jeallen01

Joined: 12th February 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

jeallen01
Mike-P wrote:
jeallen01 wrote:

As you may guess, my preference is for Sigma - and I am with Mike-P on the subject of the early non-HSM Sigma 70-200 F2.8. My is s/h, bought about 3yrs ago from Mifsuds, and it's so sharp - I love it! (only used less now that I have the 100-300mm F4 and use that for airshows - but that is a far more unweildly beast, and much less "fun" to use)
I always take the 50-500mm to airshows, infact the 100-300mm f4 very rarely gets used at all which is a shame as it's a also a superb lens.

I must say Sigma have made some cracking lenses in their time .. and some real dogs
Thought about one of the longer Sigma zooms, but because I am getting on a bit (64 in Oct) the sheer weight of these would be too much for me to lug around and then use. I can certainly feel the difference between the 70-200 with the 1.4xTC, and the 100-300 without it

As well as the difference in size/weight, the main advantage (to me!) of the 100-300 over the 70-200+TC is that the manual focus ring on the 100-300 is easier to grasp than that of the 70-200 because the TC on that moves the ring further away from the camera body, and so I have to shift my left hand to focus it.

I also realised (last Sunday at Dunsfold) that I am just not quick enough and accurate enough nowadays to point anything longer than the 100-300 at a fast moving aircraft and then actually keep it in the frame without cropping the nose or the tail off! . So 100-300 is as about as "long" as I will go!

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Tamron or Sigma 70-200 f2.8. Which? at 31/08/2011 - 19:56

jeallen01
Blythman wrote:
Going away for a week. When I come back I think I will be buying either the Tamron 70-200mm F/2.8 Di LD (IF) Macro or the Sigma 70-200mm F2.8 EX DG MACRO HSM II both are £599.
I'd be grateful for opinions on both. Which should I buy?
What other lenses do you have as I found that there are potentially major differences between brands - such as the positions of the controls and, worse, the manual focus rings turn in the opposite direction, which can be very disconcerting when you are swopping lenses about.

I tried some other, earlier, Tamrons, and I found this to be a problem as I am used to Sigmas. I also found the Tamron had "stickier" manual focusing mechanisms.

As you may guess, my preference is for Sigma - and I am with Mike-P on the subject of the early non-HSM Sigma 70-200 F2.8. My is s/h, bought about 3yrs ago from Mifsuds, and it's so sharp - I love it! (only used less now that I have the 100-300mm F4 and use that for airshows - but that is a far more unweildly beast, and much less "fun" to use)

Therefore I would take some of these factors into consideration when choosing a lens

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Tamron or Sigma 70-200 f2.8. Which? at 31/08/2011 - 19:31

jeallen01
beachboy2 wrote:
No one mentioned the Pentax SMC F 1.7x AF Adapter. Makes the MF lens a very fast auto focus lens!
Probably because of three problems:
1) Finding one (hens teeth?)
2) Being able to afford one!
3) The reduction in effective aperture - as I said above, anything more than a 1-stop reduction will cause problems with a lot of lenses.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Which MF Pentax Teleconverter Recommended? at 30/08/2011 - 18:37

jeallen01
mille19 wrote:
prsjnb wrote:
thoughton wrote:
The IQ of the Sigmas - especially the 1.4x - is good, but they only work with lenses with a recessed rear element, and they won't work with Sigma's HSM lenses.
Hate to take issue with you Tim, but I have the 1.4X and it works (fine AF) with my 100-300mm f4 EX DG, which is an HSM lens.

Jon
I thought Sigma 100-300mm F4 didn't come with HSM.
A slight aside: I had the 100-300 F4 in use at Wings & Wheels at Dunsfold yesterday, and I found out one disturbing thing about combining it with the Sigma 2x TC on the K5:
It was almost impossible to manually adjust the focus with the TC attached, and very concerning because you could clearly hear a clutch slipping loudly inside the lens when you did try to do that - I stopped as soon as I realised that because, whatever it was, it did NOT "sound good".

Won't try that again, and if I do use the two together, it will be for pics that don't require a lot of rapid focus distance adjustment, and so the lens can be left to autofocus in its own time!

OTOH, I don't get the same problem, or at least to anywhere near the same extent, with the 2x on my oldish 70-200 F2.8 - which does work reasonably well, but, as I said before, not autofocus very quickly.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Which MF Pentax Teleconverter Recommended? at 29/08/2011 - 09:37

jeallen01
bretti_kivi wrote:
it's not a microUSB cable on any of the Pentaces. Bret
You are correct! - it is a USB to miniUSB cable! I omitted to check my fact first (and I have a number of items which do require the micro version)

Anyway, IIRC, you get the right cable in the box with the camera, and it only "fits one way" - so there should be no confusion later on (provided you can still find the damned thing weeks later!)

Comment by jeallen01 posted on K5 firmware question at 15/08/2011 - 20:37

jeallen01
ChrisR wrote:
Maybe all camera boxes should carry a warning :-

YOU WILL NEED COMPUTER SKILLS TO USE THIS PRODUCT.

Take care.

Chris R.
Not wishing to be rude, but what item of relatively advanced piece of consumer electronics does not require some computer skills to get something decent out of it. Don't forget that most DSLRs would be considered to be "very advanced" by comparison with a "fully auto point and shoot, and then hand over the memory card to your local print shop" camera that requires virtually no interaction. Even for the modern microwave oven, you need to read and understand the book before you try to make it work (as I found out to my cost last year, when I did not do the latter!)

Most people who buy DLSRs have done their homework before they spent several (many??) hundreds of pounds on them, and let's face it, that these Pentax units are not cheap, and so are (or should ) not be bought without at least a little thought as to how they are going to be used!
OTOH, if you don't have a PC (which I assume you must, to be on this forum) or you don't want to try to deal with these issues, then I would seriously suggest that you take/send your camera to a decent dealer to get the work done - and he will probably then charge you around £30 to £50 for the priviledge.

BTW, although not quite yet retired, I am getting very close to that stage in my life as well!!

Comment by jeallen01 posted on K5 firmware question at 15/08/2011 - 20:32

jeallen01
helios wrote:
.
The warnings about the need to fully charge the battery and not interrupt the process of firmware installation are a bit scary though the actual process turns out to be surprisingly simple in retrospect.

The same goes for sensor cleaning - scary at first but easy once it has been successfully accomplished a few times.
Quote this post
Completely agree on both points.

The firmware upgrade is painless and very rapid - no more than 5mins (if that)- and I think you could probably do it several dozen times without charging the battery.
Just:
- connect the PC to the camera with a USB to microUSB lead
- Download the firmware to a new folder on your hard drive (or probably even the the "desktop")
- Run the self-extracting compressed file supplied to extract the BIN file
- Follow the camera instruction manual on how to set it up for the upgrade
- Run the BIN file
- Wait 5 mins or so until you get the upgrade completed message.
- Turn the camera OFF and then ON again.
-> job done!
OTOH, don't start with a battery that you have just used for a day's shooting!

OTOH No. 2, for sensor cleaning, you need the right kit or you may need several tries -> I started, "from scratch" (never having cleaned a sensor before or seen it done "live" and relying mainly on the instructions in the kit) on the GX10 with this kit http://www.cameraclean.co.uk/products.php?cat=Introductory+Cleaning+Kits
and it worked almost first time. Needed more swabs and fluid later though, and you can buy larger quantities from here and elsewhere - and after cleaning the sensors, and if used immediately, the used swabs are really first rate for cleaning lenses and filters.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on K5 firmware question at 15/08/2011 - 19:14

jeallen01
thoughton wrote:
The IQ of the Sigmas - especially the 1.4x - is good, but they only work with lenses with a recessed rear element, and they won't work with Sigma's HSM lenses.
I realise that - although maybe I did not clarify the points to sophiecentaur! - but what I was trying to point out was that a 1.4x T/C is a far more realistic prospect than a 2x.

Therefore a Kenko (etc.) 1.4 should be a viable solution, whereas a 2X might well not be - albeit, as you say that it would have to be used in manual focus mode. Again, a 2x would be less desirable as the viewfinder image would be dimmer, and so it would be more difficult to focus manually.

BTW - I think that HSM-compatible versions of both the 1.4x and 2x T/Cs are/soon will available (in Pentax mount??) for the Sigma HSM lenses.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Which MF Pentax Teleconverter Recommended? at 15/08/2011 - 11:07

jeallen01
sophiecentaur wrote:
Is there any up to date thinking on teleconverters? I have had my 60-250 for a while now and it gives excellent IQ. To have 500mm would be really useful for 'nature'. If I could achieve this with a 2X converter, without sacrificing too muchon quality, it would make my life complete (at least, for a while).
A word of caution: I have the both the Sigma 1.4x and the Sigma 2x (cost me a £100 new about 3 yrs ago!). I have tried them both with both the 70-200mm F2.8 and 100-300 F4 Sigmas (both non-OS), and I rarely use the 2x as it slows down the focusing no end, and the lock-on is much more iffy - sometimes it is OK, and other times not, especially if the light is not that good. Even then, the 1.4x always locks on quicker with either lens, and the more so with the 70-200 F2.8.

So, if you are shooting objects/animals that are fairly stationary at a fairly constant distance then you may get away with the 2x on an F4 lens - otherwise, if you shooting at something which is moving quickly and approaching/receding, then I would not recommend the 2x converters. That is particulary true with Pentax DSLRs where the autofocus - even on the K5 - is not as good as some competitors.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Which MF Pentax Teleconverter Recommended? at 14/08/2011 - 20:24

jeallen01
Probably nostalgia in the early days as I lusted for a Spotmatic or the like when I was young.

Then, when I could afford something to replace my Praktica B-series (which I still have ) I could just afford an MZ-5N & a 28-200mm Sigma - and so it went on from there, through a GX10 to the K-5.

The fact that I could still use the older lenses with the image stabilisation and weathersealing (airshows etc.!) that I bought for the MZ-5N was a bonus in the early days - but now with s/h long (not really long!) non O/S Sigmas I am very happy.

All of the stuff is pretty rugged (dropped the GX10 with 10-20 Sigi on its nose from waist height when the strap gave way - no damage at all except a cracked plastic Tiffin filter which took the direct impact with the floor!)

And I too am a bit of an individualist in the way I do things and don't go for the "me too" attitude. So it is interesting to go to airshows and be almost the only one not using Canikon (mainly Canon in practice).

OTOH, I do sometimes lust after some of the really "big" Canikon stuff with huge zooms stuck on the end,or on tripods because the damn things are so heavy that I think that I could barely even carry them - let alone actually take photos of moving objects with them! (could be the years catching up with me - but, not I think, entirely!)

The only thing I hope is that the K-5 does not get the sensor problem!!

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Why do you stay with pentax? at 11/08/2011 - 19:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo