All Forum Comments
Comment by Mongoose posted on K10D or....... at 22/05/2007 - 14:28
Unfortunately I still don't think this answers the question, it seems to me that it will depend on
1. whether or not the Samsung/Pentax lenses actually roll of their own separate production lines
2. if it's the same line, how hard is it to switch coatings. It may actually be more expensive for Pentax to insist that Samsung use their own coatings than to simply do as Manesty suggested and prevent them from shouting about having SMC.
Comment by Mongoose posted on K10D or....... at 22/05/2007 - 14:01
Comment by Mongoose posted on K10D or....... at 22/05/2007 - 13:24
The 50-200 is a 10 group lens, if it were uncoated then it would pass only ~66% of the light compared to 98% with SMC. The Samsung versions would be best part of a full stop slower at the same F-stop not to mention the level of flare and ghosting you'd get. Inept as reviewers often are SOMEONE would have noticed.
I agree that if these lenses were packing the best coating system in the world (with the exception of SMC Ghostless of course) then it would seem odd that Sammy don't shout from the rooftops about it
Comment by Mongoose posted on K10D or....... at 22/05/2007 - 12:52
I am willing to pay the extra for the after sales service. I do wish someone somewhere could confirm whether or not the Sammy lenses have SMC coatings though, because if there's a decent price difference and the coatings are good then I might be convinced to swallow my pride and buy a Samsung badged 50-135 F2. 8 (damn I want that lens!)
Comment by Mongoose posted on K10D or....... at 22/05/2007 - 12:10
Comment by Mongoose posted on channel clipping vs in camera clipping and white balance at 21/05/2007 - 10:39
Go Ben, Go Ben, Go.......
Comment by Mongoose posted on I Can't Believe This.. at 21/05/2007 - 00:40
It's all real. Everything. Every little bit of praise. Yes!
Comment by Mongoose posted on It's REAL! at 21/05/2007 - 10:25
This is why 1.2V rechargeables are ok to use in devices designed for 1.5V alkaline cells.
Comment by Mongoose posted on About AA battery voltage at 19/05/2007 - 13:44
Expect to pay a premium for these lenses IF you can find them.
Comment by Mongoose posted on SMC - M series 35mm & 28mm f2 ?? at 19/05/2007 - 00:32


... if it were uncoated then it would pass only ~66% of the light compared to 98% with SMC.
To me, a coating is simply an additional layer, multi-coating being more than one additional layer, that would actually attenuate the lens's ability to pass light, not improve it. Hence flare control ! ! !
It's somewhat hard to explain without going into physics mode, but I'll do my best.
As you know, every time light hits a glass-air surface, a certain amount of it is reflected back. Uncoated glass in air will reflect approximately 4% (at this point I may have got my maths wrong earlier, I'm not totally sure if it's 4% per surface or 4% per element (2 surfaces), I assumed 4% per element). Total light transmission is therefore 96% to the power of the number of elements in the lens, 0.96^10 = 0.66, 66%
Coated glass takes advantage of the wave nature of light to reduce this. The amount of light reflected at a surface is controlled by the difference in refractive index between the two media (glass and air or coating). By picking your coating material carefully, and having a coating exactly 1/4 wavelength thick, you can arrange for the light reflected from the second surface to be exactly out of phase with the light reflected from the first surface. These two reflections then cancel out. Since energy is always conserved, and nothing is now being reflected, all the light has to be transmitted through the system.
In practice there are various reasons why it can't be done with just one coating, there isn't usually a material of exactly the right refractive index, and the coating would need to be a different thickness to be effective for different colours. By stacking several coatings, Pentax SMC is able to get the transmission rate up to 99.8% (again not sure if thats per surface or per element, I have assumed the latter) which gives the same 10 element lens coated with Pentax SMC a total transmission ratio of 98%.
Incidentally multi-coating is the main reason we are able to use simple F stops with a high degree of accuracy rather than having to compensate for the number of elements in a lens. Modern zooms would be impossible, or at least impractical, without it.