Flink

Joined: 17th May 2005

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Flink
Yes Drew, thanks, I had already seen the link you gave and my DS's firmware (1.0).

The problem happens only with the Tokina. None of my other lenses exhibit this behavior, so there is nothing wrong with my DS.

Oh, and something I didn't clarify earlier: when I said the Tokina was sharp, I didn't mean to say it is very sharp in a general sense (although this is exactly what I said), but that it is sharper than I was expecting of a 59 Euro 28-105 lens.

Actually, it is very consistent in sharpness from wide open to F8. Most of my other lenses are a lot sharper stopped down than wide open. The Tokina doesn't have too much CA as well, but I don't like it's color reproduction much... I simply love Pentax's color.

All of my Pentax lenses beat it in sharpness stopped down a bit. And when it comes to veiling and flare, there simply is *NO* comparison.

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 23/11/2005 - 22:12

Flink
Kimbo, thanks for your time.

Indeed, you're right. None of my Pentax lenses exhibit the Tokina's simptoms. Changing the aperture does not change the focus point.

But I have been doing more tests and, at 28mm, the Tokina really changes the focus point as I change from F3.5 to F8. At 105mm however, focus seems to be spot on. In manual focus, the focus confirmation reacts in exactly the same way.

If I set the aperture at F8 and focus I always have good focusing, so I will be using it like this, and opening up after focusing if needs be.

I'll also upgrade my firmware and see if that makes any difference.

Thanks again!

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 22/11/2005 - 22:37

Flink
Blimey!

Matt is correct! The body is trying to focus on the hyperfocal distance!

I gave it a quick try during lunch; I set the body on Aperture priority, wide open (F/3.5), point at some infinity (distant mountains) and my DS wasn't able to focus (it moved to infinity and made that sound of wanting to go further, stopping and blinking the autofocus confirmation hexagon). Then I changed the aperture to F/11, and the body focused to about 5 meters... and I was still pointing the lens at infinity.

The body is actually trying to focus on the hyperfocal distance, and failing miserably. When wide open, it probably is trying to back-focus again, but since there is no more room to go... it stops with the warning.

How did I never realize that the focus point was connected with the aperture before?! I don't remember reading about this anywhere...

I'll give it another go later in the evening when I arrive home.

P.S.: I was/am enamoured with a Tokina 28-70 F/2.6-2.8 , and I purchased the 28-105 as it was a cheap (59Euro) one to see the Tokina characteristics... now I'm afraid the same will happen with the more expensive lens...

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 17/11/2005 - 14:55

Flink
Ok, take a look at these pics; they're cropped and scaled, but you'll be able to see the effect even at these scaled sizes (otherwise the pics would be gigantic to post).

From top to bottom, I tried to focus on the 28-80's numbers, then on the water bottle's barcode and then on the TV's remote "Sanyo" logo. Here's the 35-80's pics:

Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image


And now the Tokina's pics, focused on exactly the same places:

Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image


Those are all wide open, 1/30sec at 35 F/4 and 28 F/3.5 respectively. The conditions are not the best to test, I know. But if the differences can be seen so easily here, on better condittions it would be even more evident.

I've read some Sigmas have focusing problems. I've read about a Canon user who says Canon's AF system is... different in his own words, and the Sigma 18-200 does a lot of front-focus. He also says he can solve it by re-focusing on the same spot, but my DS doesn't move an inch when already "focused". In fact, it does this with every lens, and the Canon's autofocus was something I saw in a store while trying the 300D: the focus would hunt around if focusing on the same spot several times...

I'm still thinking that the DS' body should have full control over the focus... and I still don't understand where exactly is that the lens comes into the equation (unless Matt is right and the body calculates (erroneosly) the hyperfocal distance)...

I might try to update the firmware... where exactly can I see wich one I have?

Thanks!

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 17/11/2005 - 08:14

Flink
Kimbo and Matt,

Yes, I get focus confirmation on manual focusing (on the wrong place), either by slowly focusing from back to front or from front to back. I'm using Select Focus Point (on the center, and I've tried Single Center, it's the same). And I kept my fingers on the (generous) focus ring; no movement is taking place after the autofocus beeps and during the shutter work.

The Pentax PhotoBrowser reports the lens as... well... as unkown. It reports "-- -- --" where it normally reports the full names of my Pentax lenses. The aperture and focal length are well reported on the EXIF info as F/3.5 and 28mm respectively.

It does a much better job at 105mm, autofocusing practically perfectly... this is really weird.

As for another AF body, I have a Pentax SFXn, but 28mm on the SFXn is too wide to be able to discern focus on the viewfinder... I can't really see if focus is right. I'll have to shoot some film and develop it to check.

As for local dealers... here in Portugal that's a bit difficult. I'll try to see if I can contact Tokina to see if there is something that can be done. Either that or www.foto-schneider.de where I bought the lens (via eBay).

Do you think I should upgrade my *ist DS' firmware? How can you see wich firmware mine has (didn't find anything on the net after a quick search).

Thanks!

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 16/11/2005 - 22:35

Flink
I am so baffled by this that I didn't even describe the culprit! I'm talking about my new Tokina AF205 28-105mm F3.5-4.5. The body is my *ist DS.

In fact, the first time I used the lens at an event (my mother-in-law's birthday) all the photos taken with the Tokina had bizarre focus points... I thought I just had too much french champagne that day to be able to compose right.

Then I made a small test (wich I think I already mentioned here) were the Tokina surprised me by being very sharp, even wide open. It's very susceptible to flare and veiling, but I could live with that. Thing is, I made that test with all lenses manually focused.

But this time (in the international chocolate festival), I realized the lens really has a problem, although I cannot understand how on earth can this be; save for a few taken to maximize DOF, all pics were back-focused. Badly.

Yesterday, I made another small test: I went outside and auto-focused on some leaves in my backyard. The effect can be seen in naked-eye on the viewfinder: in 28mm, it never focuses the leaves I wanted! It seems to do a better job at bigger focal lengths; for example, at 105mm it seems to focus right.

Then I took the lens in and did a small head-to-head with two of my zooms: a Pentax SMC 18-55 and a Pentax 35-80. The test involved three objects at about 80cm from the camera, separated by 15cm each in a line going away from the camera. I took three shots, focusing on each object, and I wanted to see only one object in focus. The lenses were all wide open to minimize DOF.

The Pentaxes did marvelously well (I think the 18-55 is actually quite a good lens except at 18mm wide open where the corners are bof-bof, and the 35-80 actually surprises me with it's image quality), but the Tokina focused the wrong object all the time. I mean, when I focused the first it (more or less) focused the one behind it.

I can see it with my own eyes, but I still can't understand it! Any ideas?

I'll post some pictures later in the evening.

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 16/11/2005 - 08:19

Flink
Can someone help me with this one?

Is it possible for a lens to have back-focus? I mean, with the body in autofocus, the lens focuses consistently further away than the point the body marks as focused.

I tried several lenses on the same body, and only this one exibits this characteristic... I thought the SAFOX system worked by phase-matching, so there was no way a lens could not be focused right... unless the system had a problem, in wich case ALL lenses would focus wrong... and that is not my case.

Does this make any sense? Did anyone have similar experiences? Thanks!

Comment by Flink posted on Help! Lens with back-focus?! at 15/11/2005 - 21:40

Flink
Here's the new baby:

Comment Image



Comment Image


Pretty, isn't it?

Comment by Flink posted on Tokina AF205 28-105mm F/3.5-4.5 at 27/10/2005 - 22:49

Flink
Has anyone had this lens? Can anyone comment on it? On digital and film (i.e. on APS-C or full-frame)? What is your general experience with Tokina lenses? People here seem to prefer Tamron after Pentax, and Sigma seems to have the good (EX?), the bad, and the ugly! But I rarely hear about Tokina.

I have just bought a new Tokina AF205 28-105mm F/3.5-4.5, firstly because I've been wanting to try out a Tokina lens (joining my manual-focus Vivitar zoom and Tamron 24mm) and secondly because I wanted a walk-around lens for my *ist DS to substitute my Pentax-F 28-80 F/3.5-4.5(non-SMC) that would give me:

1. 50cm or less minimum focusing distance (instead of 1 meter)
2. Internal focus (so that I can use my polarizer decently... oh, and a hood, too)
3. At least 3.5-4.5 speed (to match the 28-80)
4. If possible, a tiny bit longer reach on both ends
5. Less problems with flare and veiling (my 28-80 is not SMC and has lots of flare/veiling)

I intended to buy the Pentax-FA 28-105 F/3.2-4.5 new to replace my 28-80 (mainly because of the problems in the points above and the zoom ring is too tight), but since I could not afford it for now, I decided to get the Tokina now and get the Pentax maybe for Christmas.

Having used the 28-80 for a while, I think 28mm is enough for most of my "wide-angle" needs in digital, and 80mm is just nice as telephoto. My wife is not very keen on waiting for me to change lenses... so having a good do-it-all-but-not-exagerating-like-a-18-200-zoom is a Good Thing for me.

I made a few tests against the Pentax-F 28-80 F/3.5-4.5(non-SMC), a Pentax-F 35-80 F/4-5.6, a Vivitar MC 35-70 F/2.8-3.8, and the "incontournable" Pentax-A 50mm F/1.7.

I would like to hear some of your opinons about it before I say what I think about the Tokina optically.

Mechanically the lens is actually quite nice; a bit big and heavy with it's almost 500g, but with a very pleasant grip on the zoom and focus rings (the focus could have more damping, but I guess that's normal on an autofocus lens) and an all-metal construction it feels sturdy and great to handle.

Thanks!

Comment by Flink posted on Tokina AF205 28-105mm F/3.5-4.5 at 27/10/2005 - 16:03

Flink
Well... I'm not a professional photographer.

For all you Pros, get a load at Apple's Aperture.

http://www.apple.com/aperture

The software seems everything a Pro would want about RAW workflow... I settled on Bibble (hope I can group all my notes together and do a post here), but Aperture is so much more! Aperture alone is probably reason enough for a Pro to get a Dual Core, Dual Processor PowerMac G5 plus 2 30'' displays...

But... no Pentax RAW support! Doh! Maybe in the next revision? Please Apple!

P.S.: Still, 500 USD still is five times Bibble's or CaptureONE's price...

Comment by Flink posted on Apple's Aperture at 19/10/2005 - 22:26

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo