Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Right, time to judge.

BTW I missed out Xmas in my post above (I was tired!). It should have read 'traditional last minute Xmas rush' - I wasn't moaning about late entries! Quite the contrary, for a while it looked like I'd only have a few to choose from, which was disappointing. I think that if I'm setting a fortnightly again I'm going to have to go for something blatantly wide (tried that!) open to interpretation. I'd thought that Juxtaposition was broad enough to encourage lots of people to unleash their Pentax, but even some recent regulars haven't posted. I guess - as with the judging - the Xmas rush probably hasn't helped (and I know that Prieni at least is on holiday). Anyway, on to judging...

I’ve been quite surprised by people’s interpretations – which is a good thing. Just one entry used juxtaposition in the way that I anticipated would probably be a common interpretation – juxtaposition of near and far objects.

Hyram – Ancient & Modern
Great sign – I guess you really have to watch out for those surfers at high tide down Porte St. Thomas! And an interesting juxtaposition of something harsh and garishly modern and something soft and aged. I do feel your usual knack of capturing great light hasn’t really happened here. The light’s a bit dull in the f/g, and rather harsh in the b/g (is the sky blown?). Good humour content, though!

Bob & his Pentax – Red Arrows
collecting coffee to go
Boy, those Red Arrows seem to be able to fly in the tightest spaces! Good example of how much you get in the frame with Fishy – no other (current) lens could have included all the planes. Though, of course, this brings compositional challenges which are also demonstrated here – the severed people and escalator, and the blown window area on the right. I also find the light a bit dull in this shot – looks like it would probably be boosted in levels (have you used these here?).

David Trout – Security & management
Quality shot with a nice injection of wry humour (always a big bonus in my book). A really interesting juxtaposition too – helped by the well-chosen title (which is fine – it’s photos that require commentary to persuade you of their relevance that are problematic for me). I like the B&W conversion too which I’m sure works much better than in colour – here we can really concentrate on the people and their expressions, which are just great. Love the guard’s shifty sideways glance in particular – almost like he’s expecting trouble. If I had to be picky, I think the guard’s face is slightly less crisp than the management’s (perhaps he moved) – but really who cares, the important thing is you captured the moment.

Lilly – Two wet cholis
This was a pleasant surprise – an entry from Lilly in India-aargh! Had left a brazen hint (to drum up entries) about the juxtapositional content of a photo you posted in Your Photos and you go one better by posting something completely new. Another quality image (no surprise there!). The more I look at it the more I like it. And there’s a number of juxtapositions going on here – colour, height, in focus/oof. Lovely light and great detail on the two figures. Nice bokeh. And the wet cholis are the finishing touch. I might have played about with brightness and contrast, darkening it slightly, but could well in the end have opted for the image as is.

Thoughton – Two lenses

Good, well composed, juxtaposition of old and new lenses – I think I know which one captures better images! Contrasting colours too, which is good – I like the way the Takumar is set against a white b/g which includes the iphone. Looks like a nice lens too – these are the kind of things I dream of having access to here in Sri Lanka.

Oppenheimer 45 – Old & new
Good juxtaposition in the style of buildings here – the dancehouse really is quite a contrast with the old warehouses(?). I think I probably would have cropped out more of the wall at the bottom (and perhaps done some judicious cloning) – IMO this improves the composition. Also the lighting doesn’t look too favourable – front or side lighting on the buildings might have transformed the scene. And I would have chosen a higher aperture – there’s evidence of the 18-55’s vignetting here.

MikeW – Untitled
Contrasting fruits – crisp, of course (what else from MikeW?!). A simple composition, but effective. Good light and simple b/g accentuating the fruit nicely. I like the detail on the avocado. Everything’s technically just so, but while it’s a pleasant image I don’t find it especially compelling.

Hefty – Redhead & Mr. Green
A quirky take on the subject, but certainly juxtapositional. Like the placement of the coloured lighters with the flatter plainer ones behind. As with Mike’s though, in the end I don’t find the image particularly compelling. I won’t ask what Ms. Redhead and Mr. Green got up to after the shoot!

Draken – Shadows among us
Not something I remotely anticipated in setting this theme, but I like this a lot. The shadows are great – I particularly like the balancing knife and the glass & tap. Actually – just looked again – I like them all! I think the sepia treatment and the added grain works really well here too. My one reservation is the crop – I can see why you have gone for this, but I’m generally not a fan of long narrow crops. Not sure if this is possible, but I would have tried to make the dark areas at the top and bottom of the frame symmetrical.

Anvh – Hate letter
We’re now getting to some welcome late entries. This is a super shot. Lovely light and the vignette works well to set this off. The contrast in colour and form of the handwriting (nice handwriting!) and the drawn heart are great. It looks to me that you pretty much accomplished all you set out to achieve in this shot – no mean feat! I bet you had a tired hand by the end!

Tony-O – Party posters

Interesting shot. I’m trying to work out why you’ve decided to use this kind of filter/effect (not sure exactly which). It strikes me that this image could stand up well without it – though perhaps not (was the tree problematic?). I like the old man walking into the frame and his hunched stance, and the posters look interesting behind though it is difficult to make out the detail with this treatment. In the end, with this kind of shot it’s down to whether you feel the filter/effect works in the context, and my instinct is that I want to see the untreated image here.

Womble – Fences
A really last minute entry from the last minute specialist (posted whilst I was posting my message above – I didn’t even notice it last night as my message appeared on the next page). It’s also the only entry to juxtapose in the way I thought would be most common – near & far. Love the close-up of the snow on the barbed wire - and the contrast with the far oof fence is good. A bit more contrast in the snow would have been nice – though this might be down to the size of the image. Is that dust on your sensor?!

Right, to the places. This is quite tough as there were three entries I really liked a lot: David’s, Lilly’s and Stefan’s (Draken's would have been up there too with a slightly different crop). Images with people generally have the edge for me so I narrowed it down to David’s and Lilly’s. Narrowing it down further was a lot tougher as these are both high quality photos. Aesthetically Lilly’s has the edge; though David’s captures the moment superbly. Tough one! In my opinion it’s more challenging to capture people head on than from behind (from a brazenness rather than a photographic point of view!), so on this slight distinction I’ve gone for the following:

First: David Trout
Second: Lilly
Third: Anvh
HC to Draken

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition #31 - Juxtaposition at 24/12/2009 - 03:27

Dr. Mhuni
Right, comp closed - if I've got my UK times right.

I'm afraid you folks are going to have to bear with me for the judgment. What with the traditional last minute rush, I've not written anything yet. And it's now 1130, and I'm kind of knackered having been up since 6 am. So I'm afraid judgment won't be posted till tomorrow morning. Expect it around 1 or 2 am your time (if you're in Europe - 7 or 8 am for those in India!).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition #31 - Juxtaposition at 23/12/2009 - 18:09

Dr. Mhuni
My favourite shots keep on changing - they tend to be the most recent ones. This wasn't shot long ago, so hasn't had time to pale. Not sure it's my favourite - I'm invariably dissatisfied with some aspect of my photos, so it's hard to pick one I'm happy with - but I do like the layered clouds.

Taken in Kandy with the K20D + DA55-300 (@ 250). The weather was rather disappointing during our w/e in Kandy, especially given the vista offered by our hotel's hillside location. However, the clouds parted briefly one morning and I got this:

Comment Image


I agree with Tim & Peter about the shots in the thread, but if I had to single one out it would have to be Matt's. I've seen quite a few shots of tigers in zoos, but this stands out - probably because of the symmetry and the eyes.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on The picture you are happiest with. at 23/12/2009 - 03:27

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks for the comments, folks. As for juxtaposition - I'm with David here. it doesn't have to be opposites, though there is likely to be some sort of contrast. Anyway, as explained in the comp thread I really am open to any (reasonable) interpretation in the hope of encouraging participation.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Elephantine juxtaposition at 21/12/2009 - 16:48

Dr. Mhuni
Nice juxtaposition, Lilly!

The cold actually sounds nice. Steaming hot (as ever), not so far away, here in Colombo.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Purdah in Shekhawati at 20/12/2009 - 18:24

Dr. Mhuni
I'm confused. Doesn't the fact that bondy's interesting pollen shot was taken with a microscope mean that a Pentax wasn't used? And if so, shouldn't it have been removed? Though, quite possibly I'm just showing my ignorance of scanning microscopes (and how you attach DSLRs to them) here.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly Competition #128 - Weightlessness at 20/12/2009 - 18:06

Dr. Mhuni
Nice shots Mike, which amongst other things demonstrate one of the qualities I've found I really like about Fishy - the colour rendition.

Re. your musing about abandoning the 12-24, though. I disagree. I was beginning to have my own doubts after a productive w/e with Fishy a couple of weeks ago. Perhaps, I thought, it was rather extravagant to have two ultra-wides. However, I used the 12-24 quite a bit this w/e and was once again struck by it's superb optical performance - it's sharper than the 10-17 even in the centre of the frame, and at the edges better than any other zoom I've had. Also, while the distortions are often visually striking, it's good to have something that doesn't distort (and the barrel distortion on the 12-24 is less than any wide angle lens I've used). It's true Fishy's pretty damn appealing, but I think the 12-24 still gets my vote for fave zoom lens.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Some fishy beach pics at 20/12/2009 - 17:47

Dr. Mhuni
I like the trees! Nice muted colours and composition.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A Frosty Morning at 20/12/2009 - 17:19

Dr. Mhuni
Here's what I would have entered if I hadn't been judging the fortnightly:

Comment Image


Taken with the K20D + DA17-70 at an elephant sanctuary near Colombo. It's slightly cropped, though I did have to get up very close with the limited focal range. Might have thought twice about this if I'd read my guide book before. Apparently the elephants have charged in the past! Though this one seemed pretty happy having her photo taken. In fact, I could have sworn she was actually posing.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Elephantine juxtaposition at 20/12/2009 - 16:58

Dr. Mhuni
Just back from a w/e away to find the grand total of 3 entries. Jeez guys, it's really not such a challenging subject is it?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly comp #31 - Discussion at 20/12/2009 - 16:43

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo