JohnX

Joined: 9th February 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

JohnX
Just thought I'd finish this small saga, firstly with thanks to all who posted comments, and then to Pentax UK who have agreed to change the lens, despite the fact that by the time the lens arrived for inspection at/by Johnson's the debris had disappeared!

On a more general note, however, I have been speaking to a lot of people along the way, and some interesting things have been said, including the fact that come October this year Pentax Imaging UK will be a seperate business within the Pentax UK organisation, so will we see a return to 'real world' pricing of lenses, etc?

There's also an acknowledgement that they can't compete with the marketing budgets of Canikon et al, so, cutting their cloth accordingly they're focussing (right now) on putting more product and support into Pentax Pro Centres.

Hopefully the enthusiasm we all have for Pentax kit is returning to Pentax itself?

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 14/07/2009 - 10:31

JohnX
I'm still waiting on a response from the retailer, but have in the meantime spoken to Consumer Direct. Seems I can't demand a replacement, although I can ask for it. According to Consumer Direct it would have to be a replacement of similar value!

I've escalated it up to a manager at Johnson's; according to Pentax they make the decision as to repair or replace in the event the lens is sent to them.

Retailer still also trying to get this resolved.

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 06/07/2009 - 13:18

JohnX
Snootchies wrote:
The dealer is speaking rubbish. The fact that the price has gone up is not your problem. You are legally allowed a repair or refund free of charge, it is your consumer right.
In fairness to the dealer there's no question of not getting a refund or a repair if I want one. What I want though is a perfect lens One of my little foibles I suppose; when I buy something new I expect it to be pristine. In this instance it looks like I need to decide between a repair = less than perfect, or paying more. As I wrote earlier, another dealer is advertising one at £10 more.

Guess all will be revealed tomorrow!

Thanks to all for your comments and advice.

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 05/07/2009 - 23:04

JohnX
scottthehat wrote:
as far as i can see there should just be a straight swap for a new one, its the retailers problem, as long as its not over 28 days old,
You're right, except I'm told by the dealer that as it was 'old' stock, and they've now run out, they'd have to charge me the difference between the old and new price because any replacement they received from Pentax would be at the new prices.

If anyone knows how Pentax handles returns from dealers I'd be very pleased to know, as unfortunately at the moment what the dealer's telling me makes sense even if I don't like what I'm hearing.

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 05/07/2009 - 18:07

JohnX
shim wrote:

...I had a similar speck on a Pentax 55-300mm I bought a few months ago from SRS, but because it was working OK I didn't bother returning it. I'll think twice about using them again though, mail orders should be inspected.

shim
If it were a speck I wouldn't be so bothered, but it's 1>1.5 mm in diameter. I'm also concerned what else might be in there!

Besides, even at the old price it's not a cheap lens, and I expect it to be perfect, that way I know if there any problems with any of my shots it's down to me, not the equipment

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 05/07/2009 - 18:00

JohnX
shim wrote:
Just tell the dealer to replace it or you'll buy one elsewhere for a higher price and sue him for the difference in the form of a "Loss of Bargain Claim".

shim
Thanks Shim, never heard of "Loss of Bargain Claim"; I'll look into it. That said, it's Pentax at fault, not the dealer. Poor quality control.

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 05/07/2009 - 17:10

JohnX
Mannesty wrote:
It sounds as if this got in there during manufacture. I'd be surprised if it got in after manufacture as it's a 'dust proof' lens. Have it cleaned under warranty or replaced by Pentax.
I'm hoping Pentax will offer a straight replacement. That would be my preferred choice. The dealer, however, indicated that it's unlikely. He talked about refunds, credit notes, etc. Bottom line, he felt that I'd end up having to pay the new, higher, price.

johnriley wrote:
Perhaps return it for a full refund and source it elsewhere? If that is fruitless, then it looks like the repair option may be the only one.


Can't get it at the same price, unfortunately, although looks like I might be able to get one for around £10 more. Could be this is the route to go.

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 05/07/2009 - 15:08

JohnX
Encouraged by all the positive things said about this lens, and prompted by the price hike, I bought one last week at the old price. Unfortunately when I received the lens I immediately noticed a small foreign object on one of the lens elements. Doesn't look like dust - 1>1.5mm in diameter, light brown in colour. Could be cardboard.

Contacted the dealer; their only other copy had dust inside!

Currently I'm waiting on what the dealer and Pentax agree on Monday, but in order for me to have this lens at the lower price it looks like I might have to send it away for 'repair'!

Thoughts? Advice? Suggestions?

Comment by JohnX posted on DA* 50-135 - what to do? at 05/07/2009 - 14:50

JohnX
Or this?

link

Comment by JohnX posted on Pentax Da 17-70mm F4 & Da* 55mm F1.4 at 29/06/2009 - 12:06

JohnX
Look at credit/debit card receipts, etc. You had to buy fuel for your hire car - where, when? Hopefully somewhere in the Lake District at the same time as the other driver was committing the offences.

Comment by JohnX posted on Legal integrity of EXIF data at 24/06/2009 - 18:46

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo