mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
johnriley wrote:
It looks like you have your plan then. The 21/40/70 set is a nice choice if you like primes and they are all excellent quality and very compact.

How can you go wrong?
By spending money on something I don't as I already have the 28 mm lens!

That's the nub of the issue. I don't mind spending the ,money but will I get a sharper lens?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Old vs New at 18/09/2008 - 16:08

mikew
johnriley wrote:
There's a bit of a contradiction here as the lenses mentioned are quite different. The 28mm becomes a slightly wide standard lens on a DSLR and the 40mm becomes a slight telephoto. These are different things and don't have interchangeable function.

The 21mm becomes a rather wide standard lens or a very mild wide angle, depending on your taste, but is a different beast again.

I think the decision depends on what sort of images you are hoping to capture. If you wanted a multi purpose everyday catch-all lens then the 18-55mm kit lens would be a better choice. The K10D is hardly light and compact to begin with, again depending on your point of view and what you compare it with, so a compact lens is not going to make it pocketable.
I take your point about the differences between the 21 and 40 and their use. Blush, the plan would be to get the 21/40/70 over a period so which comes first is a bit academic.

I have replaced the kit lens with a Tamron 17-50 which is quite big but does offer f2.8 and I do want that wider aperture which would rule out the kit lens anyway.

Also the kit lens is also quite lengthy especially with its hood on while the 28 is quite compact and the pancake would be negligible.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Old vs New at 18/09/2008 - 15:53

mikew
The pancake would be new and AF - I can quite see why you'd get your mitts all over it with manual focus.

But will the Ltd be a sharper lens.

I guess I should just use the 28 for a while - good enough is good enough

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Old vs New at 18/09/2008 - 15:48

mikew
OK I am being tempted to get a pancake lens for my K10D - possibly a 40mm or the 21 mm as I want a light and small lens for general use.

At the moment the 40mm Ltd is looking good but I already have a 28mm f2.8 Pentax A lens so all it lacks is the autofocus and that's not really a deal breaker as I reckon I can focus pretty quickly.

Will the Ltd lens be better quality than the A lens which was after all designed for full frame? Otherwise the 28 is OK, it's equal to 42mm full frame which is an OK walkabout lens length and while it isn't pancake it's small and light.

Any thoughts?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Old vs New at 18/09/2008 - 15:13

mikew
beginner wrote:
I dont use Photoshop or the like I just try and the best out of my camera that I can!,I have a Ds which I love and produced shots on a par with ,if not better ,than friends on a photo blog with all the latest top notch gear from both Canon and Nikon!.This was because I stuck at it and learned how to get the best out of it,I now have the K20 which I am trying to get to grips with, it's going to be a long process but I'll get there in the end.Why do we yearn for 2 more frames a second or af a fraction of a second faster,or even more pixels?.I think we should all think back to photographic technique rather than demand cameras that do more and more!........People might think I'm strange.....but I'm not really!..lol
I pretty much agree with this. I did upgrade from a K100D to a K10D because at the SRS price it was too tempting and did deliver extra facilities that made life better.

But I know it's my technique that's the weak link in the chain and that I have sufficient pixels etc. to deliver very high quality images if only I were good enough. I remember when I had an old Leica IIIA with a 50mm lens and a light meter I barely used as I learned how to guess the exposure. I still have a few of those images about the place while the camera is long gone.

Then again I enjoy a good session of technicalities and LBA!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Honest Jealousy at 18/09/2008 - 07:15

mikew
Certainly I find the Tamron a bit big on the K10 and I do rather like the idea of a more discrete lens which I think the 21mm is while the 31 is possibly not. In my heart I still hanker for a Leica or similar but my wallet ...

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on pentax 16-45mm or sigma EX18-50mm at 16/09/2008 - 20:22

mikew
Isn't the 16-50 bigger and heavier? I haven't checked but I think it is. My current lust is for a 21mm prime and I'm selling my old Leica 35mm to help finance this. I would consider the b31mm but it's more expensive but the killer is the size.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on pentax 16-45mm or sigma EX18-50mm at 16/09/2008 - 20:14

mikew
I wanted f2.8 for two things, more limited depth of field and also the ability to shoot in lower light. I was always finding that I was using the kit lens at its maximum aperture and I wasn't happy.

If this link works then it answers your question but not my photograph:

link

I find I use f4 quite a bit, well enough, and wouldn't want that to be the maximum aperture. That said I wish the Pentax 16-45 had been cheaper when I bought.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on pentax 16-45mm or sigma EX18-50mm at 16/09/2008 - 18:13

mikew
The 16-45 is f4 while the Tamron 17-50 is 2.8 and that extra stop can make the difference and I find it is a good lens although I realise you didn't mention it.

But I haven't used the 16-45 so I can't comment beyond that.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on pentax 16-45mm or sigma EX18-50mm at 16/09/2008 - 09:46

mikew
I once gave a 12 session course in programming in C to a research establishment - and to my horror one member of the group had been in the team that developed ALGOL. I really did feel unworthy in her presence.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on DON'T BUY PENTAX DIGITAL LENSES!!! at 13/09/2008 - 10:10

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo