McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Richard, check in on the Shanny 'new adopter' thread .... Your help is needed there.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Wildlife photographer of the year peoples choice at 08/02/2017 - 09:49

McGregNi
Not silly at all ! Good questions really ....

The Shanny lacks the 'Pentax Wireless system' functions. So no off-camera P-TTL and related modes. When off-camera it works as a 'dumb optical slave' ...ie it triggers optically from any strong enough light source that it can detect.

This could be the built-in flash, but it needs to be able to ignore the pre-flashes in order to fire in sync with the actual exposure. There is sometimes a special 'SL2' mode on flashes like this in order to achieve this. The forum members Stub and Richandfleur have the Shanny and will be able to confirm that this works ok.

Manual radio triggers should work ok.

The original 44 Af-1 only had wireless slave capability, and does not act as a 'master/controller' from the camera. If there is an updated model then the instructions should be on the Metz website ... Hopefully they will give full details.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Early adopter Shanny SN600FGZ at 08/02/2017 - 07:48

McGregNi
Yes, and McBrian made a good point above about the flash exposure needing to be much higher than the continuous lighting in order to 'wipe out' the blurred effects on the bird ....and yet the exposure is quite even over the bird ....

The difficulty is to understand how it was possible to isolate the effects of the two different light sources, ie how can the continuous (ambient) light only affect the tail and the flash lighting only affect the body and head ? It is hard to understand in this (presumably) natural setting how such a separation could be created.

They could be switched on and off independently of course, and used selectively for different frames ....assuming that the bird is diving repeatedly at the exact same spot then multiple images could he shot with just the ambient light on and then again with just the flash lights on ..... But , this is just speculation based on a way that I can understand it . The photographer seems to imply it is a single frame. I suppose he is content to keep hold of the mystery.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Wildlife photographer of the year peoples choice at 08/02/2017 - 07:06

McGregNi
The question is really over whether the standard flash technique we're talking about, rear curtain sync with a fairly long exposure, could possibly have produced this image alone. In flash-speak the technique is known as 'dragging the shutter', with the long ambient exposure recording the blurred movement and the flash burst right at the end freezing the subject outline. The 2nd curtain sync mode ensures that this outline is positioned in front of the blurred elements, which therefore 'trail' the subject.

But of course the whole bird was moving, not just the tail, so I do not understand why the blurring is only seen on the tail, unless it is a blend of different frames.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Wildlife photographer of the year peoples choice at 07/02/2017 - 20:27

McGregNi
I'm with you on that! Actually, you'll notice that I didn't comment here before about the photo. I had a look, but it didn't really stir me. Of course I can appreciate the technical skill, preparation, patience etc .... But it has a kind of clinical perfection to it which seems unreal, it feels non-organic. Even the fancy flash stuff failed to amaze because it is so far removed from what any mortal photographer could do ... And I am inspired by photos that make me think 'hmn, I could do that!'.

Even if it was all created by special techniques at capture, I feel that if something looks photoshopped then it may as well have been.

But I'm not interested in Kingfishers anyway .... I'd be interested to hear the response from someone who is, eg Blythman, who takes great natural looking bird photos. Does he feel the same as me, or is he wowed and inspired to get those lights out and set up down by the lake .... ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Wildlife photographer of the year peoples choice at 07/02/2017 - 07:29

McGregNi
The remote control for our DSLRs should be an obvious tool..... It can be held in a hand well below the frame, assuming a fairly close in portrait. Focusing well on the eyes will be the tricky technical thing, given inevitable small displacements each time we get up to check the camera screen.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Weekly #500 - Auto-Portrait at 06/02/2017 - 22:28

McGregNi
Ah, thanks, ok .... I thought it might be that the portrait had to be taken with green square mode!

Hmmm, but I do feel that people with articulating screens may have an unfair advantage ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Weekly #500 - Auto-Portrait at 06/02/2017 - 21:46

McGregNi
Never fear !.... I don't know if this is exactly what happened with this image David, but what I think the guys are saying is that there were two 'effective' exposures, one after the other....

The first was the ambient exposure of 1/15thsec, and this recorded the blurred movement ....

The 2nd was the flash exposure of an extremely short duration. (eg 1/15,000th sec), and it was this that recorded he sharp 'frozen' parts ....

The '2nd (or trailing) curtain sync' thing means that the ambient exposure records first and then the flash exposure occurs at the extreme end of the ambient exposure. This ensures that the blurring appears at the 'trailing' (rear) end of the moving object, a natural looking phenomenem.

But. .... The effect is usually seen on the whole subject, as a blurring of the whole subject with a frozen outline, do I agree with David that in this image it appears odd .... Or at least the flash technique I've just described cannot explain everything about the image.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Wildlife photographer of the year peoples choice at 06/02/2017 - 21:21

McGregNi
Could anyone explain what is an 'auto-portrait' please ... ?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Weekly #500 - Auto-Portrait at 06/02/2017 - 17:13

McGregNi
Ok thanks, there's a full range of Pentax DSLRs listed, the oldest being the K10D and K200D, right through to the K3, which is the latest model listed. The MX-1 and Ricoh GR are there also.

Comment by McGregNi posted on DxO 9- free download available. at 05/02/2017 - 15:13

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo