Catadioptric Lens

RAB
Posted 02/01/2010 - 13:00 Link
Hello All.

I'm getting back into photography after a significant absence and have recently bought a K-X along with a couple of lenses (18-55 & 50-200 zooms). I also have a Sigma 600/f8 mirror lens which I used to use for (mostly) wild-life and other subjects.

I've had a rummage through this and a couple of other forums and it would appear that mirror lenses have fallen out of favour somewhat.

I always had pretty good results with this lens using 35mm cameras and, from playing around in the back garden with it, it seems to be fairly compatible with my new DSLR.

Whilst I am fully aware of the pros and cons of these lenses ( I actually think out-of-focus doughnuts add to certain shots) as a relative newbie to 21st century photography, is there something I'm missing with regard to their use with DSLRs?

RAB.
"He's not the Messiah, ..."
johnriley
Posted 02/01/2010 - 14:11 Link
You've had one of the better mirror lenses, although a cat lens is a solid piece of glass as I recall, so not vulnerable to damage in the way most mirror lenses are.

The trouble is there are quite a few really poor lenses, plus those that have been handled badly, so the overall experience will be very mixed.

There's no reason why a mirror lens can't be a good lens, it's just that for various reasons often they are not.
Best regards, John
grahamwalton
Posted 02/01/2010 - 16:59 Link
I too have a Sigma 600 f8 Mirror Lens.
They are a very interesting lens to use, and the out-of-focus highlight doughnut effects can add to certain images.
To me, the optical quality is not crisp enough for wildlife and the fixed f8 certainly limits the use to good lighting. With my lens, I find there is an illumination fall off at the edges of the photo.
Now that I have a Sigma 150-500 APO, I will certainly try it side by side with the Sigma 600 mirror.
Friendly Regards
Graham
edumad
Posted 02/01/2010 - 19:44 Link
I have the Tokina and Tamron mirror lenses, both 500mm F8, both give great results when properly focused and a adequate shutter speed is applied (kinda goes for any lens). In this lies the issue with these lenses... its applicability becomes limited due to constant F8 aperture.

I've used them for a while on birds mainly, and my observations are that they are great bang for the buck on good days, and worth a try because they are small and easy to carry.
JonSchick
Posted 02/01/2010 - 21:59 Link
I have the Tamron 500mm F8 and have used it frequently on dSLR. I find my best results:

(1) are when I use a monopod and keep SR switched on (handholding is a no-no with these lenses, despite the temptation to do so given they are so compact)

(2) are when I keep the shutter speed to at least 1/125 and preferably faster - so good light is a must unless you bump up the ISO

(3) are when I shoot RAW to give me the maximum data to play with afterwards - even good cat lenses have reduced contrast compared to conventional glass, and starting with a RAW file can really help

I also tend to use the camera's "catch in focus" feature, which often works well. I will try and post some samples in this thread sometime, but SmugMug (which is where they are hosted) is going through some maintenance tonight so I can't get at them!....
Jon

Some occasional random stuff at The Photographers Block: link
JonSchick
Posted 02/01/2010 - 22:38 Link
SmugMug is back up now so here are a few Tamron 500mm samples (Pentax K20D in Botswana):

Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image


In my view, a good cat or mirror lens used with care can deliver results far in excess of what the nay-sayers will suggest. I'm happy with what I'm getting - and it also makes me smile that my first PPG acceptance (the elephant above) was taken with a £45 secondhand lens that many people on the photography forums will tell you aren't worth bothering with. If you had a good experience before, I think with practice you will again (and from what I've read, your Sigma is a good lens that's up there with the Tamron as among the best of breed). Have fun!
Jon

Some occasional random stuff at The Photographers Block: link

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo