sophiecentaur

Joined: 14th June 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

sophiecentaur
I suggest that different lenses have a different field of view so the base their analysis on a different set of samples of the scene. It could also have something to do with the different levels of UV getting onto the blue sensor?

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on How to use the Colour Balance control on a DSLR at 07/10/2009 - 11:05

sophiecentaur
I agree about the Photoshop thing.
However, you often need very little actual haze to achieve 'mood' in a landscape picture. Your eye seems to be much better at seeing distant mountains through haze than the camera is. The 'perspective of light' thing is very effective even when it's only just present.

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on Haze filters and DSLRs at 07/10/2009 - 10:59

sophiecentaur
NO, I meant that cutting the blue channel would have 'repercussions' - i.e. less signal so worse signal to noise. Good idea of yours to reduce the blue noise in your pictures by reducing the blue video bandwidth. PAL TV does just that, in effect.
As a good polarizer chucks away half the energy (of un polarized sources) it should be up to one stop reduction on average.

Bob
I may contact Hoya and ask them to put their money where their mouths are.

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on Haze filters and DSLRs at 06/10/2009 - 23:28

sophiecentaur
Yes but getting rid of haze all the time is not what you want - that will get rid of some wanted colour components in some pictures. A built in UV filter shouldn't remove any of the visible haziness. A haze filter would be a 'least worst' treatment (short of a large vacuum cleaner to get rid of all the dust etc.). What I'm after is a chainsaw for removing the upper portion (perhaps a half?) of the overall blue response. It will have repercussions on the blue channel noise performance if it's there all the time.
BTW, does a haze necessarily produce polarisation? I can see that a polarizer could sometimes improve pictures, though. And a polarizer introduces a stop (?) of light loss, too, which could be relevant on occasions.

I'd be really surprised if there wasn't a hugely expensive DSLR version for reducing haze better produced by someone.

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on Haze filters and DSLRs at 06/10/2009 - 16:09

sophiecentaur
Vic. You just made me feel a lot better!

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on How to use the Colour Balance control on a DSLR at 06/10/2009 - 15:59

sophiecentaur
Having looked at the spectral responses of some typical film and digital sensors, I notice that, not surprisingly, the green and red sensitivities are far better separated from the blue curve and the selectivity is better.
This leads me to conclude that the optimal haze filter for digital could have a far steeper cut-off at shorter wavelengths than what is best for film. This is because the amount of scattering is proportional to the fourth power of one over the wavelength - hence cutting out an extra few percent off the UV end of the blue light curve could be achieved with a sharper filter and this would make a significant difference to the visibility of the haze without upsetting the general colourimetry of the picture.
Question: are there 'special' haze filters available for DSLRs yet?
I think there should be. Any opinions or even experiences?

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on Haze filters and DSLRs at 06/10/2009 - 14:42

sophiecentaur
Quote: However, if you are shooting RAW then the white balance is irrelevant as you set this afterwards in the RAW converter.

That makes sense!
Perhaps my problem is now that the 'buttons' on Aperture may not be adequate (the temperature and tint at the top of the inspector). Using the levels control or the advanced tint control can get you anything but that is another level of complication AND needs a much more systematic approach. But, I suppose, no one ever said it would be easy.

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on How to use the Colour Balance control on a DSLR at 06/10/2009 - 08:40

sophiecentaur
I thought I had begun to suss this out but, after about 500 pictures taken on a holiday in the states, I am back to square 1. Perhaps someone can help me.

I have usually used the AWB setting on my K10D and most pictures ('snaps') look OK - natch, I suppose.
But, when I was photographing Whales off a boat, off Maine, the pictures were all far too blue. (Using RAW, Btw) This has surprised me because I thought that AWB would try to 'integrate to grey' and, for a scene with lots of blue in it, I would have expected the blues to be toned down, rather than exaggerated. I could get the colour hue / tint / balance I wanted (as I 'remembered the scene and what 'looked nicest' to me - sorry to the purists but you know what I mean) by using the 'temperature' control on Aperture.

Looking at other pictures - sunsets, for instance - the AWB seems to exaggerate the red, rather than toning it down, for an overall grey.

Sometimes I use the shade or cloudy or sunny settings and get varying results but I am a bit of a rudderless ship and can't really find a rule to work to.

Do other people have the same problems? If so, what do they do about it? Using a compact, point-and-shoot, seems not to give the same problems so could it be the use of RAW - which, of course, is wonderful in every other respect.

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on How to use the Colour Balance control on a DSLR at 05/10/2009 - 22:40

sophiecentaur
People still buy pounds of potatoes and say the temperature is 65Farenheit. They (and I) will say "Jeez, that's thirty bob!"

It's only a matter of familiarity.

Where lenses are concerned, if a given lens can be fitted to a range of mounts with a range of sensor sizes (only two, at present, I think) it's essential that the focal length of the lens is used to describe it. Any other description is open to misunderstanding. (Even quoting the 35mm equivalent can introduce problems because you can end up doing the conversion twice!)

How many serious users of a DSLR do the conversion from 200mm to 300mm when selecting which lens to use? They just get to associate a certain focal length with an appropriate range of subjects and distances. You get to know what to expect when you look through the viewfinder.

The "Equivalent Game" is just there for the benefit of lens manufacturers. They want to make out you're getting more for your money. They omit to point out that, for wide angle lenses, you are getting LESS.

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on lenses designed for digital at 14/07/2009 - 10:08

sophiecentaur
sorry george

But what is the answer to my OP?
The AAAAperture library is a great beast inside of which you cannot look, I think. What are the advantages of using it to store everything?

Comment by sophiecentaur posted on another aperture question at 13/07/2009 - 18:34

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo