McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Photo editing on a touchscreen is likely to be frustrating I suspect .... at least if you want to use anything but a basic, touchscreen dedicated programme. There's always going to be the need for quite fine control, especially once you start to look at selective working, and then a mouse and keyboard make a big difference. The relatively small screen size of an iPad will be limiting as well I think .

Comment by McGregNi posted on Post process at 05/09/2016 - 22:59

McGregNi
That seems like a fair reasoning of the situation .... I'm in the second camp there, but I've grown to appreciate the better of the older lenses thanks to the knowledge on the forums from the longer term Pentax users around. It seems it was hard to get a bad K / M / A series lens, but then easier from the F series onwards.

Those who want to use a high quality film era autofocus lens seem to have to look harder, and still pay quite a high price for those considered the best. Rarity comes into it by now also I suppose ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on First Few from the D FA 28-105 at 05/09/2016 - 22:55

McGregNi
Well I'm sure my approval for the Samyang 14mm is well known around here, as are many images I've shown taken with it, so no need to rave on any more. I include the Samyangs here in this 'legacy' discussion, not because of the optics, which are modern high quality designs and benefit from modern coatings, but because functionally, on the DSLRs, they are the equivilent of the old A-series types ..... an aperture ring with A position,so allowing automatic exposure control via P, Av, Sv, Tav modes etc.

However, being manual focus, they also have same metering limitations .... ie centre-weighted only I believe, with only the central AF spot being available for focus confirmation. Also, again because of the lack of autofocus, they are not compatible with P-TTL automatic flash exposure. You should use manual flash exposure, or possibly the older 'Auto' mode, which is available on the previous Pentax versions of the AF360 / 540 FGZ flashes, as well as some third party flashes from Metz etc.

What do people think about my idea of treating the 14mm as a sort of 14-18mm 'zoom', via a shoot-wide-crop-later approach ... ? I'm thinking that with the high optical performance from it, plus the resolution of the K1, it would hardly be necessary to buy the equivilent zoom for such focal lengths on FF ..... ?

The other advantage for cropping would be less edge distortions to deal with.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Which legacy lenses for K1? at 05/09/2016 - 16:32

McGregNi
Here is a series of shots taken from Durlston Country Park, to the west of Swanage, Dorset. This is centred around the small Victorian castle on the top of the Head, with both coastal and cliff-top walks heading west around the 'Jurassic Coastline'. From here you can see the distictive Lighthouse complex and pass the closed extrance to the Tilly Whim Caves, as well as view the dramatic barren rockfaces.

I saw a couple of other photographers with big long camouflaged lenses, so I assume there must be birdlife to capture on the cliffs .... Thats not my thing , (although I did grab a couple of a Condor ).

I had the K7 with Tamron AF70-300mm Di LD .....


1.

Comment Image




2.

Comment Image




3.

Comment Image




4.

Comment Image




5.

Comment Image




6.

Comment Image




7.

Comment Image




8.

Comment Image


Thanks for your views (in both senses of the word )

Comment by McGregNi posted on Around Durlston Head at 05/09/2016 - 16:21

McGregNi
Though not 'legacy' in the real sense, the Samyang manual focus options are a compelling choice for K1 users ..... perhaps not so much the longer ones (eg 85 / 135mm), but certainly the wider ones. I don't think manual focus is such a concern with wide angles, and the sort of landscape and architecture stuff I would be taking with them suits the manual focus approach anyway.

I'm thinking specifically of the 14mm, and now the new 24mm F3.5 Tilt Shift ..... this is something I would really be looking at when I get a K1, or K1 successor ...... link

With the 14mm, while for some subjects the distortions would prove too difficult, I imagine that with the high quality optical performance if offers, plus the resolution of the K1, it would be easily possible to happily crop into the images .... I mean frame wide, and crop to achieve field of views equivalent from 15mm through to about 18mm without significant quality loss .. ? (So its almost like having a 14-18mm zoom).

For me, I'm thinking now that I have a D FA 28-105, the 14mm plus 24 tilt shift would probably meed most needs.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Which legacy lenses for K1? at 05/09/2016 - 15:52

McGregNi
Some lovely blurred backgrounds throwing the subjects into focus.

The most successful for me is the 2nd, because you've brought the flower into full prominance, a good size within the frame, and its sharp in the right place. The others lose impact by being relatively small in the frame.

Nice soft tones and subtle colours throughout.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Flowers at 05/09/2016 - 15:29

McGregNi
Hi John, I checked the EXIF on the DNGs, and there is a fairly even mix of 0 EC and -0.5 EC, so generally it was ok with that half stop negative exposure. That said, where there were bright skies I did experience the burn out as you described .... here's an example of that .....

Comment Image


This particular one had no EC when shot, so I guess I could have taken it with 1/2 or maybe even 1 stop under .... but in this sort of high contrast scene I would be worried about the shadows in that case, as the K7 is not good for noise in underexposed areas. So I guess I have to keep a careful eye on contrast and dynamic range ..... well, at least until I get a K1

Comment by McGregNi posted on First Few from the D FA 28-105 at 05/09/2016 - 15:18

McGregNi
Thanks Philip

I'm pleased to say that there is no software blurring with these, it is completely from the lens optics. In those where the background has dark shadows I used noise reduction to remove colour noise, but this did not change the bokeh effect or add to the blur significantly.

This was one of the things from reviews about the lens that was attractive to me .... That it was reported to render nice OOF backgrounds, at least for a zoom anyway. For portraits with my F35-70, at 70mm I'm finding I don't get enough OOF behind, so I figured that standing back and zooming in more with this 28-105 would help with that a lot.

Comment by McGregNi posted on First Few from the D FA 28-105 at 05/09/2016 - 13:21

McGregNi
A varied and ingesting selection giving a good sense of the places and journey. That extreme low angle in No2 is great!

Comment by McGregNi posted on North wales narrow gauge at 05/09/2016 - 08:06

McGregNi
I like the angle of flash light in No2 and how you've turned his face towards it ... Nice soft light also. From the catchlights it looks like a softbox .... ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Todays 4 images at 05/09/2016 - 07:56

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo