Blythman

Joined: 13th September 2010

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Blythman
Each to their own Ken. I hardly use photoshop, but for some its the most enjoyable part.

Regarding lanscapes, it would however be nice when looking at an image if you knew whether it was "real" or not.

"Real" to me does include dodging and burning, removing a bit of litter or the like which you were unable to move on the day.

"Real" to me doesn't include dropping in a new sky, removing castles, etc.

Not being "real" doesn't mean it isn't valid. I'd just like to know.

As to the particular image in the article. On skimming through it, what they seem to have missed out, is that the photographer broke the rules of the competition which only allowed the type of manipulation I referred to in keeping the image "real"

Bit of a shame that the judges including Charlie Waite didn't notice that the rules had been broken, and that it was other photographers who brought it to light.

As an aside the photographer was also criticised for copying work. The image was almost identical to one taken by another member of his camera club a number of years ago.However, he did credit the previous photographer as providing the inspiration for the shot. And I think to criticise on that basis is ridiculous as we've all been to places where you can almost see the tripod holes where people have been time and time again.

Comment by Blythman posted on Is photoshop ruining photography at 12/03/2013 - 10:13

Blythman
tyronet2000 wrote:

That is something I think I would have enjoyed Alan, especially the lightroom demo as I just don't seem to be able to get on with it.
Thanks Stan, think it was an eye opener for the many who haven't used it before. Both for those who are already proficient in Photoshop, and also by those who are intimidated by it.

To me being in a camera club is about sharing experiences and knowledge to help each other to improve.

I must confess, however, being relatively new (just my second season) I am competitive in the competitions. I do expect I'll ease off, once I've "proven myself" for want of a better phrase.

I was previously in a camera club, in the film days, where after two years I still felt like an outsider and I packed it in.

Comment by Blythman posted on Lightroom demo/wildlife talk at club at 11/03/2013 - 21:54

Blythman
Hi Stu, just looked at my post again. A bit long wasn't it

As to my current decision to stay with Pentax. Its a compromise. If I were to purely take wildlife shots then I reckon I would have switched by now. However, I am wanting to diversify and for other work I think Pentax takes some beating pound for pound.

The problem I have in diversifying is lack of free time. When I get up early on a weekend I think there will always be another sunrise tomorrow, and I can take people shots any time. But the target bird/animal may have moved on if I don't get it today

Comment by Blythman posted on For wild life and sports lenses at 11/03/2013 - 21:22

Blythman
A very good set indeed.

Comment by Blythman posted on Mallory Park Today - 10 images at 10/03/2013 - 22:32

Blythman
Its a learning curve with this lens Brian but the second last one, the gull, looks sharp enough. Wide open at f6.3 too

Comment by Blythman posted on Sigma 150-500 OS first outing at 10/03/2013 - 22:30

Blythman
Stu, I've told this story before. I nearly switched after seeing my first ever cuckoo late last summer. Myself and two other photographers both got shots of it sitting on a post. It then flew to the left. The two guys I was with got excellent in flight shots. I got a blur. I have no doubt that if I'd had the Canon that one of them had, or if I'd had the Nikon that the other guy had, then I too would have got excellent shots. Incidentally, I don't machine gun. Accurate and fast AF is one thing Machine gunning is something else altogether. Try machine gunning with a Pentax shooting RAW, and you'll miss more than you catch, while your buffer is being emptied.

Are you suggesting that in the instant when it unexpectedly took off and flew left I should have tracked it with manual focus and managed the in flight shots that I was after. My view is that with manual focus I would have had a choice. Take the pictures on the post OR choose to gamble where it would fly and pre-focus there. Would I guess right or left. Would I guess that it would fly perpendicular to me, or would it move nearer to me or farther away.

The gear we have today has made the photography of wildlife so much more accessible than it has ever been before. There are undoubtedly more people taking quality wildlife pictures than at any time. And many more of those photographs are action photographs taken by ordinary people with full time jobs, who can only get out at the weekend.

If all you want to do is take a photo of a bird on a stick, then you will do fine with manual focus. If you want to get quality action shots the I'm afraid you need to either use AF, or give up work, and spend your week guessing whether the bird is going to fly right, fly left, or towards you and pre-focus. This will be in the knowledge that you've nothing better to do all week. Of course the cuckoo is due to fly to Africa. So, it might not stay with you all week

There are times when you can stack the cards more in your favour. Know the flight path of a bird. Pre-focus. Use an aperture of f8 or smaller to maximise depth of field. I've done this for flight shots of blue tits, house sparrows, greenfinches, etc. Be interesting if you were to give this a try and see what percentage of keepers you get. This is an instance when AF will not help, so its a level playing field across all systems.

As to the analogy of sanding a door. That is nice and slow. Maybe useful in a comparison with landscape photography, but not with action photography. However, having both an electric sander and a block sander you do use both. You use the tool that is best for the particular job. If the door was going to fly off, you'd maybe use the electric sander a bit more

Of course cost comes into it if changing systems. I could get a 2nd hand Canon 7d body for £700, probably less. I could get an old version of the Sigma 120-300 f2.8 for £800. A 1.4x TC for less than £100 and a 2x TC for another £140 or so.
Alternatively, I could get a Pentax fit Sigma 300m f2.8 for £2300 in the hope that the reported fast AF is in fact a reality. Although, it probably just means fast compared to other Pentax fit lenses and is actually still not on par with Canon or Nikon. Not to mention the prime is reputed to be inferior to the 120-300 zoom. Still need the TCs of course. Unless I were to go for the Sigma 500mm f4.5 which is £3999

So, changing systems is potentially a much cheaper option. Has to be said wildlife photography is expensive. Hobby or not. Its a case of what a person wants to spend disposable income on. Having decided not to change systems for now at least, I'm doing it on the cheap with a Sigma 150-500 and a DA*300. Still at over £1000 if I'd already had the Canon 7D the the 120-300 and TCs wouldn't have been any more expensive.

Comment by Blythman posted on For wild life and sports lenses at 10/03/2013 - 22:23

Blythman
Strange, weird, excellent set

Comment by Blythman posted on Cottesloe Art-sunrise shoot at 10/03/2013 - 16:55

Blythman
Good set David. That first one is a corker

Comment by Blythman posted on A wet day in Middlesborough at 10/03/2013 - 16:45

Blythman
Stuey, what is wrong with someone wanting better tools? Are you still cooking the rabbit, that you caught with a trap made from stripped tree bark and a branch, on a fire that you lit by rubbing sticks together?

Comment by Blythman posted on For wild life and sports lenses at 10/03/2013 - 15:43

Blythman
Hi Dave, I ordered from that site on the 18th Jan. Delivery expected by the 7th Feb. But it turned up on 24th Jan

Comment by Blythman posted on Long Range Birding setup at 10/03/2013 - 15:38

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo