Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Right, I know I've been rude about one or two sunsets (or more?) that have appeared here over the past six months or so. So now it's time for people to get their own back. My reason for being so - as far as I can recall - was that while the light might have been nice that alone is generally not enough to make a good photo. Now, I'm in two minds about the following so if you are coruscating about them that will get me out of my quandary. Alternatively - you never know - someone may even like them!

Comment Image


Comment Image


By way of explanation what I like about the first is it's simplicity - though I wonder if there's too little going on.

In the second I like the colours and the receding silhouetted headlands and mountains - but is that foreground rock just too murky.

BTW, the first was taken with a DA12-24 & the second with a DA17-70 (both K20D).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Yet more sunsets at 26/02/2010 - 17:52

Dr. Mhuni
But your location's down as Cheshire, and in my 'Rare Welsh teapot in situ' competition the latter would have to mean Wales itself. So I'm afraid I'd have to disqualify this blatant attempt at circumventing clearly stated guidelines!

BTW, I didn't realise Sarah Palin had Welsh ancestry!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on So as not to disappoint at 24/02/2010 - 17:32

Dr. Mhuni
Really beautiful colours in all these. The light looks like it was fantastic.

Re. the sub shots, it's no.1 for me too. Though I agree with Mike about the blown areas (should be remediable) but not about including the clouds. Rather, for me it's a slight shame that some of the clouds (top left) are cut off.

One other thing - though I'm not sure I can bring myself to say it, given my excesses (mostly in the past, I hope!) - but I'd suggest there's evidence of some oversharpening in shots 1, 2 & 4 (though maybe in 1 & 4 this is to do with the image size).


What lens did you use btw?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A walk to Aberlady Beach at 23/02/2010 - 13:00

Dr. Mhuni
I second Hefty. If you want your flowers in context, the 35 or the 50 would be best. If you want isolated flowers go for a 100 (or move closer with the 50!). The former are more flexible - apart from for bugs etc. And for that you could get extension tubes.

I just got an old MF version of the 50 macro - an A50 f2.8. I'm totally blown away by the image quality. Phenomenally sharp and with the 3D quality of the Ltds. I guess the newer version has some of the same genetics - although I seem to recall reading that the A & F versions were considered the best 50 macros. I think the DA35 would be similar, but perhaps not as good for flower shots (too much context?).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax Macro lens. Which one??? at 21/02/2010 - 19:15

Dr. Mhuni
Picked up the lens yesterday. Thanks dynamosh. Everything as described. Fantastic lens.

Didn't even face stiff import charges. Had to pay just 122 rupees (about 60p.). Bizarrely, I had to pay 175 last week for a Beano annual I had ordered for my daughter. They clearly have a strange tariff system here!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on 3 Prime lenses for sale at 21/02/2010 - 11:14

Dr. Mhuni
I think the square crop works well, Tim.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Blue on blue at 19/02/2010 - 01:28

Dr. Mhuni
I'm afraid neither really works for me. Nice conversion in 1 though!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Odd angles at 18/02/2010 - 17:48

Dr. Mhuni
I like 1, Tim - though you could perhaps do with a bit less cloud in the sky.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Blue on blue at 18/02/2010 - 17:43

Dr. Mhuni
What with the new Fortnightly comp theme being ‘People’ I thought I’d share a recent experience of mine which led me to muse on the issue of taking unsolicited photos in public places. The other day I walked past a group of schoolgirls waiting for a bus in central Colombo. I saw the potential for a shot, and self consciously got out my LX3, which I try to have with me when I’m out. Taking a picture involved quite brazenly standing directly in front of them lining up the camera and pressing the shutter. This brings me to dilemma no.1:

1. Is a foreigner taking photos of locals in this manner acting in an unsensitive, inconsiderate, even an exploitative manner? Here in Sri Lanka, people are generally very amenable when it comes to having their pictures taken. But that doesn’t mean that everyone is, and without getting consent first (which would destroy the purpose of most street photos) you will be risking taking photographs of people who do not want theirs taken. In Africa I know that there was often some resistance to having pictures taken – in some cases because of superstition, in others because it was assumed that the person taking the photo was in some way gaining from it – in which case the subject themselves should be recompensed in some way (upfront).

Anyway, as it turned out several of the schoolchildren I was taking a photo of in Colombo were not happy having their photo taken. However, I only realised this after downloading the image later. At the time of taking the shot I was struggling to compose the frame in harsh sunlight which made viewing the LCD screen very difficult. Partly for this reason, and partly through my inhibition causing me to avoid direct eye contact, I actually didn’t look at my subjects at the time of taking the shot, other than in the barely visible LCD.

When I got home I was surprised to download the following:

Comment Image


As you can see, the Muslim girls as one have acted so as to avoid having their faces visible. I felt quite uncomfortable finding this out in hindsight. Had I been aware of this at the time, I most certainly would have desisted. However, the picture was taken and by this time was on my computer, which brings us to dilemma 2.

2. What should I do with the photo? Given that a large number of the subjects clearly didn’t want their photos taken, the answer might seem simple. Bin it. To do otherwise would be exploitative. But interestingly, while I wouldn’t have thought twice about stopping taking the shot if I’d been aware of what the Muslim girls were doing at the time, looking at the shot as a completed capture it occurred to me that perhaps this actually gave the photo added value. The fact that only the Muslim girls (other girls seem quite unconcerned by my presence) reacted in this way lends it some documentary significance.

I’m still undecided as to how to treat it. For now, this image is on Flickr, though I may be persuaded to remove it. But this seems in part to get to the essence of street photography, which inevitably has to involve photographs taken without the subject’s consent. I can understand people wanting to protect their privacy, however, I am also sympathetic towards a photographer trying to capture meaningful images. The issue becomes even more controversial when it involves children, of course – though, assuming the images are innocent and cannot in any way be put to indecent use, I fail to see why children should be treated any differently to adults.

One rational guiding my photography is the desire to document. And I’m doing this not only for personal fulfilment, but also with an eye to how my images could potentially be viewed (and used) in the future. As some of you know, I’m a historian by training and I’m conscious how – if they had access to them – future historians of Colombo might use photos I had taken. I have researched and written on colonial East African cities – Dar es Salaam in particular – and if I had come across images of the sort I have taken in contemporary Colombo in, say, 1950s or 1960s East Africa this would have been a potential gold mine (although, it must be said, photos can be hard to interpret as historical documents). To use examples from the West – imagine how different our view of , say, medieval Britain or Ancient Greece would have been if photographic records existed documenting these societies.

So my profession is one thing that influences my approach to this issue. The other is the importance of photography as a medium in capturing the human experience over the past 150 years. For me, for now, these override any concerns about invasion of privacy. Though one should still be sensitive to context and behave appropriately, and although I have more or less convinced myself of the documentary merit of the above photo, I am still not entirely comfortable about it.

What are others views?

Ps. If you got this far – apologies for the length of the post!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Taking pictures of people at 18/02/2010 - 17:34

Dr. Mhuni
I like all three. Though how 'bad' were they in the first place?! It would be interesting to see the originals.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Post processing to match content and save an image? at 18/02/2010 - 04:34

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo