All Forum Comments
Comment by richandfleur posted on hands on kp @ srs at 13/02/2017 - 21:29
What would you like to see lol
Call me easily pleased or what have you, but I'm totally satisfied with Pentax's stills ability. Sure I'd love to see their AF be a bit smarter, and give a hope of some focus tracking ability at my children's sports day races etc, but I'm really impressed with the Pentax stills capabilities already.
What I'd like to see now is an attempt to polish the video package they already have. Notice I'm not even mentioning 4K etc, as I think they just need to get their basics right.
Returning mechanical stabilisation during video seems a must, even if it's off by default and has a warning about possible noise when you want to turn it on. Sensor based SR works in video on Panasonic, Olympus and Sony cameras now, and Pentax had this working on the K-5 and K-7 models pre Ricoh:
Upping the video quality bit rates from their current 2012 settings would be useful also. With the new chips on the modern cameras I'm sure we can do better now than we did 5 years ago.
So yeah, sort that and we'll be onto a winner.
What do I expect though? Probably a K-3 with the new sensor of the KP and the focussing of the K-1. Maybe a touchscreen if they're being daring. And the same old video package I expect it will be a great mini K-1 camera and a worth K-3 successor.
Comment by richandfleur posted on hands on kp @ srs at 13/02/2017 - 20:28
These might be of interest
Hope the link works like that.
For me personally, in terms of what I do with a DSLR for video, I'm not worried at all by a limit of 29 minutes recording, (which is based on an EU tax category restriction). I'd suggest that if you are worried by that limit, then you really shouldn't be using a DSLR for the task. You won't find a 29 minute+ scene in any film, tv or music video
You can do a lot with video on the Pentax. It's not horrible, but it could be a whole heap better pretty easily. For best results I'd suggest not thinking of DSLR video as a handicam, and remember all your stills considerations of composition, exposure, focus, depth of field, framing etc all remain equally as important for DSLR video
Comment by richandfleur posted on Movie at 13/02/2017 - 20:20
but there's no reason why a dslr couldn't have an off centre electronic viewfinder also.
Not saying it's particularly smart or sensible mind
Comment by richandfleur posted on hands on kp @ srs at 12/02/2017 - 23:00
The current Pentax file format came in in 2012, and replaced a less compressed/larger file type from the K-7/k-5 cameras. The older format will produce much larger files, but with less compression and potentially with more detail. In modern terms though, yeah, you'll go through some space Pentax seems to have opted for smaller file sizes, valuing more compression over quality/higher bit rates, which is strange given their focus on high image quality in stills.
For interests sake, the mini DV tapes from early digital camcorders were not compressed at all, and produced massive files sizes for tiny SD resolution 720x576 video.
100mm macro lens in aps-c format (appeared larger on the back screen)
One odd thing though, you can look at a static photo hundreds of times but a movie clip much less. I suppose it locks you in to a time frame whereas a photo can be 1 sec or a minute.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Movie at 12/02/2017 - 22:26
Thanks for your generous responses, I will go through them in detail and see if I can come up with a decent result. I do see that there is shake reduction in movie mode though, but I guess if using a tripod it should be switched off.
Ps richandfleur, K1 has a headphone jack and a menu option to adjust headphone volume.
First thing to watch is that you get your exposure right in camera in video mode. There's not a lot of leeway to push the video image, as it's essentially akin to a predeveloped jpeg still.
Pentax users who don't use video often say things like "Pentax doesn't do video" etc, but every Pentax DSLR since 2009 has had video capabilities. They do do video, just not very well unfortunately. As you say, some models feature mic or headphone ports, and there's simply no need for these at all for stills. They are video features, on a Pentax.
DSLR's make an excellent choice for video work, as they allow you to interchange lenses, and their larger sensors allow for easy depth of field manipulation over a standard handicam. As Nigel mentions above, equivalent interchangeable lens video cameras cost in the region of 4 x a K-1.
The stills equivalent of a handicam video camera is a point and shoot/bridge camera, with a fixed lens and smaller sensor, so handicams aren't in the same creative league as a DSLR.
Just as bridge cameras have their place, so to do handicams. If you're looking to simply capture a long performance, with no artistic aspect, then a handicam is ideal. Likewise for a soccer game etc. In these situations, and you could include converting old home movies to digital, a handicam is fine. They're great for recording a lecture, rolling for hours, times when you don't mind zooming etc.
Pentax DSLR's have only just offered continuous AF in video mode, on the K-70, which uses on sensor phase detect AF points. Everything else allows you to focus with the AF button, but it's not continuous. I don't mind that, as I hate the AF hunting look during video, but AF is useful to lock on to start with. Pentax offers focus peaking, which works great (even though it's limited to just the one colour/amount). However, this stops working during video capture, which is unfortunately when you need it most, given there is no AF in video in most Pentax cameras.
The 'Movie SR' is electronic, meaning it's software that tries to stabilise the image. It's not the real sensor shake reduction that is in use during stills capture, or that was used during video capture back on the K-7 and K-5 series. It introduces a lot of image warping, and frankly is poor at best. If you're not shaking or movie that much, it can be ok, but on the whole it's best to leave it off and try to stabilise using your video editing software afterwards, if you access to something that can do this.
Unfortunately this feature (real mechanical sensor stabilisation during video) should be a Pentax strength, but nowadays it's only found in Sony, Olympus and Panasonic cameras. Others provide stabilisation within the lens, instead of the sensor itself, but lenses made for the Pentax mount usually strip this out, on the sensible belief that Pentax will use their own sensor stabilisation. Which is fine in stills mode, but Pentax don't offer it in video mode anymore.
DSLR's have been in use for video for a long time now. Way back in 2010 the finale episode of one of the House seasons was filmed on DSLRs for example. The 29 minute limit is only an issue if you want to record straight. Personally I film a lot of little clips, and then stitch them together.
Another thing to consider is your frame rate. 24fps is standard for bluray/film, but it's not fast enough to provide smooth motion in pans. That's an issue that's independent of the camera. This was one aspect that lead to the TV's with faster refresh rates, and interpolated frames to try and reduce this issue. Setting to 1080p at 30fps might help you if you're seeing this at 24fps? 24fps was an option that was added in 2012, as the models previous to this had 25fps only, and no focus peaking.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Movie at 12/02/2017 - 21:42
With the K-01 and K-30 Pentax dropped the real mechanical sensor stabilisation of the K-7 and K-5 series. It's never been seen again since, which is disappointing given it was well ahead of its time. Nowadays you'll find it in several cameras, (such as Panasonic, Sony and Olympus), just not from Pentax.
The other aspect is the bit rate, which essentially describes how much detail of a complex moving scene can be captured, before it blocks up into a pixelated mess. Once again, this hasn't changed since 2012, on any new Pentax camera, and it's looking ridiculous 5 years later in 2017.
I'm concerned that when Pentax finally address their video offering they won't address the basics. 4K will become a standard spec within a few years, but simply transferring what we have to a higher resolution will let us see that blocky mush mess more clearer.
For now though, if you tripod mount your camera, set the focus well, pick all the best quality mode stars, and there is not too much movement in the scenes, you should do ok. If you are recording to 29minute lengths, and don't require the depth of field for example that a DSLR can offer over a handicap, then a basic video recorder might suit your needs better.
Warning, I'm about to post my usual wish list again. Those who have seen this, or are bored of it, please look away now...
Return physical Sensor Stabilisation during video recording. (Provide menu option to enable/disable this if there are any audible noise issues associated with this).
Ensure no field of view cropping occurs if the inbuilt stabilisation is turned OFF.
Enable Focus Peaking during video recording.
Up the bit rates to something more modern, from the current 18Mb/s or so 2012 spec.
Enable clean HDMI out, at user selectable resolution and frame rate, for those who want to use a more capable external recording device.
Up the maximum 1080 progressive framerate, to enable full HD slow motion options when slowed back down in post.
Show visual on screen audio levels, so that the appropriate audio gain setting can be selected.
Offer a headphone out jack, so that the audio levels can be monitored if desired.
Allow for flashing highlights, blinking highlights, blinkies, zebras etc during video recording, to convey blown hightlights/full black exposure areas.
Consider additional video formats, in case something more suitable is available.
Provide flat a picture profile / higher bitrate option for pro users.
Then offer 2.7K resolution, so there is the ability to stabilise and crop in post if required.
Then offer 4K resolution.
Then offer 4.6K resolution, so there is the ability to stabilise and crop in post if required.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Movie at 12/02/2017 - 19:53
With the mirror up, a dslr is in 'mirrorless mode'. With on sensor phase detect AF points in the K-70, smart tracking options could be implemented like many mirrorless cameras offer.
If the same lens mount is used, then mirrorless and dslrs have more in common than they are different really.
Issue I can see with the KP is that it's priced really high for what's close to a K-70 internals. It doesn't have the k-3 1/8000 shutter etc and I think you are paying a lot for the 'retro' casing, which I personally don't mind the look of.
Mute point for me through, as I'm not buying a new Pentax until they improve on the 2012 video spec (most importantly returning mechanical SR during video). At which point I'll buy it regardless of what housing they put it in.
Comment by richandfleur posted on hands on kp @ srs at 12/02/2017 - 04:25
Richard, i'm glad you heard the siren call!
You're not needed to check if the camera flashes do the 'control' triggering.... What needs to be established is whether the Shanny's slave modes have an option that ignores the pre-flashes and therefore syncs the flash with the exposure.
These slave modes are commonly labelled SL1 and SL2, or S1 and S2 ..... The 2nd one is the one that usually ignores pre-flashes.
Point to what you want to test and how to confirm it, and I'm sure someone will help

Comment by richandfleur posted on Early adopter Shanny SN600FGZ at 08/02/2017 - 21:02
Can't see that the preflash can give any additional info to the off camera flash, other than go now! Can't see that it can give varying info around how strong to flash etc
Also add to this Pentax mucking with the flash capabilities of its cameras now. I'll have to check that they K-30 and K-S1 can both do this pre flash command mode.
Personally just waiting for an affordable off camera HSS trigger option to compliment they SHANNY.
On both my cameras, inserting the SHANNY brings up the red GPS symbol. That's of more concern to me right now?! Weird.
Flash wise though, you do get genuine HSS supporting PTTL flash for not much money. That in itself is pretty awesome.
Comment by richandfleur posted on Early adopter Shanny SN600FGZ at 08/02/2017 - 18:39


You really wouldn't want a touch screen unless it can be turned off, so there is no point in having it in the first place. A touch screen only device (AKA a mobile phone) is already available for those that prefer it complete with video capabilities. Can you imagine a Pentax camera being yet another Android phone which appears to be your wish?
Just imagine having to go into touch screen menus before you take a photo or video to set up various options. A Spotmatic would be many times faster to use and produce better results with a nice new roll of Ektachrome.
I could see a touchscreen being good for menus, and especially for photo reviewing on the rear screen. I've heard good things about using the touchscreen for focus point selection also. No reason why it can't be turned off, or used for just selected tasks. Pentax have always been pretty good at allowing users to customise the buttons etc, so I'd expect they'd be able to implement this well. Wouldn't have to replace physical buttons either, so you'd chose.
How do you mount your different lenses to your mobile phone?
That type of response to video is really common, and I think it stems from handicams and endless hours of holiday video etc. Just because a cellphone can take video, doesn't mean it's a viable replacement for DSLR video. Just as a cellphone is likely not a replacement for your DSLR stills...