it could all be ignored and just used in a simple RGB manner ....

I fear that we are overcomplicating things for the OP .... Louise has asked before about RAW and been given ideas, but clearly did stick to jpegs, so it may be better to try and pin down where the yellow colour came from in the first place .... Do we think it was caused by custom settings on the camera at point of capture, or was it introduced by some processing step used later ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Picture not printed right at 08/02/2016 - 20:52

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo