All Forum Comments
Comment by Flink posted on RAW converters at 09/09/2005 - 14:56
You're right, I'm using it wrong; in fact, I'm doing nothing at all! All I did was load-convert. That's no way to use something like C1 or Bibble or ACR. I just wanted to see how all three programs "default converted" a difficult picture.
I will read the manuals, of course. In fact, I have already read CaptureONE's "online" help (the application's help), that I found very basic and uninformative. I have an apparently very good tutorial on C1 that I will read, and I will surely follow your indications! That's the whole point of this thread, really. If someone is to benefit from this, it has to be done by valuing everyone's view.
As for the response curve, every program has one. I was talking about the "shadows" and "highlights" settings (that end up changing the curve, no doubt, it's just another way to do it).
As regards to speed, I was not only refering to conversion speed, but to GUI speed and responsiveness as well (when you change curves, noise cancelation, etc).
From what I have seen, C1 has by far the best user interface of them all, simple, logical, effective and snappy. Bibble's interface is slower and generally less pleasing. ACR is nice, not fantastic but nicely done.
I want to talk about other things that diferentiate the three, like for example, C1's automatic hotpixel removal, Bibble's web gallery generation and Highlight Recovery, etc. I want to see how well they fit in the workflow and if the results are that significant.
Matt, I'll be very happy to hear you (and/or any of you in this forum) say "you're wrong" again, because it means we're learning how to do things right! There's no evolution without criticism.
Comment by Flink posted on RAW converters at 09/09/2005 - 14:43
So, I'm comparing CaptureONE 3.7.1, Bibble 4.3 and AdobeCameraRAW 3.1.
I've just started the comparison, and since I'm on a Mac I'm using a fresh install of MacOS X 10.4.1 Tiger. I calibrated my monitor with WizyWIG.
I started by picking a test shot with lots of dynamic range, dark shadows and bright, sunlit areas, and people (ladies with nice skin tones . Then I loaded the RAW file in all three programs and converted immediatly to JPG (high) using the default configurations.
Then I showed the three JPGs to my wife (we tend to be biased by the process). Our first impressions are these:
* C1 has WAY too much contrast. The shadows are nearly black. Small detail like earings almost loose their color.
* B4 is much better, shadows show a lot more and highlights are nice, and no problems on small detail like the earings.
* ACR is a bit better than B4. Great colors and great detail.
This is preliminary and ONE picture only. Also, Bibble asks for default configurations, and I chose the middle contrast setting, not the "normal". ACR has settings (auto and manual) for "shadows" and "highlights", wich I suspect change the tone curve. C1 and B4 had nothing similar (that I could find).
I will do a lot more testing with a lot more pictures, and I ask of you RAW veterans to guide this test so it can be as acurate and helpful as it can be.
Next phase: I'll pick a few shots (high ISO, high and low key, very colorful, underexposed, superexposed, etc.) and pass them through all the converters, trying to get the "best" possible result. In the process, I'll take notes about user interface usability, special features and speed of each converter.
Help me out, please!
Comment by Flink posted on RAW converters at 09/09/2005 - 11:15
I have also bought a generic M42 to Pentax-K adaptor on eBay, but it came without a small piece of metal I see on other adapters. I think it functions as a "fixator", in that the small metal tab clicks into a groove to avoid the adaptor coming off. My adaptor has a small place and hole where that metal tab should be, but it is not there. It worked on my MZ-50, but it would not click-stop like a real K-mount lens (haven't tried it on my DS yet). Anyway, I have heard of a few horror stories about generic adaptors like these getting jammed on the body...
Like most people on this forum, I try to stick to Pentax glass (although I sure would like to try a few M42 Carl Zeiss lenses to see what all the fuss is about).
Comment by Flink posted on Caution, do not stop on the tracks (non-Pentax K mount lens) at 09/09/2005 - 09:51
Actually, in my case, having the opportinity to shoot in digital, with all the convenience it brings, made me want to shoot in film a bit, too. I may actually be very far from your average "95%" photographer, but once I had my *ist DS (that I love and take with me almost wherever I go) I started to look at photography with much more interest.
Nothing ever beats digital, but I am shooting some film just for the fun of it, trying out Fuji and Kodak and Ilford and Agfa film, exploring the differences, and developing B&W film myself. Again, just for fun.
So, I believe we shouldn't have these kinds of quarrels about "this is better than that". Digital reigns supreme, but film (I hope) will remain as a hobby of many interested photographers (and probably as the main workflow of some niche markets).
For me, digital has rekindled my interest in film. Mainly because of digital's convenience and price, I can now explore film.
Comment by Flink posted on I am fed up with everyone telling me digital is convenient ! at 10/10/2005 - 14:12
Nevertheless, as stupid as that might seem, I WANTED a film camera as well. And I bought a second and Pentax SFXn.
I like film. I haven't really thought much about it, so I don't really know why. It can be because of the curve in the highlights, because I love B&W film contrast and dynamic range, because the camera makes this BZZZZZT sound after the mirror's, because it feels real, feels permanent. Or because there really is something diferent in film pictures. Everything I said may or may not make sense to you...
I have a mini-lab develop the film and make a PhotoCD out of it, with minimum modifications (I have had them develop B&W prints from the negative, but they RUIN my photos! I scanned the negative and made prints exactly as I intended). I always take my SFXn with me when I can, to acompany my DS.
Life's good!
Comment by Flink posted on I am fed up with everyone telling me digital is convenient ! at 08/09/2005 - 17:32
I have the Cokin A series and will buy their UV (as soon as I can find one) for testing. Any experiences from you experienced folk?
Comment by Flink posted on UV filters on Digital *istDs at 30/08/2005 - 18:05
Anyway, last year I developed an application for an embedded system that would go aboard buses (UMTS real-time flight information and publicity movies). It used WinXP Embedded (that's what the Japanese bundled it with) and it was a Pentium III 700Mhz with 64MB RAM. I struggled to get movies playing decently on the damn thing and I was doing it programatically and had full control on movie size and compression! Remember, WinXP Embedded is much lighter (they strip out a lot of stuff you end up needing, oh well...) than XP PRO, and I had the same 64MB RAM, so no wonder you can't play them.
P.S.: You could squeeze more juice out of that machine if you instaled a nice, light version of Linux. Try one of those bootable CD's and see what you can make of it.
Comment by Flink posted on pentax optio s5z video clip playback problem at 26/08/2005 - 20:24
Ah, well. Guess I will just have to avoid shooting the sun with it and find a good lens hood (any ideas?).
Since I'm at it, is there anyone here using the Cokin A Series filter system? I find it most flexible, and I have a ND8 and a circular polarizer (couldn't find the UV filter yet), with adapters to fit all my lenses (49, 52 and 68mm).
Comment by Flink posted on Pentax F 28-80mm - Cokin system at 24/08/2005 - 15:56
It's this way: http://www.digital.pentax.co.jp/
On that site, you can access not only Digiichi, but the special sites of the Pentax *ist DS and Pentax *ist DL. These are (methinks) quite good as a presentation of these cameras to anyone who is choosing a new DSLR to purchase.
Comment by Flink posted on Pentax Launch DSLR WebSite at 24/08/2005 - 10:01


The trials are here:
CaptureONE: http://www.phaseone.com/Content/Downloads.aspx
Bibble: http://www.bibblelabs.com/system/download_new.jsp
ACR: http://www.adobe.com/products/tryadobe/main.jsp#product=39
I use Apple's iPhoto to tweak and manage my photo archive, so I come from a great workflow experience. I'll describe my RAW workflow here so you all can comment and see if it is for you or not.
But just don't shun it without giving it a try first. You may be surprised!