All Forum Comments
Comment by RichardDay posted on DA* 60-250? at 19/11/2009 - 12:33
Surely you meant to say "the Elite".
If I would make a guess I think it would be Capture One though.
Silkypix does have just as many local controls, they are just named differently and many perform in a different way, in fact there are considerably more adjustments than with almost any other RC, you will have to persevere with the different way of arriving at the results you are after. There are at least two very important controls that LR doesn't have and that is perspective correction and lens distortion correction. Also the CA correction is much easier to implement with SP, the automatic eye dropper control is an absolute boon, as well as the dodging control (do read up about that!).
Yes it certainly is a big lack that LR that it does not have Lens correction controls like many other RAW converters.
Dodging tool appears to do the same thing as brightness in LR, at least that's what I've heard. Also need to look into that.
Also with SP (Pro version), there is now very little need to open your image in Photoshop for final output as Silkypix now has printing profile support and has very full control over final output for both print and screen.
If we merely talk about printing then Lightroom already had that since day one.
In fact, with LR, a large (PSD) file is produced in the background before it is opened in Photoshop. I agree that it would be nice if SP had the ability to directly open output files in an external editor like Photoshop just like Capture One can, but nothing is perfect!
Regarding speed, I find that Silkypix Pro is slightly faster than LR3 and Capture One v4 on my machine and Raw Therapee is much slower. My computer is nothing special, it's an Acer Aspire 5920 laptop dual core with 4GB Ram, 320GB SATA 2 7200 rpm HD running Vista Premium.
If I move a slider in PS it takes around a second before a setting is applied, you see it working. With Capture one and Lightroom the effects are seen faster although the interface hicks a bit when applying the setting, Silkypix does not do that.
When working with the curve tool in SP you need to drop it to see the effect where with the "others" you don't have to drop it, that was one thing that annoyed me though.
Finally do not confuse Silkypix Pro with Silkypix v4 or v3, it's a much more comprehensive program.
EDIT
One of my pet hates with LR is that you cannot just open a single image directly, without first importing it into the library database. Also, if you move files or directories around your drive, you have to update the library each time. It's a real drag and a PITA.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Silkypix wont open RAW file at 19/11/2009 - 12:19
Sorry to the OP - just realised I've gone a bit off-subject!
Tony
One thing you might also miss and what I realize now are the local controls you've with Lightroom. Silkypix doesn't have it, just checked and Capture one neither so far as I know.
Slikypix is also slower then the other RAW converters I tried, results are good though so far (2 photos).
ps. a small question.
Is there a way to open you silkypix creation in photoshop without creating an extra file?
Since now I create an file open it in photoshop and throw the file away
Silkypix Pro's (UK English) manual is now available in PDF format from Silkypix UK's website: - link
Also with SP (Pro version), there is now very little need to open your image in Photoshop for final output as Silkypix now has printing profile support and has very full control over final output for both print and screen.
In fact, with LR, a large (PSD) file is produced in the background before it is opened in Photoshop. I agree that it would be nice if SP had the ability to directly open output files in an external editor like Photoshop just like Capture One can, but nothing is perfect!
Regarding speed, I find that Silkypix Pro is slightly faster than LR3 and Capture One v4 on my machine and Raw Therapee is much slower. My computer is nothing special, it's an Acer Aspire 5920 laptop dual core with 4GB Ram, 320GB SATA 2 7200 rpm HD running Vista Premium.
Finally do not confuse Silkypix Pro with Silkypix v4 or v3, it's a much more comprehensive program.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Silkypix wont open RAW file at 18/11/2009 - 22:45
I don't think Richard is saying that the 16-50 is optically inferior to the others, though he wasn't very impressed by the wide-open performance. Above 24mm he describes it as stellar.
The 16-50's problem is the price. You have to really need the weather-sealing and large aperture to justify such a huge premium over the 16-45.
G
Optically, there is absolutely no better zoom than the 16-50 above 24mm, in fact it can equal or better the best primes under most conditions. It's just that it's now so expensive!
On a purely personal level, I have mixed feelings about the 16-50 as I find the performance rather unbalanced and I frequently changed the focus instead of zooming, due to the size and placement of the narrow zoom ring. I used one for a couple of months and finally decided it wasn't for me and eventually opted for the DA 17-70 as it was just more universal for my needs, but oh, how I wish it had the wider 16mm field of view and lower barrel distortion of the DA 16-45.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 18/11/2009 - 22:06
My choices, in order, with no price limitation plus some of my own observations, would be as follows.
DA 17-70, Now much too expensive, but a very nice lens overall and well made, SDM AF only and is not that fast, but very positive.
DA 16-45, The bargain in the Pentax range, great IQ wide open and the best of all at the wide end. Wobbly zoom barrel, but fast AF.
DA*16-50, Ridiculous price now, relatively weak at the wide end compared to it's stellar peformance from 24mm and above. WS, but is large and heavy and the zoom ring is very narrow (and too close to the body) in comparison to the focus ring.
Tamron 17-50, Reasonable range, very sharp, well priced and constant f2.8, no quick shift, somewhat muddy muted colours and evidence of severe field curvature at the wide end, also reports of sample variation with regard to focussing accuracy.
Sigma 17-70, For - range, price and f2.8 at the wide end that's useful if you're really stuck for light. Against - Sigma quality (?), no quick shift, warm and slightly muted colour, soft edges, reverse focusing direction to Pentax and Tamron lenses.
If I was to consider cost then it would be:
DA 16-45
DA 17-70 (just!)
Tamron 17-50
Sigma 17-70
DA*16-50
Others opinions will definitely vary!
Comment by RichardDay posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 18/11/2009 - 19:18
People with opinions just go around bothering each other.
Most of the top Raw converters are excellent compared to shooting in JPEG! But some people prefer different aspects when it comes to using them.
I often find that many users haven't really explored them in depth sufficiently and therefore have a unrepresentative, or even biased viewpoint, based upon their incomplete analysis. The more complex the program, the more I find people have incomplete knowledge about them.
Silkypix especially is a classic example, due to it's unconventional and often bizarre naming of functions, but I persisted with it very early on and learnt my way around it to the point I now feel completely at home with it. I have even used the Japanese version (now that's challenging!), but even so I still ocassionally find out some new aspects of a feature that I haven't explored fully in the past.
The new Pro version is a very complete and powerful Raw converter, and I, like many others, always gravitate back to it after trialling the other main offerings. But I do revisit all the major converters when a new version is announced to see what improvements and features have been introduced.
Currently playing with Capture One v5 and Lightroom v3, I've also recently tried DxO pro v5 and will shortly trial Bibble 5 preview v3. I currently keep Capture One v4 and Raw Therapee as well as ACR (i.e. Photoshop) on my computer.
You can burn up an awful lot of time trying to keep up with Raw converters!
Comment by RichardDay posted on Silkypix wont open RAW file at 18/11/2009 - 18:43
Thanks a lot for the detailed description Richard. Blimey, that sounds like a lot to do at the shop - but I guess it's worth it if you know you're going away with a decent lens.
Do you take your own tripod or does SRS provide one for you - I'm sure they'd be amenable!
I usually take my own kit as I try not to overstretch my welcome, or their patience!
Comment by RichardDay posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 18/11/2009 - 18:02
Doh - Am I the only one who's not in a camera club
No you're not the only one Gareth
I live in my own little world, in a club of one! ... But, it's okay, they know me there!
Comment by RichardDay posted on I am the only one with a pentax in our club!! - warnig - rambling post at 16/11/2009 - 22:02
Richard, I'd be interested to know how yours and your acquaintances' bad copies underperformed. From what you're saying there seem to be real QC issues with this lens. Is this right?
Also, I've been meaning to ask you - what do you do in-store to check a lens? Given that I have to buy lenses in/from countries where I'm not resident (have yet to come across a Pentax lens in Addis or Colombo), this would be a very useful skill for me to acquire!
Agree with your point about prices - is the 17-70 worth so much more than the 16-45? Probably not. I'm glad I got mine before the (double?) price rise and with the £50 cashback!
I will say that this seemed to have been the case with some early samples. I believe that later units are pretty consistent, but even so a rogue one can appear. It's usually down to transit knocks that can cause things to go out of alignment. I actually find it amazing that they can survive the transit knocks that they're subjected to before we get them!
My testing methods. They are not desperately technical, but I think they are valid and more than accurate enough for most purposes.
The following applies using a K20D or K-7, much harder to do with a body that doesn't have individual lens AF adjustment (in fact, pretty near impossible! I won't buy a DSLR now without individual lens AF adjustments).
What I do to quickly check is firstly to mount the camera on a tripod and use 2 sec delay for mirror lock up and take a shot wide open at the longest focal length on an object that would fill the screen at x11 magnification that contains considerable detail, such as a sign or a car number plate. I do all the checks using x11 magnification on the review screen (on a K20D), which equates to approx full size.
I would check for front and back focus by adjusting the lens AF adjustment from -10 to +10 to find the sharpest setting, hopefully around the center (0) setting. I don't actually like using an angled focus chart as I have found them to give inconsistent results.
I would then check again with a close object and a more distant object to check that the setting remains constant, if not, I would probably reject the lens. If it's okay, I would repeat the test at two or three other focal lengths to see if the focus adjustment stays constant. Again, if not, I would reject the lens.
I will then take a shot of a fairly flat plane object at a reasonable distance, like the front of a flat building, and examine for equal sharpness fall off across the frame, if one or two corners, or an edge, is worse than the other(s), then that indicates an alignment problem. I would recheck at medium and close distances and if there is unequal softness, I would reject the lens.
This building is a familiar sight to anyone who visits SRS!

I would do all my tests in daylight and at ISO 100.
If I do my tests at home, I sometimes use a newspaper for medium to long focus lenses that should have fairly flat field charicteristics for close tests, I do not use this for wide angle lenses, as they tend to have greater field curvature and at such close distances you're almost guaranteed to get large fall off in sharpness across the frame, but I do expect a wide angle lens to have reasonable sharpness across the frame at distances beyond 2 to 3 metres. It's vital that you ensure that your camera is perfectly aligned at right angles to avoid errors. This is a typical shot (taken at 70mm focal length).

For longer distances I use the following building in Gloucester docks. I'm sure you could find something similar.
For example at 60mm.

and at 250mm.

I hope this helps and gives you some guidelines to work with. Don't be too exacting, you can live with small inconsistencies as nothing is absolutely perfect, but usually a lens that has a serious issue in one area, will have problems elsewhere as well. It's usually quite clearly obvious when a lens is not up to the mark.
Comment by RichardDay posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 16/11/2009 - 21:30
Looks like SilkyPix seems to be coming out favourite?
If that's the case, as a 'newbie' to this sort of software, would I be better off going for v4 or jump straight in with Pro?
Comment by RichardDay posted on Best raw conversion software? at 14/11/2009 - 20:22


I've had quite a collection of long lenses, Sigma 70-300 APO, Sigma 100-300 EX, Tamron 70-300 macro (both versions LD and Di), Tamron 70-200 f2.8 Di, Tokina 80-200 f2.8 ATX Pro, Tokina 80-400 ATX, Pentax DA 55-300, Pentax A*300 f4, Pentax FA*300 f4.5.
Only the FA* was as good, but the flexibility and convenience of the 60-250 is so convenient plus it's very sharp at all focal lengths and wide open.
I have a series of test shots and examples on my flickr site LINK