niblue

Joined: 13th December 2005

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

niblue
It was the Tamron I'd originally considered when I was looking for a 28-200 lens for use on family days out etc. I went with the Pentax one in the end mainly because the costs were similar and it was reputed to have a better multi-coating, however the Tamron was getting good reviews at the time.

If I recall correctly the close focus on the Pentax is something like 52cm so there might well be a later model of Tamron than the one the Pentax was based on.

My Pentax 28-200 was a better performer than the other consumer lenses I had at the time (FA 28-80 and FA 100-300 - both powerzooms) and still performs quite well on digital, although the 1.5x multiplier does limit the usefulness of the wide end considerably. On the plus side the ability to vary the ISO setting makes the long end easier to hand-hold.

Comment by niblue posted on Tamron 28-200 at 29/03/2006 - 13:35

niblue
My wife is a biology teacher and this year will be taking part in various field trips including to Handa Island in Scotland (for bird watching) and to the Malaysian rain-forest. She's expressed an interest in getting a decent pair of binoculars so this would seem a good time to get them. I have a little set of 8x22 Canon's that I use when hill-walking etc, however I think something larger is required, however as she will be hiking on these trips it can't be something to large so the likes of 10x50 is out.

After looking around I think the Pentax 8x28 DCF MP could be a good option, especially as they're water and fogproof (ideal for the rain-forest) without being too expensive (£123 from Amazon).

Does anyone here have advice that they could offer - either on those particular binoculars or on others which might suit?

Regards
Steve

Comment by niblue posted on Question on binoculars at 26/03/2006 - 11:33

niblue
Another thing to consider is whether the lens needs to be 40-43mm or whether 50mm would suffice. A FA 50mm F1.7 can be had for a lot cheaper than the other two lenses and is an excellent performer. With digital then the 40-43mm lenses are going to be around 60mm equivalent while the 50mm while be the equivalent of 75mm - for portraits etc. the latter is (IMHO) a more useful focal length. Certainly the FA 50mm F1.7 is a massive step above the 18-55 in performance terms.

Comment by niblue posted on FA primes vs DA primes at 25/03/2006 - 08:02

niblue
Quote:
while the af is sluggish my af 1.7 telecoverter and 70-200 takumar-a 1:4 is usable and I think most would be satisfied.
Mine used to work fine with anything under F5.6 maximum aperture but didn't always work with F5.6 and above, even with a brightly lit, high contrast subject. The worst offended was the FA 100-300 as with the 1.7x that would never AF near the long end under any conditions.

Comment by niblue posted on lens tele extenders at 26/03/2006 - 09:38

niblue
I'd be surprised if AF worked at the long end with the 50-200 and the 1.7x

Comment by niblue posted on lens tele extenders at 25/03/2006 - 18:59

niblue
The Sigma 70-300 APO Macro is generally regarded as a good lens and should be considerably better quality that your current 100-300mm lens.

For zooms in that range I'd tend to stay away from anything with a maximum aperture of slower than F5.6 at the long end.

Comment by niblue posted on Zoom lens question - should i? at 25/03/2006 - 07:54

niblue
I'd agree about making sure you have a macro capability and in that case it might be worth considering the Sigma 70-300 APO Macro instead of the 80-320 Pentax as the Sigma has a very useful 1:2 macro capability.

Comment by niblue posted on Help! Zoom Lens for Pentax MZ50 at 25/03/2006 - 08:11

niblue
Quote:
Practical Photography reviewed ultrawide digital zooms in their May edition and gave the Pentax 10-17 both Best Buy and Best on Test!
The did give it a very good review, however in the context of the other lenses covered it would have been far better if they'd including the Pentax 12-24 instead.

The 10-17 is a very unusual lens and it wouldn't surprise me if some professional photograhers buy a Pentax DSLR just to allow then to use that lens (as happened with the previous fisheye zoom).

Comment by niblue posted on fisheyezoom at 26/04/2006 - 10:29

niblue
Matt is correct when describing fast prime lenses, however when it comes to fast zooms lenses (e.g. F2.8 ones) then it's my experience that they are usually sharper than slow zooms so one of the disadvantages mentioned "Can be soft (ie not as sharp)" doesn't usually apply. The weight and cost disadvantages still exists however, and to a greater extent than with primes.

If we compare the popular 80-200mm range then the F2.8 zooms (including the 3rd party ones) perform at a significantly higher level than the F4-F5.6 consumer zooms, however they are a lot heavier and a lot more expensive. Despite that it's my opinion that a 80-200mm F2.8 is one of the most useful lenses available.

Comment by niblue posted on lenses at 25/03/2006 - 08:08

niblue
Quote:
The AF-500FTZ is a more powerful gun which has a tilt 'n swivel head but is less compatible with the newer cameras as, amongst other things, it doesn't do wireless mode.
The DL lacks TTL compatibility so the AF500FTZ would be manual only with it.

Comment by niblue posted on AF360 FGZ FLASHGUN at 18/03/2006 - 14:52

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo