All Forum Comments
Comment by ChrisA posted on is this any good?? at 23/08/2007 - 19:22
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=220142396923&sspage...
please advice as i have read good things about this lens.
paul
Good for the price?
Good for use with your camera (which is?)?
Good compared with some other lens?
"Good" is always relative.
It probably isn't good for use with a K10D, since it doesn't have an A-setting.
It probably is quite good if you wanted to use a reversing ring with it for macro, and didn't want to use one of your good lenses.
I don't know anything about it, but it would help those that do to say a bit more about what you want.
Comment by ChrisA posted on is this any good?? at 23/08/2007 - 11:44
The micro-switch would be a bad idea as I leave the quick release plate from my tripod on my K10D all the time.
Also if you use a bean bag rather than a tripod the micro-switch idea wouldn't help.
I think they've got it about right. If you use a long exposure, you aren't going to want to use it in "push the button, release immediately" mode, so SR will be switched off for you, and if the exposure is short enough for you not to care then I doubt having SR left on is going to be a problem.
I've definitely seen issues with SR left on when on a tripod.
Comment by ChrisA posted on Leaving shake reduction on at 27/08/2007 - 16:37
The SMC-FA 80-320 is not made anymore. In the UK they can generally be obtained second hand for around £100.
I'd appreciate a view of the relative handling qualities of the two as well.
Comment by ChrisA posted on How good is Sigma 70-300 APO DG Macro? at 23/08/2007 - 14:15
Thanks Chris, Just reading through those previous threads there are so many lenses I would like but cant afford that's why I'm going for older one without autofocus.
There are quite a few SMC-A 50mm F2s about also, which go for a bit less.
Comment by ChrisA posted on K10D and SMC M 1: 1.7 50mm at 22/08/2007 - 18:53
Hello, Thank You John and Tyr for your quick replies. Never mind I will take a look on ebay for the A version of this lens.
Thanks again, James
https://www.pentaxuser.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5360
It refers to two threads discussing this issue; there are others too worth having a look at.
But getting the A-series equivalent is a good plan. There are hordes of them about at the moment.
Comment by ChrisA posted on K10D and SMC M 1: 1.7 50mm at 22/08/2007 - 18:32
I haven't done such a test with the latest digital lenses but my Pentax 28-200 performed better than several other Pentax zooms I've owned, where their ranges overlapped e.g. FA 28-80 powerzoom, FA 28-80 F3.5-5.6, DA 18-55 and the 100-300 powerzoom.
One of the things I like to do is sit inconspicuously at barbecues or other outdoor party-type events, far enough away from people for them to be engrossed in what they're doing without a camera in their face, and grab a few candid shots.
I've found the 28-200 ideal for this, and I can imagine that bit of extra reach that you get with the Tamron 18-250 being even more ideal.
None of the results are the sort of thing you'd blow up to A3, indeed the shots in isolation aren't anything to write home about. But taken together they provide a more up-close-and-personal record of the event than you can get with a compact, and most of them would be completely impossible with the 16-45, or indeed the 18-55, since the enlargement of the crops required from them would negate their superior optical qualities.
Comment by ChrisA posted on Really Wide Zooms - Opinions at 23/08/2007 - 22:14
I recently bought a K10D + D-BG2 grip & Tamron 18-250mm Di II
I don't think there's any question that such superzooms are worse than the best, but I'd love to see some reliable evidence about how much worse, and indeed whether they're also significantly worse than the not-quite-best.
Comment by ChrisA posted on Really Wide Zooms - Opinions at 23/08/2007 - 21:33
11 or 12MP from 10 is such a tiny resolution increment.
To get the same increase again, you'd need to go to 16.6 MP.
Comment by ChrisA posted on Pentax press conference 23/8 at 23/08/2007 - 22:41
Why does it have to be a 12 MP sensor?
It's just like 10MP but its one louder...
Or he could be stringing us along... not sure I'd bet either way, to be honest
Comment by ChrisA posted on Pentax press conference 23/8 at 23/08/2007 - 19:24


The lens in the auction looks to me as if it is a SMC Pentax-M or the older K version. If you plan to use it on a K10D, I would go for at least the SMC Pentax-A version to avoid the exposure issues that are well documented elswhere on this forum. That said, the BIN price is very low and is worth risking.
But as you say, if it's for the '10, then SMC-A 50mm F1.7 every time (I have two of these now, and an F2, so I'm not so bothered about the prices going up )