McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
Thanks Couls and Andrew ... Weather has been good generally and Swanage is a beautiful area. These are always stimulating discussions ... Some things keep on coming up again and again of course. I'm looking forward to my 14mm and 135mm portraits for perspective comparisons and will post them here in future.

Go and enjoy the Sigma zoom on aps-c for now ... And lets hope you get the chance to experience it's wider field of view (but not different perspective!) on a Pentax FF very soon! You might just have to crop a bit if you want things to fill up the sensor as much.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 08/08/2015 - 09:16

McGregNi
It would be very interesting to test it for sure ... I'll try, but may not be able to post the results until back from holiday .... Nothing is simple it seems ... Well, at least for photography geeks

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 07/08/2015 - 16:57

McGregNi
Well it would be a boring old forum if we'd just ended it with 'yes' ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 07/08/2015 - 16:16

McGregNi
But I could take 2 portraits from the exactly the same distance from the subject ... One at 14mm and one at 135mm .... Would the perspective be the same? The shape rendering on the face would surely be different .. Is that not 'perspective'? (you'd have to really go to 200% or so to see it on the 14mm shot I guess ....)

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 07/08/2015 - 16:00

McGregNi
A very interesting observation Philip, and I'm sure that's right. It's focal length and distance that combine to produce the required magnification. The required magnification only has to be 'enough' .... Enough depends on the resolution and intended output size (print or screen).

For most purposes a frame filled aps-c size image at our modern resolutions is 'enough'. If that was taken with a 300mm lens than with modern resolutions there's no reason that it is not ' enough' for a full frame photographer as well. The superfluous pixels will just be cropped away.

Our FF shooter might feel cheated of course ... His bird or whatever looked smaller! Well, he doesn't need to spend a fortune on a FF diameter 400mm lens ...... What he might like is a viewfinder control to increase his viewfinder magnification to, say, 140% ..... Then at least he'll feel happier when shooting .... ! And his back balance will be as well .

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 07/08/2015 - 14:29

McGregNi
A good location and you've got some decent angles and captured the power of the sea ... Can hear the crashing and whooshing as I view them!

You were certainly a man on a mission there .... You were let down by the light unfortunately, there's not a great deal you could do with that light. Hopefully another opportunity will come along soon ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Hook Head Lighthouse at 07/08/2015 - 13:02

McGregNi
Sounds like we're singing the same tune then It doesn't take much in these sort of discussions for word definitions to be treated many different ways.

I think when people go FF they won't need longer lenses ... They might just have to crop a little if they want their sensor space filled more .....

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 07/08/2015 - 12:58

McGregNi
Another great set, and clearly the techniques have worked. The back button AF is one of those things we all should discover as soon as possible ... It seems so much more logical to divide the focusing, metering and capture actions.

Sometimes I have to put focusing back into the shutter button for someone else to use the K7, and when I use it again like that it just seems crazy to keep focusing and refocusing every time you need another frame.

Comment by McGregNi posted on The Hawk Conservancy Trust at 07/08/2015 - 11:11

McGregNi
I'm not so sure ... Perspective is really a component of the focal length. As such it is another constant, so doesn't change with sensor size. Perspective effects are things like how flat or deep something appears ... So a face portrait looks good in the range from, say, 70mm through 135m, due to the nice rendering of shape caused by those lengths. Again, none of that changes with sensor size.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Full frame or not ??? at 07/08/2015 - 10:52

McGregNi
Looks like you should stick with Pentax, that's for sure! Great results here ... Superb clarity and action capture. The lens/camera/person combo has really come together beautifully

The first one is unusual ... It really focuses attention on the subject, but the context seems removed .... Have you used a mask -out programme? It looks like our Tiger has been placed in one of those shopping mall instant baby photograph studio set-ups ! (I'm sure its parents would love it :wink

I prefer the others with natural backgrounds ... All nicely rendered with good aperture choice I think. You've picked some strong angles and good moments ... Overall an excellent collection !

One small point for your processing ... They all look rather warm in tone. Perhaps the white balance could be a little cooler, or a small reduction in yellow saturation might help ... Worth a look I think.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Tiger cubs and Polar bears @ YWP at 07/08/2015 - 10:30

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo