All Forum Comments
Comment by Flink posted on Bokeh wonderings at 04/09/2008 - 15:05
I cannot stress enough just how powerful the 24-90 is. I've had quite a few lenses on my Pentax for comparison, and I'm also the incredibly happy owner of a 31mm and 77mm Limiteds.
For me, the 24-90 is simply amazing; it's really a zoom with a soul. The bokeh and rendition is just beautiful. I goes for crazy prices on eBay, but I don't think anyone could have one for a few days and say "people over-hype the 24-90". Carl Zeiss glass, on the other hand, is also going for crazy prices but it IS over-hyped to death, methinks.
Have fun,
--
Flink
Comment by Flink posted on SMC A-Zoom 28-135 F/4 at 19/03/2008 - 14:51
Niblue has one of those, I guess, and he seems to like it. Nevertheless, the Pentax-K 50mm F/1.2 is going for very affordable prices on the Bay. I sold mine a couple of months ago for less than that value (and now I kind of regret it... but the money for the 77mm had to come from somewhere).
Remember that ultrafast manual focus lenses are very hard to focus when wide open... it seems easy on the viewfinder, but you usually have only a few milimeters of DOF to play with at 1.2... that was the other reason I sold mine.
Have fun!
Comment by Flink posted on Porst 55/1.2 at 11/02/2008 - 13:41
I expect it to be much smaller and lighter and also much cheaper. It will probably be almost as fast (F/2 at least). Since there is no way on earth they can improve the performance, I hope they can at least stay close.
It might just be the best lens Pentax has ever made (or will the 55mm F/1.4 steal that crown?).
--
Flink
Comment by Flink posted on New 55, 60-250, and 17-70 Announced at 31/01/2008 - 15:21
DA 35mm (non-macro, faster than F/2.
DA* 50mm F/1.4
DA 17-70mm
--
Flink
P.S.: If the 18-55 II really is an improvement over the first version (for bigger sensors), it should be an even greater lens on the 6MP bodies!
Comment by Flink posted on New lenses announced at last!!! at 29/01/2008 - 10:12
We're spoiled, I think.
It's often good just to take a single lens and be done with it
Matt
Just a note of warning: don't buy any of the Limiteds unless you know you'll be able to keep them. I've thought of trading one of my Limiteds for a cheaper alternative to finance a K10D, but I simply can't part with them now. No way. Hu-hu,
Comment by Flink posted on Building your own set of lenses in Pentax World at 04/12/2007 - 14:50
Funny you said that about the 50s... I just bought an FA. I don't think I'll have the cash for the DA*. The 77mm really drained my budget, I even sold a K1.2 for that. But I'll keep an eye on the DA*, also because my *ist DS is missing too much shots because of intermittent AF problems (I dropped it a couple of months ago) and I may have to get a K100D Super with SDM (using the leftover of sales). Or is the K10D a better bet in the long run?!...
Clarky, I sold the 300/4 because it was a 1Kg beast, a joy to use indeed but there was no way I was going to lug it along with me all the time. It gave impressive results, even wide open, and focused like a dream. I just couldn't justify having it (no matter how cool it looked in my kit), even if it was the A version.
As for the 16-45, I'm waiting to see if I can afford it. I guess Pentax is at blame here; if they made a cr**py kit zoom, we'd all have a 16-45.
Hefty : it really is amazing how we all build our kit in so many different ways! It seems to be a strength of Pentax world; the choice is so big we can have several valid kits for all sorts of purposes. Is it like this on the other side of the fence?
Thanks all for your comments!
--
Flink
Comment by Flink posted on Building your own set of lenses in Pentax World at 04/12/2007 - 09:27
In the end, I tried to adere to the Riley Rule and took some aditional advice from the other veterans in this forum. I ended up selling everything I had to purchase what I really wanted. I now have a lot less lenses, but they work together, they all get used and I love the results and flexibility they give me.
My present kit is comprised of:
Zooms:
SMC Pentax-DA 18-55mm F/3.5-5.6 AL
SMC Pentax-FA 24-90mm F/3.5-4.5 AL
SMC Pentax-FA 80-320mm F/4.5-5.6
Vivitar 70-210mm F/3.5 (manual focus)
Primes:
SMC Pentax-FA 31mm F/1.8 Limited
SMC Pentax-A 50mm F/1.4 (manual focus)
SMC Pentax-FA 77mm F/1.8 Limited
M42 curiosities: (all manual focus, obviously)
Pentacon MC 29mm F/2.8
Meyer Optik Gorlitz Lydith 30mm F/3.5
Helios 58mm F/2
Schneider Kreuznach 50mm F/2.8
Some lenses I've tried (but no longer own):
Pentax SMC K 17mm F/4
Pentax SMC K 55mm F/1.8 (and all the 50s in manual focus)
Pentax SMC K 300mm F/4
Pentax SMC M 24-35mm F/3.5
Pentax SMC M 100mm F/2.8
Pentax SMC A 50mm f/1.7
Pentax SMC F 24-50mm F/4
Pentax SMC F 35-80mm f/4-5.6
Pentax SMC F 28-80mm f/3.5-4.5 (non-SMC)
Vivitar MC 35-70mm f/2.8-3.8
Vivitar MC 28mm F/2.8
Tamron BBAR 24mm F/2.5
Revuenon MC 35mm F/2.8
Revuenon MC 135mm F/2.8
Tokina AT-X Pro AF280 28-80mm F/2.8
Tokina AF205 28-105mm F/3.5-4.5
Misc:
Pentax Crossover bag
Pentax AF400T flash
Pentax AF400FTZ flash
Vivitar 2x Helicoidal Macro adapter
The zooms:
The 18-55 is very controversial; while no-one has any doubts that it is the best of all kit lenses out there (in all respects), some love it (i.e., gives quite nice results) and some hate it (soft corners and vignetting at 18mm). I love it. While it is not the best lens out there, it's good enough to play the role of the wide-portrait flexible zoom in my kit. The rendition is very nice, with good, soft bokeh, great contrast and well controlled aberrations. Sharpness is not all I search for in a lens. Alternatives: the 16-45 is the obvious one, right? While it is impossible to use with the embedded flash (the zoom is "inverted", it's bigger and heavier, the results seem to be much more consistent and 16mm really is wider and worth it. Then there is the Sigma 17-70, wich is praised everywhere. Pentax is also (hopefully) coming up with it's own 17-70. Humm...
I'm in love with my 24-90 (thanks George!). It's a zoom with a soul. It has a great reputation and for good reason. For my kind of picture-taking it's the perfect focal length range. I prefer longer than wider. It's sharp, and the bokeh is beautiful. Portraits look sublime, the extra reach and speed are really helpful here. On the other hand it is a bit big (mainly at 90mm where it extends a lot) and heavy. The build feel and materials could be much better (feels wobbly, it's got a plastic body). 24mm is not very wide, though, so if you always like to shoot wide this might not be your lens. When I foresee I need wider I mount the 18-55. But I just can't get enough of the 24-90! Alternatives: Probably none. The offer is so good on the 18-somethings (Pentax has the 18-250 and will have a 17-70 too) that if you need a longer zoom you don't have to sacrifice the wide angle. The 24-90 is a very special lens, so it's on a class of it's own on digital.
The 80-320 is a good telephoto zoom on digital. It has great rendering, smooth bokeh (the 8 blades help), vivid colors and generally good sharpness. On the other hand it's a bit too soft from 200mm on, it's very slow to focus (on my DS at least), it's huge, and has a problem that happens on many samples (mine lost the A setting). All in all, a decent choice but I believe there is better out there. Alternatives: The 50-200 seems nice, bokeh and rendition seems quite good, plus it's a lot smaller and lighter. The Sigma 70-300 APO also seems to be popular. What do you recommend in this area?
The Vivitar 70-210 is a legendary lens. It's very sharp, and very fast (F/3.5 constant). I have wonderful shots with it. It is clearly not as good as a Pentax when it comes to contrast, veiling and flare, but bokeh and rendition is quite pleasant. A pleasure to use this old portraits goodie when there is time to focus and compose.
Missing pieces:
I need a wide angle zoom. Although I'm not a wide person, I sometimes find myself wanting wider than 18mm. I'm thinking about the 10-17mm fisheye; it's veeeery wide at 10mm, I like to use the fisheye effect creatively (I had an 17mm FE wich I loved), it doesn't distort that much at 17mm and I think I can defish when I really need corrected perspective. On the other hand, aberrations and purple fringing seem to be huge... The alternatives are perhaps the Sigma 10-20 or the Pentax 12-24, amply discussed here, but they are a bit too expensive for the use they would get.
Then there's a couple of old manual focus zoom lenses I'd like to try: the Vivitar 35-80mm F/2.8 and the Angénieux 70-210mm F/3.5. Anyone has any info on these two?
The primes:
The 31mm is a legend, the best lens I've ever seen, in all respects, no exceptions. It is considered by some as the best autofocus prime lens in the World, and I'm inclined to agree. The shots have a little "something" to them... Alternatives: Obviously, the Pentax 35mm F/2. For about one third the money, it seems to be a great normal lens on digital and much better value for money than the 31mm. Also, it's smaller and lighter. The Sigma 30mm 1.4 seems huge and heavy, but ultra-fast; does anyone have one?
The 50mm F/1.4 is your can't-go-wrong lens. It's wonderfull in all respects, and rendering is second to none. The bokeh is amazing, it's very fast, it's softness wide open is great for portraits on digital, sharpens up really quickly when stopping down, it's small and light. It may have a touch of CA, but you won't notice it in most shots. I most definitely recommend the autofocus version; manual focusing a 1.4 shot is a game of chance. Alternatives: Most 50mm lenses are pretty good. The Pentax 1.7 is great, sharper than the 1.4 when wide open, but I think the bokeh is not as nice.
The 77mm is the matching legend to the 31mm, and probably the only lens that will make you rethink the 31mm's position. Although purple fringing is a bit on the high side to my tastes in some situations, there is just "something" on the 77mm shots that can't be quantified, and that makes the shots unique (just like the 31mm).
Missing pieces:
1. The 50mm 1.4 in autofocus (F or FA). Do you think it's worth waiting for the DA* 55mm F/1.4? I'm afraid it might be too close to the 77mm. In fact, I'm considering getting the 43mm Limited instead of the 50FA 1.4; I think it might be a better compromise between the 31 and the 77. What do you think?
2. A longer (100-ish), macro lens. My desire is a Voigtlander 125mm F/2.5. The Pentax macros all seem to be wonderfull too, and in manual focus probably much cheaper than the Voigtlander.
Bottom line:
The 31mm and the 77mm together form what is, perhaps, the best two primes in the World, such is their symbiose on digital (a normal and a portrait), at least to my shooting habits. Results are consistently stunning (and I'm not only talking about sharpness). The 24-90mm completes the trio of dreams, wich I love to carry around. My Crossover bag normally takes the 24-90 on the body, the 31 and the 77. If needs be, I can squeeze in the 50, or the 18-55, and a flash. Or even the 80-320 (instead of the 77).
I'm a happy Pentax shooter!!
Your comments are welcome and apreciated! I'll post some pictures taken with my kit. If you want info on some of the other lenses (and maybe some pics), just ask.
--
Flink
Comment by Flink posted on Building your own set of lenses in Pentax World at 03/12/2007 - 21:31
My 50mm F/1.4 and 77mm F/1.8 could easily attest that (as could many more primes, even old M42, K and M).
The other thing, in my humble opinion, is rendering (but that's not measurable, so I guess it doesn't count for many people).
--
Flink
Comment by Flink posted on Pentax 18-250 or Tamron 18-250 at 13/12/2007 - 23:36
Thanks,
--
Flink
Comment by Flink posted on Voigtlander APO-Lanthar 125mm/2.5 SL at 13/11/2007 - 16:35


I think that many lenses do pretty well with big bokeh. Small bokeh, on the other hand, is very difficult to handle and only a selected few please me.
Also, as said before, the aperture influences bokeh a lot. I found some very different performances from wide open to stopped down in the same lens.
I think the rendering of highlights is also difficult for a lens, sometime even when the rest of the bokeh is pretty soft and buttery.
This is all a bit subjective, but I will try to post some shots (and try to illustrate the issue) when I get home. One lens alone amazes me time and time again, in all situations: the Pentax 31mm Limited.