George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
rparmar wrote:

The point about earlier Pentax DSLRs remains, however.
No, it doesn't. Shake reduction was not present in the early DSLRs.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Are You Satisfied at 04/08/2009 - 16:06

George Lazarette
I haven't stooped to personal remarks, Robin. I have attacked the fact that you have reviewed something you hadn't seen, and formed spurious conclusions as a result. If it is sad and pathetic to attack flawed methodology, then so be it.

I say your conclusions are spurious because other people who have actually owned and used the camera have not reported that they have an issue with the things you mention. No doubt the camera is not perfect, but viewed as a photographic tool, rather than as a design exercise, it seems to work just fine.

Perhaps your blog should be directed at designers and people in ivory towers, rather than at people who take pictures.

On here, we are more interested in how well something works in practice, rather than in your imagination.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Are You Satisfied at 04/08/2009 - 15:58

George Lazarette
I wonder if it would look better if the camera had been level? You would of course have to crop out more sky, and you might need a wider lens.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Mountain Panorama converted to mono at 04/08/2009 - 11:52

George Lazarette
rparmar wrote:
There are smaller cameras from other manufacturers (Olympus) as there have been from Pentax themselves.
Different format. Not comparable.

Quote:
Where I live I get no chance to handle Pentax gear. Yet I have bought many items on the basis of thorough research and comparison with items I can handle. If you grant me the right to praise gear you must grant me the right to critique it on the same basis.
I'm not into granting rights, but had you praised the camera your article would have had no more validity than the present one. Reviewing things unseen is a practice that does nobody any good at all.

Quote:
It doesn't take handling a camera to realise that two buttons placed close together might get in each other's way. It doesn't take a genius to realise that a change in button placement renders the camera ergonomically incompatible with previous bodies. An arbitrary change is never a good one.
If it's all so obvious, what was the point of your article?

Quote:
Designers work on paper before ever seeing a mock-up. They do so from experience. As I have done.

Besides, now I have handled the K-7 it has not changed my mind one bit. In fact I was even less excited by it than I had hoped. I would not change one word in the article based on my short time with the camera. (I guess I got lucky. Or maybe I was applying time-tested design principles?)
Or maybe you didn't try it for long enough, or maybe you weren't in the mood to admit you might have got it wrong.

Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:
And we really don't want Pentax NOT to do something just because Nikon has done it first. That argument doesn't wash.
I didn't make that argument.
I will let others be the judge of that. This is what you wrote:

"This is only for obtuse reviewers who complained there was no ISO button on previous models. There was, but it was labeled "OK". So now we have an extra button that provides no new functionality. And again, this is on the top surface. Could this be because this is how Canon does things?"

[QUOTE]It is not enough for a new body, especially one as hyped as this, to be just "good enough".[/quote]Pentax hasn't hyped it nearly enough, in the view of most people.

There are two problems with your article. One is that you reviewed something you hadn't even seen. The second is that you damned it ("I am truly sorry things turned out so negative!") largely on the basis of the placement of a couple of buttons.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Are You Satisfied at 04/08/2009 - 11:37

George Lazarette
Looks like the Spirit of Ecstacy letting herself unwind.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on With or without smoke a Rose will always be a Rose :) at 04/08/2009 - 00:38

George Lazarette
Bob, you're quite right, it is not an accurate representation of the scene in geographical terms, but it's still a good picture on its own merits (save for the rather dull bottom left quarter).

It's my favourite part of Britain, south of Hadrian's Wall. Tryfan has special memories for me as it was the first time I led a difficult climb. But that's many years ago.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Mountain Panorama converted to mono at 04/08/2009 - 00:29

George Lazarette
I concur!

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Takumar lenses? at 04/08/2009 - 00:14

George Lazarette
One of Pentax's traditional strengths has been to have lots of camera in a small, neat, ergonomic package. The K7 represents a return to that philosophy after the comparatively chunky K10D and K20D. I, for one, applaud the new design.

Robin, your article raises no important objections to the K7, and comes across as a bit picky. You recognise yourself that most of the changes will please some people, and it is inevitable that they won't please all.

It also seems a little odd to criticise a camera that you have never actually handled. Had you waited until you had done so, your article might have carried more weight.

And we really don't want Pentax NOT to do something just because Nikon has done it first. That argument doesn't wash.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Are You Satisfied at 04/08/2009 - 00:04

George Lazarette
You'll need the special remote software.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Direct Photo Preview at 03/08/2009 - 23:44

George Lazarette
The sad thing is that original Takumars were the very pinnacle of Japanese lens-making. They were superb both optically and mechanically.

If you can get hold of a good 55mm SMC Tak you will find the focus ring moves like silk lubricated with purest Jersey cream.

Makes me salivate just thinking about it.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Takumar lenses? at 03/08/2009 - 23:36

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo