richandfleur

Joined: 3rd December 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

richandfleur
Personally this reinforces the now relatively small incremental improvements happening in the sensor technology these days. If you filter on the right by Pentaxyou'll see we've not really progressed much in the last 4 years or so on this single particular aspect. (To be clear, I'm NOT saying the cameras have not progressed at all).

Also, comparing images resized down to 800x529 pixels seems fairly pointless to me, when you're trying to spot such relatively minute/incremental differences. I expect could just have easily used an iPhone for that same shot with the differences no more clear to see once resized down.

For the record, I invite you to view the detail of the brown feathers from the K-30 which presently costs roughly half that of the K-5IIs

Comment by richandfleur posted on Got to be asked....K5 ii or iis... at 06/03/2014 - 20:09

richandfleur
Smeggypants wrote:
There's absolutely no difference between the two for all practical photography purposes
Especially at this dramatically reduced web resolution.

Only difference I can really spot is a higher colour saturation in one of them.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Got to be asked....K5 ii or iis... at 06/03/2014 - 05:44

richandfleur
[quote:3496ace15f="kh1234567890"]the same scene with the same lens and the same postprocessing /quote]

You can't really use the same post processing for both and expect to see comparative results most would be hoping for. I see that request a lot, "I applied the exact same settings to each" etc.

The end result is the important bit, although it's obviously nice if you can get to the optimum in as few a steps (noise reduction etc) as possible. Personally I'm all for as much detail as possible in the straight out of camera shot. It's always harder to add what's not there in the first place.

The guts of this thread seems to be that on the whole the IIs will be sharper, but it's more prone to exhibit moire when you get that nowadays rare situation of it being produced. In which case the II will perform better, but no one really seems to know how affective the AA filter in the II is anyway. And no one really know exactly how much more sharper the IIs is either. However, if it costs more it must be better right?

If anyone is really, really worried about it, I am prepared to exchange my K-30 for their camera, so they can be safe in the knowledge that this model line doesn't have an option for any different AA filter variant.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Got to be asked....K5 ii or iis... at 06/03/2014 - 00:00

richandfleur
Is the AA filter an element that can be removed from any recent Pentax camera? ie can one (if so motivated) opt to create a K5s, or K-30s model by removing said filter component?

Or is it a treatment/baked or fused onto another required component?

Just wondering, no reason...

Comment by richandfleur posted on Got to be asked....K5 ii or iis... at 05/03/2014 - 23:30

richandfleur
Fletcher8 wrote:
the thing that hit me was the feel of or should I say lack of in relation the the quality of the K7, K5, K3.
Not show related but I know exactly what you mean. Hard to fully convey, but the button resistance when you push them and the lack of wiggle in the buttons, and the lack of flex in the camera body when you hold the camera are definitely distinctly better on a Pentax, from many eras actually. My K100D still feels solid even today compared to other brands...

Comment by richandfleur posted on NEC Photography Show at 04/03/2014 - 23:11

richandfleur
I read an article on this the other day, about how comfortable a buyer felt that they would be looked after by the company. This was both with regards to system cameras (ones that required non standard lenses etc) and with regards to future firmware support to deliver future features back to older model lines. (Apple seems to do this well for instance with their fleet wide iOS upgrades etc).

With the Q and MX-1 both being discontinued I can't help but see a heap of development energy being wasted here.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Q10-now discontinued. at 04/03/2014 - 23:08

richandfleur
Moire tends to be an issue related to resizing also, as illustrated above by the comment that you think you have it (when viewing a scaled down picture) but it's not there on the full sized picture. It was much more common in the earlier days of smaller resolution photos from 6MP sensors etc, than it is today. I found some recently on some architecture photos from a friend, and was really impressed with Lightroom 5.3 (?)'s ability to remove this with the adjustment brush.

Some subject matter is obviously more prone with some subject matter, so the K-3's approach is most likely the best option, but in all cases you're probably not going to realise you have the issue until much later, in which case you can't easily retrospectively opt to turn the filter back on.

For me personally, I think I'd prefer to go without and deal with the consequences when they happened. It's a fair call however, as above by others, that if you're doing weddings etc then maybe you'd opt to be safe rather than sorry, assuming the AA filters actually do work as described? With modern high res sensors, do we even need the AA filters any more?, and do they protect enough under conditions where Moire will be present - ie how much do they reduce the effect really?

Comment by richandfleur posted on Got to be asked....K5 ii or iis... at 04/03/2014 - 21:38

richandfleur
Hi,

I've been considering this lens for a while, and I've been warned that there aren't many 2nd hand... but I'm keen to hear from anyone who maybe wants to part with theirs? No idea of what this would be going for 2nd hand?

After the 14mm f/2.8 IF ED UMC Aspherical manual focus lens, usually Samyang but it goes by a few other trading names. I think there may have been a dodgy first version so I'm after the normal 2nd version of this.

Drop me a PM if you've got ideas / one available. Would need postage to London area, or could possibly collect depending on location around that area.

Thanks

Comment by richandfleur posted on Wanted: Samyang (or other variant) 14mm f/2.8 IF ED UMC Aspherical at 04/03/2014 - 07:14

richandfleur
richandfleur wrote:
This is all sounding good. I hope I have a similar good story to tell soon
my story has been sorted too by the looks of it. Got the camera back about 2 weeks after it arrived with them.

Looks to be sorted but won't know for sure until I get to try it out again later in the month. Johnsons Photopia were easy to deal with and appear to have sorted the problem in a quick and professional manner.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax repair times at 03/03/2014 - 23:21

richandfleur
Update again. The camera has now been returned to my sister in the UK from Johnsons Photopia. I haven't tested the results but understand the technician was able to replicate the fault so that was a huge relief with the postage effort and all.

The report is very quick and vague (ha reads like a Pentax firmware update change log) :
REPLACED DIAPHRAGM MECHANISM- ADJUSTED & CALIBRATED- CLEANED- CHECK & TEST

I have no idea where or what a body Diaphragm Mechanism is, but hopefully it does the trick. Others appear to have reported an Aperture Motor fault but I'll know when I get the camera back to New Zealand later in the month.

Johnsons Photopia were quick and easy to deal with.

Comment by richandfleur posted on K-30 random exposure failure issue at 03/03/2014 - 23:17

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo