Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
paulyrichard wrote:
Wow, I didn't expect to get this reaction from you guys.
I thought I was getting ignored and disliked on this forum, thats why I stopped posting here.
At the start this photo went down the postings and onto the next page, without a reaction at all, so I thought - oh well.
I for one didn't leave any feedback because this image wasn't my cup of tea, Paul. I'd say, given the left-field nature of it, that this would be the likely reason for the (initial) lack of feedback.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A Night Scene at 05/03/2010 - 01:36

Dr. Mhuni
thoughton wrote:
From what I understand it was quite touristy even back then (we're talking 20 years ago). That's why she snuck in before dawn, to get the full effect without the other tourists (and to see the sunrise of course). I can't remember how she got in, I think they (her and a girlfriend) found a gap under a chainlink fence - which in itself suggests it must be quite touristy.
If it was twenty years ago, I don't think it was touristy at all. I went in 1991. Admittedly it was in October, so hardly peak season. But we only came across one other group of tourists during the whole day we were wandering about the valley. Having spoken to people who have been recently, it seems to have changed a lot - inevitably, I guess, as it's a truly spectacular place. There was only one large (empty) hotel when we were there. Now there are several full ones.

Just to make you green Kris - after Petra we moved on to Palmyra and Krak des Chevaliers! We'd been backpacking in Africa and were making our way back to the UK through the Middle East and Eastern Europe. Arrived back in Dover two days before Christmas, 1991. Happy memories.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Some for Andrew at 05/03/2010 - 01:30

Dr. Mhuni
Have been going through a similar thought process myself, but am increasingly concluding that I'd rather have a shorter high quality 2.8 and a teleconvertor. A big factor in my reasoning is the fact that the 70-200's constitute a significant (further) step up in size.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A's vs. DA's at 04/03/2010 - 09:01

Dr. Mhuni
Cheers, Mike. The lens has found a happy home - I love it!

thoughton wrote:

Mostly coincidence, I don't have anything against DA lenses, but also due to budget e.g. Sigma 10-20 instead of 12-24, Tamron 17-50 instead of 16-50, Tamron 90 instead of DFA100, Tamron 70-300 instead of 55-300 etc. Photography is just a hobby, second best at half the price is often good enough for me. An exception might be the 50-135, I probably would have got that by now if SDM was more reliable.
Interesting - I think I would have gone down your route too if I hadn't got a load of DA zooms in the halcyon days of December 2008 when there was a £50 rebate offer on many lenses and the old (old) prices still applied.

Very nearly got a DA50-135 too before the last price rise when I was in the UK last summer, but in the end decided it was too bulky for me to take with all my other equipment to Sri Lanka (was moving from Ethiopia then). It was probably the right decision at the time, even though I could have got it with VAT refunded for under £500. Am still hankering after it, but like you am a bit wary of the SDM on that lens (others seem okay) and - now - the price. Have you considered the Sigma 50-150? I know the DA50-135 is viewed as a peerless zoom by many, but I've read comments in various places (including those of Mike-P here) which indicate it is of comparable quality image wise (though apparently it tails off from ca.135-50, which the DA doesn't have in any case). It's also significantly cheaper.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A's vs. DA's at 04/03/2010 - 03:29

Dr. Mhuni
Kris, did you have a digital body with you that day? Would be very interesting to see any shots you took with that if so, as a point of comparison.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Some for Andrew at 04/03/2010 - 03:07

Dr. Mhuni
Quote:
Quote:

I don't think they're soft, it's just that you seem to have focussed on the artwork rather than the people. I thought it was deliberate

In 2 I certainly did focus on the face of the statue. Not certain that was the right choice in hindsight. In one the focus is on the picture as I thought the painting would look odd out of focus compared to the people.
The question is whether it was more appropriate to focus on the people or the art? I think the general rule of thumb would be to get people sharp as they will inevitably be the main focus of attention, even when small in the frame.

For me, in your first photo - a shot in which the onlookers were sharp and the art softer(but with some detail) would, IMO, probably have made a better image. In the second, I actually think that probably either could be appropriate. In the third, which I find most interesting as a composition, there doesn't seem to me to be any compelling reason to
have focused on the back wall - and I find the lack of detail on the women distracting.

I hesitated to post this given others' overwhelmingly positive response - being wary of coming across as a curmudgeon. However, I do feel that there's too little constructive criticism on PUF. And we can all learn from a little disagreement!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on In the Museum at 04/03/2010 - 02:57

Dr. Mhuni
Great image in either colour, Stefan. Though I think I prefer the gold.

Re. the highlights - I hesitate to give people who are clearly much more skilled in pp-ing than me advice, but were you using ACR for the RAW conversion and if so did you push the Recovery to its limit? I have recently started using ACR and I find this is a very useful feature that wasn't available on the version of Silkypix I have. I was ginger in its use at first, but apparently I've found you can push it more or less to the maximum without having a detrimental effect on the rest of the picture. Having said that, you probably already know this.In fact, you've probably already done it here!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Glass Flower at 04/03/2010 - 01:58

Dr. Mhuni
Many thanks for the considered judging Glyn (really commendable detail as others have said), and congrats to Tony and the others.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Entries for Fortnightly Competition # 36 - "People" at 04/03/2010 - 01:58

Dr. Mhuni
thoughton wrote:
I can't comment as I no longer own any DA lenses but I like the pics!
Thanks Tim. But is your lack of a DA a preference or an accident.

Mongoose - I haven't really had the lens for long enough to reach a conclusion yet but I was wondering, like you, if the A50 might produce images that were more flexible. Colour wise that is - optically the A50 shoots all my DA's out of the water, even the 12-24 which is remarkably sharp for a zoom.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A's vs. DA's at 03/03/2010 - 14:16

Dr. Mhuni
I have recently acquired a Pentax A50 f2.8 Macro lens and have been interested to note its colour rendition qualities in comparison to my Pentax DA zooms. I was curious to know what other peoples' impressions of A lenses vs. more modern ones.

I find the DAs are much bolder in their rendering - the A50 more subtle. See the following images of the same dog taken around the same time of day (but not the same day) at the same place.

DA55-300

Comment Image


A50

Comment Image


As you can see the A50 has produced a much less saturated image. Not sure yet whether this is a good or bad (or superfluous - it is easy to adjust the colours in pp-ing) thing. I guess there will be times when I want the more subtle approach of the A50. In any case, it's other qualities are undisputed - the sharpness is outstanding. Here, the first image received much more sharpening in pp. It also seems to have some of the fabled 3D characteristics of the Ltds.

As another example of the colour rendition, the following was also taken with the A50:

Comment Image


With a DA lens I would have expected the colours on the front of the bus to be much bolder.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A's vs. DA's at 03/03/2010 - 13:24

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo