All Forum Comments
Comment by johnriley posted on Hello everybody! at 21/10/2012 - 10:38
but I think it is fair to conclude from the results that the modular approach has proved more sucessful in terms of extracting greater finer detailing and a greater range of tones. That seems to be what most people have said, at least as far as this particular 'shootout' is concerned.
Comment by johnriley posted on Our Great Photo Processing Shootout! at 21/10/2012 - 10:24
Comment by johnriley posted on Other Forum at 21/10/2012 - 10:22
The K-5 is fine with Live View, clearly the best yet, but the K-01 is probably even better and this should carry over to the K-5 II and the K-5 IIs.
Comment by johnriley posted on Live View at 20/10/2012 - 19:18
It's a matter of workflow, whereas the thread started off as a matter of quality of results. Hence the confusion.
FWIW, when I shoot a RAW file, which is not unless needed, I don't save it in ACR, I open it. Then continue to deal with it like any other image.
Anyway, whatever suits the individual is fine, but it's always worth looking at alternatives to keep abreast of developments.
Comment by johnriley posted on Our Great Photo Processing Shootout! at 20/10/2012 - 16:33
For example, in ACR David was hugely more limited with his saturation and vibrance control.
I'm not sure how much experience you have in using Adobe products?
Comment by johnriley posted on Our Great Photo Processing Shootout! at 20/10/2012 - 15:39
Comment by johnriley posted on Pentax K 85mm f1.8 Initial Impressions at 20/10/2012 - 15:34
Film did not have the same response curve as they eye, so filters were used if a more natural rendidtion was required. Exaggerating this also was popular as it added drama to a shot.
Digital sensors reproduce colours pretty well, but can be fooled by excessive amounts of IR or UV light. Hence the blocking filters employed by manufacturers, to a greater or lesser extent. Dynamic range also plays a part, and over-exposed areas of green will tend to look very over-bright and sickly yellow very easily.
Add to this the human eye, and some people are more or less colour blind or see colours differently to each other. Just look at how some TV sets are adjusted by their users, who happily ignore bright orange faces and think it's a good picture.
There's more to this than just dismissing it as nonsense. I have a friend who used to work in colour printing and as part of one of his lectures he demonstates very well just how far off people's colour perception can be.
Comment by johnriley posted on Our Great Photo Processing Shootout! at 20/10/2012 - 12:58
Comment by johnriley posted on Our Great Photo Processing Shootout! at 20/10/2012 - 12:45

