All Forum Comments
Comment by fritzthedog posted on MobiCity at 24/08/2014 - 17:59
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on pentax M28,M50 Pentax F35-105mm . Cosina 19-35mm at 24/08/2014 - 17:38
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on Question to members going to Tickhill today at 24/08/2014 - 09:49
Has a meeting point/ time been arranged or is the event so compact that we will all trip over each other?
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on Question to members going to Tickhill today at 24/08/2014 - 09:08
Hi Carl, I love the Lighthouse images but for one significant thing. Composition is great, sharpness is great, colours are nicely saturated.
The thing that bothers me is that they both look yellow instead of white and this is not how they are in real life.
I think I mentioned something a while back about a yellow tinge on some of your images and it is very noticeable on these. Unfortunately because of this it spoils them for me.
The other pics you've posted here are superb too, but again they have the yellow tinge. I don't think this is intentional (is it?), maybe there is a settings issue somewhere on the camera or in post processing?
Sorry to give this feedback but I think it's best to be honest because I think it is holding back some of your shots from being absolute stunners.
Best wishes
David
All striking and effective images Carl, full of interest, depth and detail. The yellow saturation looks ok on the water generally, quite attractive there, but its coming over too strong on the rocks and grasses, and on the lighthouse too. I don't think its just white balance, I'd pull down the yellow channel a bit overall and see how that goes.
Would love to see them with any adjustments, it's an amazing bit of coastline and excellent images!
I have re-set them all to WB settings used in camera - does this correct it? If so - no idea what is going one - why would auto WB in LR4 give a yellow cast ?




Comment by fritzthedog posted on Creating a Cliche at 23/08/2014 - 19:51
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on Mono or Colour? at 23/08/2014 - 12:45
All taken on the K5IIs and Sigma 10-20 with a variety of Lee ND grads and a CPL
As always C+C welcome





Comment by fritzthedog posted on Creating a Cliche at 23/08/2014 - 11:35
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on anaother italian enthusiast at 23/08/2014 - 06:50
If we're talking about this one then I'm stunned to hear that.
It's my favourite lens and I have had 2 - 3 people ask if shots taken with it were taken with a prime and one was shocked that it wasn't. I wouldn't let it go for all the tea in China .... mind I don't drink tea but you know what I mean.
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on 55-300 Trade in value? at 20/08/2014 - 20:23
I actually thought the processed look on these was intentional and as Nigel says I quite like the slightly surreal appearance. Apart from that I think you've done really well to capture these Carl, I don't think you would have expected them all to be pin sharp would you?
Regards
David
Damn - I have been rumbled.
Truth is with the light conditions I had and the fact that I had resorted to a lens too short for the job - I did decide to process them to be a little different - but what I said about sharpening is true - I used no more than 20% max and most are much less than that - and there is a serious amount of noise reduction added - in some cases 100% - but I did boost various levels to create a slightly 'unreal' quality - especially in 1, 3 and 4.
1 is cropped to absolutely the max and is far from sharp enough - it seemed to work to create a slightly unreal quality by messing about with various levels
Interesting how different people react to this.
For what it's worth - for me - it works on some and not on others BUT I would have preferred a sunny day with winds below the 60mph we experienced!!
Carl
Comment by fritzthedog posted on Straightliners at 20/08/2014 - 20:10


As for SLR Hut - avoid.
Carl