Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Neil, I'd do a similar crop to your original one but leave more space on the left.

The lens is probably the Pentax or Samsung 50-200.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Beach life at 30/10/2009 - 04:55

Dr. Mhuni
Paul, For me this doesn't exude the quality of your other homeless portraits. While it is, as ever, a beautifully crisp well taken shot and skilfully converted into B&W, I feel it needs your explanation about the guy barely lifting his head to make it work. And, as Malo1961 wrote about one of my photos a while back, images that need explanation are usually failing in one way or another. I've come to agree with Martin. This would work in the context of a collection/exhibition where an explanation to explain its relevance would be appropriate. However, as a stand alone image it doesn't work so well IMHO.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on EHN! Project #16 at 30/10/2009 - 04:53

Dr. Mhuni
Aha - nothing to do with a 'snoot' then!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on My first attempt with a 'snoot' at 29/10/2009 - 15:28

Dr. Mhuni
grahamwalton wrote:
I have one and it is an excellent bag. I much prefer it to the Lowepro Slingback 200 and 300 which I also have. I regularly use mine with my K20D and Pentax 55-300 attached, including the lenshood in position.
Out of interest - why do you prefer it to the Lowepro?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Kata DCS 3N1-30 DSLR Camera Sling / BackPack Bag at 29/10/2009 - 15:25

Dr. Mhuni
I like the egg AND the Bacardi bottle. Amazing colours on the latter - I'd never have guessed what it is.

If you don't mind me asking, how come your user name is Snootchies, when you've only just started using a snoot?!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on My first attempt with a 'snoot' at 29/10/2009 - 15:18

Dr. Mhuni
Lovely colours in all of them - I guess that's the light. They're also all pleasingly crisp images. Compositionally, I find 3 the most interesting, though 2 is more interesting subject-wise. For me 2's slightly let down by A. the narrow crop & B. the bird on the left being too close to the edge. I like the positioning of the man and boy and waves behind though. In 1 I'd say the woman was too close to the edge, but I like the way the water flows through the scene from front to back. 4 doesn't work for me. The pier is too small and there's too much sky. It may have worked if you'd kneeled down and attempted to get closer to the birds so they took up more of the frame with the pier behind. But as it stands neither the birds nor the pier really commands my attention.

What lens/camera did you use?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Beach life at 29/10/2009 - 15:05

Dr. Mhuni
Lens tests offer an often imperfect guide to performance - the results from different ones are often contradictory. I've always based my purchases more on feedback from actual users. And on this score the DA16-45 must have more happy customers than any other Pentax lens (partly of course because of its range and the fact that it costs a lot less than, say, a 12-24, 50-135 or a 31 Ltd).

In use, I've found the 16-45 to perform dramatically better than my 18-55, particularly wide open and at the wide end of the range. I'd also say the IQ was better throughout. Having said that, QC on the 18-55 seems to be quite variable and it's possible I had a bad copy. At the right aperture/focal length the 18-55 can perform really well given its modest status. If you're lucky enough to have a good version perhaps the difference won't be so noticeable. But I recall having to do a lot of cropping to address severe vignetting on images from the 18-55 and its low light performance was frankly poor.

You also get the extra 2mm wide on the 16-45, which is not to be sniffed at.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on 16-45mm £229 or Tamron 17-50mm?? at 29/10/2009 - 14:33

Dr. Mhuni
stu49 wrote:
[quote:3496ace15f="Greytop"]
Not overly happy with my 50-200, not very sharp (to say the least). Was thinking of getting the 55-300 (very sharp supposedly), but as I do a lot of walking I've decided to get the 18-250, good range but slightly less sharp.
Never had the 18-250, but unless you have a bad copy of the 50-200 you may be disappointed with the results beyond 100mm compared to the latter. Though of course you also have the utility of 18-50 & 200-250 - and it apparently performs surprisingly well up to 100mm.

You're right about the size Greytop, the 50-200 is very diminutive when you consider its' range. If you want to see what it's capable of do a lens check on the Pentax Photo Gallery - there's some cracking images there taken with this lens.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax 50-200mm DA ED f4-5.6 Lens at 29/10/2009 - 13:20

Dr. Mhuni
Greytop wrote:
I've been toying with the idea of getting one myself as the WR version is at SRS is currently a bit of a steal at £109, however the optical quality does appear to vary depending on what review you read.

Here is an example at Photozone 50-200 review so I am a little unsure
I was always very happy with my results from the 50-200. I prefer the extra reach and sharpness/contrast of the 55-300, but at £109 for a WR lens it's a snip. Though I see you have the 60-250. Isn't that WR too?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax 50-200mm DA ED f4-5.6 Lens at 29/10/2009 - 12:37

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks Peter, Emily.

They're not hot pixels - was wondering if someone would pick up on this. The smaller ones are rocks and the largest (in the distance) is actually another worshipper. I love the triangular relationship that the three worshippers have in this shot - like they're involved in some arcane positional ritual. The problem though is the third one is too small to see properly and does look like a hot pixel, so I probably should remove them!

You other points are good Emily. I'll work on tidying up the b/g.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lalibela rock hewn church at 29/10/2009 - 12:32

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo