All Forum Comments
Comment by Stuey posted on Security pose at 18/05/2011 - 20:21
Comment by Stuey posted on More flowers... in mono at 18/05/2011 - 20:18
I'm not normally one for critique - I usually state that I like a photo or just don't comment but this set has got me puzzled.
I can't work out quite why some of these shots are not quite hitting the mark that you would hope for given the lens/ camera combo and also despite having a peek I can't find your exif info so guesswork is what it will have to be .
1. In terms of the overall look of this and the detail it may well have been that the lighting is quite strong from the side, however, the usual suspects of high iso/noise reduction in pp/ largest apeture (surely the DA* would be ok)or a heavy crop or slight focus error - maybe a combination but somehow it is just not a sharp as I would expect although I do not yet have this lens. I like the shot though despite this. I doubt that this is camera shake as the twigs around the bird show no signs of this.
2. Again just not as sharp as I would expect though it looks like a large crop/ high iso/ noise reduction maybe - nice pose though.
3. This is the best one for me but it still seems to have lost sharpness - guesses as above (high iso/ crop being most likely). Also Have you used a tripod whilst leaving the shake reduction on- I have heard that this can cause problems similar to this but not noticed it when I have made the same error.
4 and 5 seem to be again just short of the mark but if ths is a heavy crop then it is what you would expect - I love the pose and the fact that at least one eye is sharp - I have no photo's of gannet's so I can't comment on how well the plumage shows up on pixel peeping - some birds plumage shows more detail than others.
6. I like this one but again it seems like a heavy crop and a very limited depth of field - if it is a lrge crop and a high iso factoring in the bird in flight element this is very good.
7. Guesses as above but in particular I suspect that the plumage of this bird coupled with the lighting has also not helped with detail - but we can't change the lighting can we and lowering the exposure a little does not always help.
8. The movement of the head compared to the shutter speed could be viewed as a positive or a negative - a higher shutter speed would have solved this but of course other issues with noise/ wide apeture may then begin to nibble away at the detail - I love the caterpillar in flight though - the caterpillar was probably less pleased.
9. This looks like a narrow DOF/ wide apeture and a focus error - focus appears to be middle to rear of the bird - I guess it was moving towards you.
10. This has to be a heavy crop - not surprising given how rarely these fellas get within picture range but any of the guesses above may apply.
I like the subjects/ the poses etc and can see why you feel some of them are not quite there yet - many if not all of my photo's could have these criticisms levelled at them so I won't be gloating any time soon.
At a guess, given your subjects many were not very close to you and when that happens you have to work with it so whilst you may feel you have not got it right you may actually have done the best possible in the given situation but without more info my guesses may be way short of accurate
I don't have this lens and as mentioned can't find your exif info but most lenses improve by stopping down a little - given the very narrow DOF I suspect many of these may have been at the lenses largest/ widest aperture if so try stopping down a little and highering the iso, if no tripod was used this may also help but with no shutter speeds to use the guess may be wrong
Hope this helps.
Cheers
Stu
Comment by Stuey posted on Birds Eye Delight at 18/05/2011 - 20:16
I love using mf lenses but the pictures I can find from the Samyang surprise me as to how poor they are.
Comment by Stuey posted on Longer focal length for wildlife at 14/05/2011 - 10:08
Comment by Stuey posted on Once the rain had stopped I ventured out at 08/05/2011 - 10:52
Comment by Stuey posted on X Games - Shanghai - Part 1 at 04/05/2011 - 21:07
I like the way yo have choisen to isolate a small part of the flower with the dof
Comment by Stuey posted on Pictures from West Woods, Marlborough. at 04/05/2011 - 12:31
I can't promise to be mature or knowledgeable but I will try to always be nice
Stu
Comment by Stuey posted on Great Community at 03/05/2011 - 21:33


I like this one though - my first thought was that it looks as though the people are on a very large lens test chart - nicely spotted