fatspider

Joined: 11th June 2006

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

fatspider
Quote:
So, when a painting is photo-realistic, it's not art?
Does that also apply to drawn or painted canvas's too then The work of a cetain Japanese erotic "artist" springs to mind here, I once had some of his work set as a desktop wallpaper and several people mistook it for a photograph.

Anyway, I think George just hit the nail on the head with his last post.

Comment by fatspider posted on Artist or Photographer? at 20/10/2009 - 17:58

fatspider
The portrait crop is the best one, there is far too much distraction in the original and the crop allows us to be more focused on the ladybird.
I also get the feeling the image now tells a story and that the bug is heading for disaster when it falls into that rather large (to a bug) black hole

Comment by fatspider posted on ladybird crop advise at 20/10/2009 - 17:45

fatspider
This was a quick fix I use for a lot of images, it saves using a graduated ND filter on camera to darken the sky.
In Photoshop select the entire image using the rectangular marque tool then enter quick masque mode, I then select the gradient tool and draw a line up the middle (bottom to top) then exit the quick masque, this leaves a graduated selection from top to bottom, ie; whatever you do to the image with adjustments, levels curves, contrast etc. the top half will be affected more than the bottom, I then just play around with the levels.

Comment by fatspider posted on Dark clouds are gathering ... at 20/10/2009 - 01:32

fatspider
I would lose the cars and houses on the right, keeping just the edge of the climbing frame in the image, then I would adjust the levels in the top half of the image to darken the sky and bring out the colour of the foilage.

[IMG]http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j168/impotentspider/4567a-kl-ps.jpg[/IMG]

PS: I'll delete this image in a couple of weeks so if your late reading the thread it wont be here

Comment by fatspider posted on Dark clouds are gathering ... at 20/10/2009 - 01:06

fatspider
Well it seems I've got it almost right, one thing is for sure and that is I dont like HDR

The software tends to exagerate saturation and contrast, it may well even out the exposure but at the expense of looking like a scene from Chernobyl

I think I'll stick to using the software for balancing out exposures.

Quote:
Looks good to me. It's not quite centred, but I'm being picky.
Your probably right George, I was rushing to get the tripod set up and five exposures taken before another bunch of tourists came in, plus I think theres some distortion from the lens (16-50DA*) on the wooden rail at the bottom of the image, though I do have them as RAW files so may be able to correct that with another attempt

Comment by fatspider posted on Another go at HDR at 20/10/2009 - 00:55

fatspider
I find it a bit...dare I say "bland"? it needs a bit more contrast and saturation or going the other way and turning it into a B&W. Apart from that I quite like the composition and suns rays breaking through the clouds.

I dont know how you'd fare with increasing the contrast though as there already looks to be burned out areas in the clouds.

Comment by fatspider posted on Autumn sunrise - does it work for you? at 19/10/2009 - 18:40

fatspider
I think the answer is simple Ted, we are ALL Photographers, except for those who also dabble with watercolours and such like.

I think the real question is "is photoography art" I dont see any problem myself with classing a photograph as a work of art but when all is said and done it was produced by a Photographer and not an artist.

And to take the argument one step further who is to say that even Artists are actually Artists, you only have to see some of the cr@p that wins the Turner prize to answer that.

Comment by fatspider posted on Artist or Photographer? at 19/10/2009 - 18:34

fatspider
Following on from my first efforts heres a five image HDR composition, I find the "out of the box" image that the software produces is way over the top, maybe HDR isn't for me? I found with this one the red carpet was more like a flourescent safety jacket, and that is no exageration, I hade to tone down the saturation slider to virtually nothing to get the result below.

This is an interior of Balquhidder Church in the Trossachs, probably more famous for the grave of Rob Roy in the churchyard.

And yes, the ceiling beams do look a bit on the dark side but that is a result of toning down the brightness and saturation to get the carpet looking a reasonable colour.

[IMG]http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j168/impotentspider/_K209165HDRsmll.jpg[/IMG]

constructive or destructive C&C welcome as always

Comment by fatspider posted on Another go at HDR at 19/10/2009 - 18:24

fatspider
Quote:
The problem with most HDR pictures is that it's so obvious they are HDR
I understand your point George, I'm not keen on overcooked HDR myself and I ran through the process again to see where I went wrong (if indeed I did).

The software has several sliders that can be adjusted after merging the images, these range from Brightness, Saturation, Vivid Colours, Dynamic Light Radius etc etc.

I didnt like the result presented to me so played around with the sliders, I actually reduced the levels on all of them till I was happy with the shot, the result is an image very close to my middle exposure (the cameras evaluation of the scene) with the exception of a darker sky and a reduction in the overall saturation of the sunlit mountain, I suppose I could have achieved the same result by adjusting the one image in Photoshop

Back to the drawing board I think as I would like to lighten that left hand side up a little more. After that I have a five shot church interior to tackle

Comment by fatspider posted on First serious HDR attempt at 18/10/2009 - 18:01

fatspider
I did think the dark area on the left should have come out lighter, I used Dynamic Photo HDR for the conversion.
The darker areas are much lighter on my third exposure than shown in the finished HDR, though not quite as light as the ones in Johns example, Looks like I'll have to play around with the software a bit more or even try it with a five exposure shot.

Comment by fatspider posted on First serious HDR attempt at 18/10/2009 - 10:19

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo