All Forum Comments
Just to hijack the thread how on earth did we get stuck with 10x8 paper?
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Print sizes .. I need help plz at 24/02/2009 - 21:09

What I don't get is
70 mm lens at F2.8
The focus was on the bricks
The sign is out of focus and it's a street sign mounted on the standard 2" tube being another 2" from the wall. Surely at over 6 feet (as I recall 8 feet) away the sign should be sharper according to DOF tables?
Or, as is usually the case have I misunderstood something?
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on Previous Competition Subjects at 24/02/2009 - 09:21
How long does it take to click on "gallery" and have a quick look?.......
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on new name for the gallery at 23/02/2009 - 20:30
Oh please! We all know the difference between a bad picture and what just doesn't light our candle. Some photos are simply bad and if the photographer really wants to improve he will want genuine honest advice and also somewhere where he/she can be assured of seeing (irrefutably) good examples of our craft.
Where can you suggest I go to see irrefutably good examples of photographs? Certainly not the Pentax Photo Gallery. There are some wonderful images there but equally there are many merely competent images that don't light my candle.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on new name for the gallery at 23/02/2009 - 20:20
Hmm...., I wonder what is worse.
Putting someone's work and efforts down( or saying it positively: give some positive criticism) or pampering someone to death with meaningless and counter productive compliments.
You might expect everybody wants to improve, in some kind of way.
Be it on the technical side, maybe on the artistic level. Even just to find out new angles and step out the personal comfort zone.
But as things go now it seems meaningless to discuss this any further.
Some people ask for a healthy dose of C&C. They can ask for it in the My Photo's section (if they dare :wink
Other seek it by joining one of the two competitions. That way they know for sure they get a good piece of feed back. (most of the times)
And then there are others who post/dump/show off in the gallery.(depending on the persons motivation) If lucky they learn and get better.
And if not so lucky they learn nothing and get lost....
So be it.
Martin.
There's a cracking site www.altphotos.com which has some really great stuff (and some truly dreadful stuff) but there is no real opportunity to comment or have a dialogue about the images so they won't get my $50!
I lurk in photoSig a lot and value some of the critiques offered a lot as they really help but even there a dedicated critique site you get platitudes and blasted birds get so much attention it's crazy.
For the little it's worth I think status quo is pretty good and just let people pile in their images into the gallery for anyone to see.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on new name for the gallery at 23/02/2009 - 19:35
I think I would have a hard job getting approval from my financial advisor.
The conversation would go something like,
Me: "Darling, blah blah, blah the best Macro lens in the world"
My FA: "What's a Macro lens? You want to spend how much?, no way Jose" and I'm not even called Jose.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on The ultimate macro lens? at 23/02/2009 - 17:19
Just to put things in to perspective, without stirring up the fire, I hope
Here you can read, what the Team had in mind, when they created the gallery.
Now....,I am the first to recognize the fact that tastes different, and each and everyone is free to judge his own work, and decide to place it in the gallery. But looking at some of the entries, and seeing the wonky horizons, unsharp or under/over exposed pictures I look in disbelief at the comments made, afterwards. The nice ones or slight variations on that appraisal are building up as you scroll along.
It is almost as if people are afraid to give honest C&C. And with that going on, I think.......Is anything learnt here?
Now...you can ask: Why should there be any learning involved ?
Obviously, the answer is No, there shouldn't !! But accepting that would also implicate there is a chance, the overall quality degrades by going on that way. And therefore drifting further and further away from the intended purpose of the gallery.
A major flaw of the gallery is the fact that there is no automated notification tool built in, so you (as a poster) have to do a lot of extra effort to check if anyone responded to your posting. A bad thing, I think. Even after several requests to fix it, still no sign of taking that seriously. The same goes for the weekly competition section. Even Worse, IMO.
These flaws are the main reason to delete my own pictures. I find it common practice to respond to every comment made at a picture of mine.
Simple courtesy, nothing more or less. But it is not doable without a notification. Now...with all of this in mind, let's return to the original issue. Is the gallery regarded as second class?? The answer should be No, as it is not intended that way by the Pentax User Team with the implementation of this gallery. But the people responsible for the launch of this gallery should also consider their responsibility in guarding their own idea, as it was intended at first.
Martin.
FWIW I think that people are quite reserved in offering negative feedback as I am sure no-one here wants to seem to be putting the efforts of others down in any way.
However, your logic is correct and there is a danger of the quality diluting over time. Personally I'd appreciate some positive criticism as I know I miss the target most of the time but seem unable to understand why!
As has been commented the judges comments in the competitions are generally very helpful and well thought out so it can be done.
Mike
Comment by mikew posted on new name for the gallery at 23/02/2009 - 16:27


I have barely used the 70 really but so far I like it. It's what a lens should be. Compact, light, easy to use, it's sharp, the colours are good and overall as you'd expect it seems a good lens. How much better than the Tamron 17-50 which is my usual walkabout I can't say yet. But I do like the fact I can have the 70 on the body, the 35 in one pocket and now thanks to Clarky the 21 Ltd in the other pocket. No bags!
It is beautifully made and I love the cap and hood which I know irritates some people. And from SRS it seems cheap really.
Mike