mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
I hope you weren't annoyed I used one of your photographs as an example Aiki. I agree with you I think that the birch would possibly be a good thing to make the subject of the photograph as they usually have some good texture and colour.

Speaking of which - brickwork, got any for the weekly?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Autumn in Nottingham at 28/11/2009 - 21:53

mikew
I think it would be really difficult to get any energy into this scene but for example link is a rather different scene but it has energy because of the way the photographer has chosen viewpoint etc.

Or this one link has structure and the only what I would call energy is imparted through the strong diagonal of the path.

You're not really just recording the scene anyway as you are making choices about what you show others in capturing what's before you. And in making those choices you can choose what's in and what's not and how they work together. You chose to shoot standing up - it would look quite different if you crouched down.

I have been trying to find suitable examples and of course I can't do it quickly but this link from our own Aiki (I hope she doesn't mind) could have been a simple photo of a plant but she chose the angle carefully and the way the leaves enter and leave the frame. For me the energy drives along the length of the leaves across the frame.

As you say not easy to communicate in text but hopefully someone better with words will come along soon.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Autumn in Nottingham at 28/11/2009 - 10:40

mikew
Brave man! Remember this is all IMO and I am well known to be wrong and ready to be corrected.

The colours are delightful and it's probably sharp although at this size it's hard to tell but after that what does the eye latch on to? You have one tree peeping in on the left - it's neither in nor out. Its branches are in but it's trunk is very shy. IMO you have to make your mind up - use the trunk as a frame or get rid of it. If you get rid of it where did the branches come from? It also casts a shadow bottom left which doesn't really do much.

On the right the rather nice silver tree seems to be equally shy and is trying to get out of shot but you were too quick for it! But the effect for me is that the tree is leaking out of frame.

Within the central portion of the frame where I would expect some action there's nothing to to latch onto. There are trees and stuff but they don't seem to form a cohesive pattern. All those blasted leaves centre left that are obviously dangling off something but I can't work out what. Actually they may be plants I can't tell.

It is a nice scene but as a photograph it seems aimless and you don't seem to have brought much to the party and injected any structure or energy into it which is what we are usually meant to do.

Phew - what a hatchet job. On the other hand what could anyone have done with this scene that would be better? If I were asked to take a photograph there I would decline as I can't see how I would do anything other than record the scene. (I drive my wife nuts doing that - refusing to take a shot because it has no potential or the light is wrong and the ultimate sanction is to hand her the camera, married 33 years and counting)

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Autumn in Nottingham at 28/11/2009 - 07:33

mikew
Do you welcome C&C?

Comment by mikew posted on Autumn in Nottingham at 27/11/2009 - 22:08

mikew
I was impressed by the Heath Robinson innovation.

If I had one optical slave could is use something like that to fire several guns at the same with cables all over the places?

Comment by mikew posted on Flash stand adaptation at 27/11/2009 - 18:55

mikew
I assume Lilly has now departed on her mammoth trip and therefore has not responded.

You can see her RPS photos on her Flickr site as well here

I hope she keeps us up to date on her travels.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Lilly's pictures at 27/11/2009 - 17:43

mikew
It's over processed AND about right. You weren't going for natural and have a good strong image. I like the central vertical but I'm not sure about the edges especially the left edge.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Decrepit... at 27/11/2009 - 15:58

mikew
A real contributor to the forum who we will miss.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Time to say goodbye at 27/11/2009 - 15:53

mikew
I came across this

link

and I'm sure it must be useful but I can't quite see how

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Flash stand adaptation at 27/11/2009 - 07:38

mikew
Models is for pussies - got to go makes

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly Competition #29: CARS at 26/11/2009 - 14:00

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo