fritzthedog

Joined: 25th July 2010

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

fritzthedog
The Sigma 120-400 is my lens of choice for airshows - even though I also have the 150-500 (the 120-400 being much easier to hand hold for long periods).

It generally handles things very well - unless the light is poor and the subjects are at distance and then it fails miserably.

Optically the DA*300 is a far superior lens but it is also twice the price and unless as David suggests, you carry two cameras - a little bit limiting at air shows where I often find I need to be shooting shorter than 300mm.


Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Sigma v Pentax longer lenses at 26/06/2014 - 08:18

fritzthedog
Plenty of whites around here - very little else at the moment

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Where have the Butterflies gone? at 22/06/2014 - 16:43

fritzthedog
At the risk of derision from the devotees - am I alone in thinking my Tamron SP AF 70-200mm F/2.8 Di LD [IF] is a superb lens that can deliver very pleasing results that (dare I say it) are up there with the legendary Pentax 60-250 for half the price?

Carl (taking cover behind a wall)

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Ephotozine review of the 60-250mm at 19/06/2014 - 08:59

fritzthedog
JohnX wrote:
The 18-250 and 18-270 are also available in their native 'Tamron' versions.

Since you want a 'walk about' lens, it's worth checking the weight of the lenses before you buy, as I personally find the weight of a lens increases exponentially in relation to how long I'm carrying it, especially when mounted on my K20D which itself is no light-weight. I found one answer was to upgrade the strap from the Pentax one.
John - although the 18-250 was available with a Tamron badge (owned 2 of them) unless I am mistaken - the 18-270 has never been released by Tamron in a Pentax mount.

I agree that weight can be a consideration - and we will all have different views on what constitutes heavy.

One of my favorite lenses is my Tamron 70-200 and at 1.2kg - to me that is a heavy lens to have around your neck as a walk-about.

At a shade over 450g - I don't think the 18-270 would be a problem and it is about 10% lighter than the Sigma 28-300

Totally agree that replacing the strap can be more comfortable - I use a very comfy neoprene one - twice as wide as the standard Pentax strap.

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Advice Needed at 19/06/2014 - 08:37

fritzthedog
Every couple of months I think - should I sell my Q? It does not get a lot of use - and then I pick it up and smile (it always make me smile) and decide that I should not sell it - I should learn how to use it properly and not just use it for point and shoot grab shots.

So - should you buy the Q10? - no you should not - it will get under your skin - you will not know why - and you will question your sanity - and then you will pick it up again and smile - darn it - time for my medication - nurse!!

Buy it - you know you want to

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Q10 at SRS prices at 19/06/2014 - 08:16

fritzthedog
Hi Mike

If 17-70 or 18-135 are not long enough for you as a walk-about the options become more limited.

Assuming you do not want to lose the wide range by opting for something like the Pentax 55-300, you are really looking at the 18-250 or 18-270 range.

Lenses covering this range will always be a compromise to some extent and often display tendencies towards softness at the extremes compared to lenses dedicated to these distances. These days - I choose to use a combination of 2 or 3 lenses to cover this range.

That said, I have owned several 'mega-zooms' over the years including the Pentax , Tamron and Samsung versions of the DA 18-250s (all intrinsically the same lenses with different badges and coatings) and accepting the limitations this sort of lens will have - all performed well with the Pentax version just edging it for me - probably down to the front element coating being different to the other versions.

Discontinued for a few years now - good used examples can be picked up for between £200 and £300

If I were looking for a new lens of this range now- I would probably go for the Pentax SMC DA 18-270mm f/3.5-6.3 SDM.

I have not used one personally but it gets good user revues and has been discussed on this forum and good reports received.

The downside of this lens was the price when it first came out a couple of years ago with a hefty £699 price tag. These days it can be picked up new for a little over the £400 mark from several retailers (£419 from our friends at SRS micro systems). I note there are a couple on ebay described as new/ demo models for just under the £400 mark.

Hope this helps

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Advice Needed at 19/06/2014 - 07:40

fritzthedog
MHP 84 wrote:
Its about 12 years old worked ok on my 2 old MZ30 films slrs and also istDL2. But have noticed that when its on the K20 the shots aren't quite sharp enough I don't know if its had a knock.

I've been thinking up to about £500 or so

it's a f3.5-6.3 DL Hyperzoom.

I'll try that JohnX.

Thanks guys
With that budget - there are many decent options. What sort of range do you prefer?

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Advice Needed at 18/06/2014 - 20:49

fritzthedog
Hi Mike

It's not clear whether you have used the lens on any other camera - if 'can't get on with it on my K20D' means you could get on with it on a different camera - then it may just be an adjustment is required?

If it is the DG macro f3.5-5.6 - it is a decent performer for the price but known to be a bit soft - especially at the long end.

Many options exist for a walk about - any everybody has a different opinion of what constitutes a walk-about. Budget is of course a major consideration - so to get any opinions of any use to you - it may be worth you saying what sort of price range you would be considering and what the main uses would be.

My preferred walk about lens is the Pentax DA 17-70

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Advice Needed at 18/06/2014 - 13:25

fritzthedog
Great shots - especially the little boy. Having been to Beamish 4 times this year already I wasn't planning on an other trip for some time but seeing these.......

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on Beamish Museum. at 18/06/2014 - 08:44

fritzthedog
Well done - you have managed to get a better Puffin shot than I have come close to at Bempton - they generally stay just too far away when I go,

Carl

Comment by fritzthedog posted on bempton at 17/06/2014 - 19:31

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo