McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
You've got some 'up close and personal' angles there! I especially like the one from under the fallen tree branches. You need some better light outdoors to really give it a good run

I wonder, does the K1 come with automatic distortion corrections for this lens (JPEG only I know) ... and are they effective?

Comment by McGregNi posted on A few from the FA 15-30 at 11/09/2016 - 19:15

McGregNi
Ha ! You're right John, of course, there was me giving all the credit to the lens .... not like me at all

But it does deserve high praise .... to my eye I see really 'prime-like' quality throughout the zoom range. I have noticed that at the long end it needs F11 to really become very sharp ... but its still quite acceptable at F5.6, and would be excellent for portraits at 105mm zoom and F5.6. I do have some others coming soon of flower and plant close-ups with OOF backgrounds that put that aspect to the test also ... (do I need to say yet if there was a smile on my face or not when seeing those .. ? )

Comment by McGregNi posted on Kensington with the New 28-105 at 11/09/2016 - 18:32

McGregNi
And another 'good luck' wish from me ! Hope the treatment goes well and you are back at the camera controls as soon as possible.

One extra point that may be helpful .... a few of the recent photos you've shown are overexposed, in my opinion. This is just the result of the particular way the metering system is responding, but I suspect it is because there is somewhat less bright surrounds around the very bright white gulls. So when doing this type of shot again in similar conditions I would suggest setting a minus exposure compensation .... say, for example, -0.7 stops, or -1.0.

This should prevent the blown out whites on the birds, and has the secondary effect of allowing a shorter exposure time, so helps a little to reduce movement blur. If you do find that the results are a little dark, it is easy enough to apply a little brightening to them on the computer.

Of course, this approach would not apply to birds against a bright sky background, where the metering is likely to react differently and not overexpose.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Birds in flight shots using K-50 and Tamron 70-300mm f4-5.6 lens. at 11/09/2016 - 18:25

McGregNi
I had a good walkabout on a break recently, around the residential streets near High Street Kensington as well as Holland Park. Late afternoon with setting sun, and I was trying out the new HD Pentax D FA 28-105 ED DC WR.

As I said on other threads here, so far I am very impressed with this lens, which I have bought with a view to a future Full Frame model, but provides me with a very useful range on aps-c for now. The build, handling and autofocus are all excellent .... I really love the DC focussing which is quite a revalation since I have only had screw drive lenses up to now.

I wanted to put the lens through its paces in some demanding light conditions, so I chose contrasty and backlit subjects .... I have to say that personally I am quite blown away by the IQ in these situations ..... very well controlled flare, contrast, and almost no abberations against very stark edges. I have not needed to carry out any CA corrections or try and reduce colour fringing at all.


1.

Comment Image




2.

Comment Image




3.

Comment Image




4.

Comment Image





5.

Comment Image





6. I found this alley with a number of posters showing computer images of the building being constructed ....

Comment Image




7.

Comment Image




8.

Comment Image





9.

Comment Image




10.

Comment Image




11.

Comment Image




12.

Comment Image





13.

Comment Image



Thanks for taking a look , and for any responses .

Comment by McGregNi posted on Kensington with the New 28-105 at 11/09/2016 - 11:50

McGregNi
Ha! I knew I'd be getting some advice from you about beer bottles Yes, focussing is an issue, but I tried hard to get equivilent set-ups for the two lenses. Its nothing scientific but I'm happy for my purposes. No, I have NOT found the 18-55 better than my A28 F2.8 ....at least not for the sort of shots I use it for.

Comment by McGregNi posted on HD Pentax D FA 28-105 at 06/09/2016 - 13:07

McGregNi
MrB wrote:
Wonderful colours, Nigel. My choice of these is number 4.Cheers.
Philip
Thanks Philip !

Comment by McGregNi posted on Around Durlston Head at 05/09/2016 - 23:54

McGregNi
At Lennyblokes suggestion I've just carried out some test shots comparing the new D FA 28-105 with the A28 F2.8. So I set up a tripod and a flash in a softbox, with radio manual control to ensure consistent exposures. I used two test items, a beer bottle (now there's one forum member I can think of who approve of that!), and a wooden toy garage..... Just to give an idea, here they are ....

Comment Image



Comment Image


Using mirror up and remote control I took various shots at different apertures with the zoom at 28mm, and the same images with the A28 also. I used manual focussing using Live View magnification to be sure I was as perfect with focus with both lenses as possible. (I must say what an immpressive focus ring and action the D FA 28-105 has .... its was actually easier and smoother to manual focus than the A28 !

I'll post some specific examples soon with the settings details and some 100% crops for detailed examination ...... but ...... immediate impressions are that there will not be very much in it at all .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on HD Pentax D FA 28-105 at 05/09/2016 - 23:49

McGregNi
I followed that sale thread (but I've forgotton who the seller was) , and had a good look at the images. I was very tempted myself, as contrast, colours, and sharpness seemed all good ..... but, those damned distortions / vertical perspective exaggerations put me off.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Which legacy lenses for K1? at 05/09/2016 - 23:30

McGregNi
andrewk wrote:
McGregNi wrote:
For me, I'm thinking now that I have a D FA 28-105 ............
If you are anything like me it would have occured to you, only seconds after the box arrived, to check out your new toy against the F 35-70mm which we both have. Did you do that? Did you form any conclusions about how they compare over their common focal lengths?

Andrew
Actually, no, that specific comparison hadn't occurred to me .... see, great minds don't necessarily think alike

Of course I considered my existing lenses before commiting to the D FA28-105 purchase .... and the F35-70 falls right in the middle of its range. But I was looking most specifically at other qualities from the new zoom .... not necessarily direct optical performance comparisons with what I already had. So it was mainly the extended, really more useful range of the 28-105, plus the DC autofocussing, build quality and handling niceties like the Quick Shift and well designed zoom / AF rings, plus the weather resistance. Also I just wanted a good value way into the world of high quality, modern Pentax optics, and the SRS sale just made it easier!

The F35-70 is very good, but its AF is noisy and doesn't always succeed first time, especially at wider zoom settings. I am likely to keep it for the 1:4 'macro' capability, which is very good and handy .... (not sure, but I think this would still produce a higher magnification than the 28-105 at full zoom and closest focus .... ?) But, in general, the 28-105 will absorb most of the photograpic opportunities, plus more, that the f35-70 has been used for .... plus of course the 28-55 part of the DA 18-55 also. Again, for now, the wider part of the DA18-55 will complement the 28-105, at least until I do move to FF.

At the suggestion of Lennybloke I have just carried out some test shots comparing the 28-105 and the A28 F2.8. I will post some photos and conclusions on my thread in the lens forum about the D FA 28-105, but initial impressions based on the camera JPEGs are that there will be very little between the two, and probably nothing significant for most practical photographic situations .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Which legacy lenses for K1? at 05/09/2016 - 23:23

McGregNi
johnriley wrote:
Quote:
What do people think about my idea of treating the 14mm as a sort of 14-18mm 'zoom', via a shoot-wide-crop-later approach ... ? I'm thinking that with the high optical performance from it, plus the resolution of the K1, it would hardly be necessary to buy the equivilent zoom for such focal lengths on FF ..... ?
It's a valid approach under some circumstances, but to get the best out of the ultra-wide lens and the dramatic perspectives possible, we really need to get in close, then closer and then closer still until we are right in the subject. Then the results will look different and exciting. We can fill the frame with such a close viewpoint that the steep perspective can add real drama.
Yes, I guess you'd still want to get up close to foreground interest to get the most out of the very wide angle .... but I was thinking that where 14mm was too wide around the perimeters, then cropping would work well.

Here's one of mine with the Samyang 14mm where I thought this cropping approach would work OK if we wanted to bring the edges in somewhat ....

Comment Image


I'm thinking of the economics as well ..... I don't see myself being able to get a K1 plus D FA 15-30 as well .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Which legacy lenses for K1? at 05/09/2016 - 23:09

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo